4 ms·
'at best' is an incomplete picture. Redistributing wealth is zero or negative-sum, yes, but utility is not linear in wealth. It's logarithmic or less (wealth di
by gwern 16y ago
'at best' is an incomplete picture. Redistributing wealth is zero or negative-sum, yes, but utility is not linear in wealth. It's logarithmic or less (wealth diminishing marginal utility).
To be opposed to redistribution despite the obvious fact that it would create utility, one has to bring in additional concepts. For example, one might take some sort of ethical stand on redistribution being Pareto-inefficient. Or one might argue that the additional growth from inequality will eventually outweigh the disutility of respecting wealth inequality. (Either of these might not apply during depressed economic periods.)