5 ms·
Let's not get ahead of ourselves here. Norway don't say yes to socialism they say yes to social welfare in a different way than in the US. So do Denmark (wher
by ThomPete 16y ago
Let's not get ahead of ourselves here.
Norway don't say yes to socialism they say yes to social welfare in a different way than in the US.
So do Denmark (where I am from) and Sweden.
Yes the taxes are higher (up to 60% in Denmark with a progressive tax system) and about the same I believe in Norway.
But it's not like everyone walks around an love it. In fact there is great opposition to the level that taxation have gone to. In Denmark it's an election year and several social welfare benefits plus income tax is being discussed as the main theme.
But all this doesn't really matter cause the US have something that neither of the Scandinavian countries nor any other European nations have.
They have a big ass market and one language.
Europe is a huge market (around +400 Million no?) but most countries (unlike Scandinavia) don't do well with english so there is no unifying factors that allow for the kind of scalable business that can be created in the US (at least not as easily)
There are many problems with the kind of social welfare models and lack of aspiration is actually one of them. People don't try as hard and because they pay high taxes they come to expect A LOT from the government.
I have lived in the US for enough years to know that there are many things that the US should envy from the Scandinavian countries. But the start-up environment is not one of them.
- _corbett 16y agoI concur–the US has a big market and a big advantage culturally in terms of startups. Switzerland has the opposite problem, people are very ambitious, expect to earn a lot of money, and so are unwilling to take the pay cut to go to startups. I have run into many who think creating a successful startup involves having an idea and throwing money at outsourcers to program it. There's so much money thrown around that the idea of a MVP is out the window, a few companies I know have runways of 6+ years.... It's also partly about catching the bug and reaching the critical mass. If you have many friends making amazing things it's hard not to be inspired to try to join in. I don't think the cultural problem is by any means inherent in socialism, but those are just my 50 kroner...
- marvin 16y agoThanks for setting the record straight on this. I'm Norwegian, and this is exactly what I would say about this. There are many things we do in Scandinavia that should be copied in the US, but start-up culture and small business is not helped along by the tax system and social services/benefits. In fact, the progressive taxation alone incentivizes everyone to _not_ earn more than about 100000 USD a year (if you work harder to earn more, taxation is about 45% on the marginal income). There are "official" (state-sponsored) investment companies, but they are incredibly risk-averse and never invest in anything halfway radical. Private financing for computer startups is nonexistent.
- michael_dorfman 16y agoPrivate financing for computer startups is nonexistent. Really? I've never had problem with this. Nor have I felt the tax system has disincentivized my income (which is well into the top bracket.)
- marvin 16y agoWhat sort of startups/work have you been doing? When I'm talking about disincentivizing, I just mean that making the conscious decision of working more seems like a no-brainer. Your personal reasoning behind this may be different, but overall, fewer people will do this if they only get paid for 70-80% of the extra hours than if they get paid for all of them.
- michael_dorfman 16y agoReally? You think there is a linear relationship between tax rates and hours worked? It's never worked that way in my experience, either as an employee or as a founder. As an owner, you don't get paid for hours, full-stop. You get paid for outcomes. I don't know about you, but if the government raised the corporate tax rate by 5%, that would have no bearing on my desire to have my company succeed. The same holds true, ceteris paribus, for my years as an employee. I worked hard (and a lot of hours) because I enjoyed what I was doing, and wanted the company to succeed, even if my income was divorced from the hours worked--as it was, most of the time, as a salaried employee. In other words, I got paid zero percent of the "extra hours", and yet still worked them, gladly, for other reasons. Naturally, YMMV.
- rue 16y ago> In fact, the progressive taxation alone incentivizes everyone to _not_ earn more than about 100000 USD a year […] 100k is a lot. Only people who've seriously lost perspective (or living in areas that have collectively lost perspective and have huge local inflation) think it's not enough. I'm quite happy to pay taxes to support social services. The only thing better would be to equalise incomes so that it wouldn't be necessary…
- Symmetry 16y agoBy most measures Denmark, far from being socialist, actually has a freer economy than the US.
- loewenskind 16y ago>Norway don't say yes to socialism they say yes to social welfare in a different way than in the US. But they do say yes to what most people in the US would call "socialism". When it comes to politics the words the US uses don't match what the rest of the world uses.