4 ms·
I'd suggest not viewing karma as the reward, but rather your influence. Ad-hominem attacks and downvotes are typically a response to cognitive dissonance - your
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
I'd suggest not viewing karma as the reward, but rather your influence. Ad-hominem attacks and downvotes are typically a response to cognitive dissonance - your argument or facts forced someone to rethink views they are emotionally attached to, and they don't like it.
You received at least 3 upvotes, and earl received 4. (Actually, most likely you both received a mix of both upvotes and downvotes.) Since I seriously doubt that those are coming from the same people, you influenced 7 people in some way. You made 4 people uncomfortable about their views, but they were unable to rationally respond. That pushes them a little closer to changing their views.
Well done.
- asinination 16y agobut they were unable to rationally respond There is an exceptionally large gap between not being able to respond, and not thinking it's a good use of one's time. My experience is that expressing contrary opinions on HN, even well-reasoned and considered ones, is a recipe for getting [dead]'d. As such, many wise people don't bother.
- nika 16y agoThanks to you and "TheAmazingIdiot" (ugh, his name makes me call him a name, the delima!) for the feedback. I'm going to try sticking around a bit.