9 ms·
Apple Antitrust Probe – Responses to Congress [pdf]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wyldfire 7y ago> Why did Apple decide to build its own maps application rather than continue to use Google Maps to power the maps applications on iPhones? I don't get it: why hassle them over their underdog competitor? Laud them for daring to compete against the market leader. Focus the argument about the walled garden and right-to-repair instead. Apple and Google should license the ability to create third-party app stores, or be compelled to do so. Perhaps that could come with terms on auditing apps and a process for resolving differences of opinion on whether an app is legitimate/safe/acceptable (with a standard like "poses a risk to device or owner's privacy/data").
- riazrizvi 7y agoA fair platform provider would not compete with the businesses on its platform, they would be an unbiased referee. Platform providers are able to snoop on the behavior of their users, unlike any other businesses. So they have an unfair advantage when they compete. If we continue to allow platform providers to publish products on their own platforms we are moving away from fair market competition. Business platforms, like investment exchanges, should be regulated.
- zepto 7y agoSo Apple should develop the OS with no experience at all of developing applications? That simply won’t work.
- izacus 7y ago> I don't get it: why hassle them over their underdog competitor? Laud them for daring to compete against the market leader. Focus the argument about the walled garden and right-to-repair instead. Because they gave themselves an edge when competing against Google by not allowing Maps all of the same capabilities from start. And to do that, they abused their OS and store to block GMaps from having same capabilities as AMaps. Even today, GMaps isn't allowed to be the default maps provider. No customer wishing for a healthy free market should approve of this.
- scarface74 7y agoThat’s not what happened. Google didn’t allow Apple to use turn by turn directions without Apple giving Google more telemetry from its users.
- greggman2 7y agoBut now Apple is disadvantages competing maps apps by making all maps links open in Apple Maps. It sucks. As a Google Maps user I have tons of labels and bookmarks in Google Maps. When I click a maps link in any iOS app I get shuffled over to Apple Maps and then have to try to find a way to manually copy the address over to Google Maps so I can add a bookmark and access it in other places.
- thu2111 7y agoThat's also not what happened. I was on the Google Maps team at the time and the issues were far deeper and more problematic than "not getting telemetry" which was at any rate, not an issue - what sort of "telemetry" do you think a Maps app could report that isn't search queries or tile requests? Maps apps are just rendering frontends for giant server farms after all. Claiming it's about telemetry is just Apple propaganda. The real problem was that Apple wrote the Google Maps app, and wasn't willing to cooperate with Google on it at all. Literally, they demanded some basic protocol specs and then wrote the app themselves. This led to several problems: 1. They refused to tell Google what changes they were making to their app, which led to: 2. Repeatedly screwing up their implementation in ways that very seriously threatened the stability of the entire Google Maps services (think: slamming the servers with way more traffic than any reasonable implementation should). Apple love to claim the best results arise from integrating hardware, software and services. Well, guess what, that logic works in both directions: by preventing even basic cooperation between the Apple team writing the GMaps app, and the rest of the GMaps team, they created massive problems. Especially because at this time Apple engineering had no serious experience with large online services ... MobileMe was a disaster ... and so they kept making basic mistakes no Google team would ever make. They also refused Google's help to stop making them. 3. The GMaps team was much larger and better funded than the iOS team, so iOS rapidly fell behind the featureset available on Android and the web. Google attempted to fix this by writing their own GMaps app, which Apple then blocked on the grounds it was competitive with their own (this was back when they had this policy). Basically the relationship was antagonistic from the start from Apple's side, and rapidly spiralled downhill as Google's own services accelerated away from what Apple was capable of. The whole Apple schtick that Google was desperate to violate privacy or get telemetry is just an advertising attack angle: it shouldn't work on the sort of people who read Hacker News. Apple Maps is architecturally identical to Google Maps, after all.
- pkaye 7y ago> Apple and Google should license the ability to create third-party app stores... I though Google already allows third-party app stores?
- kcolford 7y agoYes, but they can't auto update without root. A feature that's virtually essential when you're managing a ton of apps.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- x2f10 7y ago#7 is a little off IMO. Perhaps Apple does not earn revenue from the app itself, but it still earns revenue from the developer in the form of Dev License(s).
- rstupek 7y ago$99/year is not even a rounding error on their balance sheet though
- mertnesvat 7y agoBut in the latest WWDC they announced they have 20 million licensed developer, 20.000.000 x 99 = 1.980.000.000 license fee. ref : https://techcrunch.com/2018/06/04/app-store-hits-20m-registered-developers-at-100b-in-revenues-500m-visitors-per-week/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/06/04/app-store-hits-20m-registe...
- xuki 7y agoAnyone can register an account on developer.apple.com, for free. I doubt there are 20 mil paid accounts for the developer portal.
- favorited 7y ago> For each year since 2009, the costs of providing repair services has exceeded the revenue generated by repairs. Huh, that one kinda surprised me.
- benologist 7y ago2009 - 2012 would be the period where nVidia had badly-soldered GPUs affecting everyone's laptops, this was an expensive repair period for many manufacturers. Air bubbles in the solder would eventually disrupt the electrical flow, I think it was just the one year of devices but a year or so passed before anyone was affected. https://codingfreak.blogspot.com/2009/04/beware-of-nvidia-graphic-cards-in.html https://codingfreak.blogspot.com/2009/04/beware-of-nvidia-gr... Then in 2013 Apple started soldering/joining everything which made all the repairs more expensive. Then in 2016 Apple had to start paying for the artificially expensive repairs themselves because of the butterfly keyboard fiasco, popping speakers, broken display cables etc. They probably really have lost money but they don't mention it's their own fault and at this point it's really just tied to the free keyboard replacement program which ends in 1 - 2 years for the worst-affected models.
- slantyyz 7y agoIt wasn't just Nvidia GPUs. The early 2011 MBP failures all had ATI GPUs.
- x2f10 7y agoDo their "costs" include warranty repairs?
- alexis_fr 7y agoDo their “costs” include overpriced parts destined to move money offshore? For example in the film industry, it is common to promise actors a share of benefits, then create a subsidiary for the movie, charge it insane amounts for the producing company’s services (brand, distribution), so that the movie may be a loss even if its revenue is 3 times the production costs. Of course the head company deserves to be paid, but discussing how much a service or a part is worth, beyond its marginal manufacturing price, is the whole question.
- Isamu 7y agoInteresting that it starts off with the advantages Apple gives Safari, as similar browser issues were a focus of the antitrust proceedings against Microsoft.
- Jtsummers 7y agoIn Microsoft's case, the free and privileged position of IE was specifically chosen to prevent the success of a competitor (Netscape) whose product created the potential for cross-platform applications (enterprise, early web applications). IE deliberately implemented some things counter to the specifications in order to be incompatible with the spec (and thus spec-conformant browsers) forcing developers to select their target platform. IE's substantial market position meant that more people supported it (thus all the sites that were IE-only, and some still are because banks and governments suck at IT). MS spent hundreds of millions (if not over a billion, it's been a while since I read the reports on the subject) to give away a product that would cripple a competitor's position. Netscape, though, wasn't the only target of MS's action. By doing this, they helped ensure Windows dominance would continue. Enterprises considering, or using, other operating systems but wanting to advance the state of their IT systems (that is, adopting web-based solutions) would find themselves in the same conundrum. Implement to the standards and use any OS, or implement to IE and support one OS that was already dominant within the corporation. This worked to effectively reduce the potential market position (in businesses and for consumers) of alternate OSes to Windows. Of course, that's not the only thing MS did. The full report of the anti-trust case was pretty interesting. There were many things MS did beyond just the browser. They favored OEMs who exclusively sold Windows-based computers with lower OEM pricing, but if they attempted to use another OS then they were threatened with increased licensing costs (this was a large part of what killed BeOS's momentum). While many people remember and focus on the browser, it was only one piece of the whole case. To draw a comparison, you'd need to demonstrate that Apple's Safari-only (or really Safari + limited WebKit-only) policy is taking advantage of its substantial market share (currently iOS is sitting at something like 55-57% market share in the US, so it isn't actually that substantial a lead) to harm its competitors. And you'd have to place that in the context of other abuses of market share position.
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- modeless 7y ago> users have many alternative third-party browsers they can download from the App Store. This answer is misleading at best, bordering on lying. I define "browser" as inclusive of the engine used to render web pages.
- aylmao 7y ago+1. They bend this definition so much. When it comes to uninstalling, they're talking about the engine, calling it a "core part of iOS". When it comes to browsers, then yeah, the shell around the engine IS the browser.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- capableweb 7y agoI had the same reaction! And the ones asking the question, seems to already have known the answer, because there is a more fleshed out question and answer later in the document (question 4).
- henryfjordan 7y agoTo Apple's credit, they do talk about Webkit being the only engine a few questions later.
- modeless 7y agoOnly when forced in response to some very pointed questions. That doesn't make the first answer true if you understand that the engine is a vital part of a web browser and a source of competitive advantage.
- mcphage 7y ago> Only when forced to in response to some very pointed questions. They weren't asked these questions one at a time.
- 7y ago
- Isamu 7y agoInteresting non-answer: >29. For each year since 2009, what is the total amount that Apple has accepted from Google for the right to be the default search engine in Safari and in any other Apple products or services? Please identify the amount accepted from Google in total and broken down by each Apple product. >Apple’s search agreement with Google generates revenue based on referral traffic through the URL/search box on Apple’s Safari browser. Although Google search is set as the default, this can be changed in settings on iPhone to another search engine, such as Yahoo!, Microsoft Bing and DuckDuckGo. Consumers may also conduct searches on search apps available through the App Store, searches performed on the web (through the search engine’s web portal), or through virtual assistants like Siri, Cortana or Alexa that are available to users on our platform.
- ikeboy 7y agoIt's possible they gave different answers privately and requested for exact numbers not to be released publicly. Seems likely based on reading Amazon's reply to the same committee, which also didn't give specific numbers to some questions requesting specifics.
- gowld 7y agoThat would be fine as far as it goes, but stuffing unrelated information in the answer is weasely.
- nemothekid 7y agoI'd imagine there's some complicated SEC-related reason why they can't provide specific numbers w.r.t revenue
- sparkywolf 7y agoHow can they so blatantly not answer the question even a little and get away with it?
- cmcd 7y agoThey sort of do answer the question, they aren't accepting money from Google for the right to be the default search engine. They are accepting a portion of search revenue for searches made through Google via Safari. This incentivises them to make Google the homepage even if it is not an explicit requirement of the deal. Definitely a sneaky way to do it but it could be completely true.
- saagarjha 7y ago> iPhone users cannot set another browser as the default browser. Safari is one of the apps that Apple believes defines the core user experience on iOS, with industry-leading security and privacy features. As noted in response to Question 1, Safari is an “operating system app,” like the Phone, Camera and iMessage, which are designed to work together. The third sentence does not follow from the first two, and does not answer the question. > For each year since 2009, what is the total amount that Apple has accepted from Google for the right to be the default search engine in Safari and in any other Apple products or services? Please identify the amount accepted from Google in total and broken down by each Apple product. > Apple’s search agreement with Google generates revenue based on referral traffic through the URL/search box on Apple’s Safari browser. Although Google search is set as the default, this can be changed in settings on iPhone to another search engine, such as Yahoo!, Microsoft Bing and DuckDuckGo. Consumers may also conduct searches on search apps available through the App Store, searches performed on the web (through the search engine’s web portal), or through virtual assistants like Siri, Cortana or Alexa that are available to users on our platform. I like how Apple answered exactly zero parts of this question :/
- dhagz 7y agoOf course: they are trying to set the narrative on this. They are trying to make the argument that Safari is like the other "operating system apps" that they don't allow you to change. I don't like that they're doing it, but it's less about answering the questions and more about framing it as though they aren't engaging in anti-competitive practices.
- nulbyte 7y ago> Safari is one of the apps that Apple believes defines the core user experience on iOS... Is this not the same argument Microsoft made about Internet Explorer?
- alexis_fr 7y agoWell, I’d answer so much yes, but if we condemn them to the same penalty as Microsoft, it’s gonna be 0.00. Penalties were dropped I think in the wake of September 11, 2001.
- aylmao 7y ago> WebKit is an open-source web engine that allows Apple to enable improvements contributed by third parties. Instead of having to supply an entirely separate browser engine (with the significant privacy and security issues this creates), third parties can contribute relevant changes to the WebKit project for incorporation into the WebKit engine. All other big browser engines are open-source too, but let's not mention that bit.
- lallysingh 7y agoNo employee non-compete? I'm surprised.
- meepX2 7y agoNon-compete is illegal in California.
- saagarjha 7y agoWell, non-enforceable.
- lmkg 7y agoIt's a relevant distinction. You're still allowed to put non-compete clauses into your contracts, even though they don't do anything. Many companies put such clauses in their contracts, either because they have a nation-wide template, or because the threat of litigation is valuable to them.
- aylmao 7y agotldr; Apple does everything it does in the name of Privacy and Security, because users can only trust Apple and everything that's not Apple is a potential vector of attack.
- rgovostes 7y agoApple's answers repeatedly suggest that the reason they require third-party browsers to use WebKit and JavaScriptCore is for privacy and security: > It is not our experience that competing web browsers have typically offered enhanced privacy or security that would protect users as adequately as our WebKit protections. Google pioneered the out-of-process architecture that Safari now uses, developed the Safe Browsing program that Safari also uses, drove the adoption of HTTPS, put pressure on misbehaving certificate authorities and shepherded certificate pinning and then Certificate Transparency, and found many vulnerabilities in WebKit through security research that Apple was not itself doing. Moreover, on the desktop, Chrome and Firefox both have automatic update channels that allow them to push out security fixes much more rapidly than Apple's heavy OS updates. (On iOS, they would be limited by Apple's App Store approval process.) All this to say, I'm skeptical of the suggestion that a Blink-powered Chrome for iOS would not "protect users as adequately as our WebKit protections." One thing to note: JavaScriptCore has special powers on iOS in that it can allocate new blocks of executable memory during just-in-time compilation, greatly improving its performance. A third-party JavaScript engine would be much slower without this ability, but granting the capability to third-party engines would jeopardize the security architecture of iOS.
- saagarjha 7y agoI'm fairly sure Apple's security spin comes exclusively from the fact that apps on the App Store cannot dynamically allocate executable memory.
- TacticalTable 7y agoApple seems to have given non-answers, or entirely avoided, several questions on here. Is this par for the course on probes, was information redacted, or are there going to be consequences for Apple here?
- ikeboy 7y agoCompare to Amazon's at https://docs.house.gov/meetings/JU/JU05/20190716/109793/HHRG-116-JU05-20190716-SD038.pdf https://docs.house.gov/meetings/JU/JU05/20190716/109793/HHRG... My guess is for questions asking for a specific number and that wasn't given, the details were submitted privately, but the ones that are just spinning an answer did not have private submissions.
- lmkg 7y agoTo my knowledge, this is Congress asking questions, not sending a subpeona. Participation at this stage is still voluntary, and mostly consists of political posturing. If Congress wishes to pursue it, they have legal tools where cooperation is non-optional. The current conversation is part of the song-and-dance where Apple tries to avoid that by offering something resembling cooperation, but on their own terms. Many of the questions are meant to answer the question "if we conduct a probe for realsies, who will be the winner?" rather than the question-as-asked.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- shmerl 7y agoApple should be punished for their nasty monopolistic behavior with banning competing browsers. MS didn't get away with doing even less than that in the past, so Apple for sure shouldn't either. They were running amok with this garbage for too long. By banning competing browsers, Apple also has leverage on broader adoption of JavaScript features and related technologies which they oppose. For example they refuse to implement Media Source Extensions, which allows them to sabotage wider usage of DASH, because they are pushing their own HLS. If that's not an anti-competitive behavior punishable by anti-trust, what is?
- mmastrac 7y agoThis is incorrect [1] - they block questions on independent repair from Apple forums. > Does Apple take any actions to block consumers from seeking out or using repair shops that offer a broader range of repairs than those offered by authorized technicians? If yes, describe each action that Apple takes and the reason for doing so. Apple does not take any actions to block consumers from seeking out or using repair shops that offer a broader range of repairs than those offered by Apple’s authorized technicians. Customers are free to obtain repairs from any repair shop of their choice. [1] https://www.cultofmac.com/620124/apple-support-forum-jessa-jones/ https://www.cultofmac.com/620124/apple-support-forum-jessa-j...
- reaperducer 7y agoJust a couple of months ago I called Apple to get my 2012 MacBook Air repaired. Apple wouldn't touch it because of its age, but gave me a list of independent repair shops in my area that would fix it. If Apple blocks people from getting independent repairs, when why are there Apple authorized repair third-party repair shops?
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoDid you read the link in the comment you're replying to?
- burtonator 7y agoI'm currently dealing with the insanity of thinking about deploying my app on the app store. The biggest challenge I have is the fact that I can't put a PWA (progress web app) in the app store. Google allows you to do it in the play store. They even have a library (trusted web application) that you can use to bridge your web app to an android app and distribute it into the app store. I DO appreciate that there are technical reasons why Apple and users would find this less than ideal but this is 90% due to apple being non-competitive. I could even understand and have sympathy for Apple had a way to side-load 3rd party apps. ... but you can't even do that. Users have NO control over their phone and Apple has completely locked down the ecosystem. They need to be broken up...
- zepto 7y agoWhy? People can just buy Android.
- vineyardmike 7y agoDon't really wanna bite, but you got me. How would you even break up apple?
- sebsito 7y agoApple's closed and exclusive ecosystem is a product in itself. As long as users can choose different computers (PCs) and phones (Android) there is no monopoly problem.
- sneak 7y agoYou’re right about the first. The argument can be made for the second, but many reasonable people disagree about bundling/preferential treatment being anticompetitive.
- PeterStuer 7y agoIt is interesting to see Apple use the exact same line of defense that Microsoft did with IE back in the day: the browser is an integral part of the OS (leading to the infamous 'Ham Sandwich' quote [1]). Note also that Microsoft did allow full-stack competing browsers, whereas Apple does not. [1] http://community.seattletimes.nwsource.com/archive/?date=19980419&slug=2746018 http://community.seattletimes.nwsource.com/archive/?date=199...
- thu2111 7y agoI have to say I'm quite impressed by the quality and precision of the questions in this document. Who in Congress wrote this questionnaire?
- sneak 7y agoAs someone with a business idea that is DOA on mobile without a browser extension (or ability to change OS default https handler to an extension-supporting browser), I really hope something comes of this.