3 ms·
I find Sam Harris' Waking Up guided meditation lessons the most useful (can find it on mobile app stores, the 30+ lessons are free and start off short and simpl
by hombre_fatal 7y ago
I find Sam Harris' Waking Up guided meditation lessons the most useful (can find it on mobile app stores, the 30+ lessons are free and start off short and simple).
Until those, I thought meditation was inherently coupled with eastern mystic bullshit with zero benefits for anyone who didn't want to buy into a bunch of other baggage.
He has a book by the same name as the mobile app. The first chapter (read out loud here) is what first started convincing me that mindfulness was something I should seek out and develop: https://samharris.org/podcasts/chapter-one/ https://samharris.org/podcasts/chapter-one/
I started doing it while laying in bed before falling asleep. Ended up with a daily morning practice sitting up on my bench.
- fellow_human 7y agoInteresting that other cultural practices are dismissed as mystic bullshit by default, until a white man introduces it. That makes it more trustworthy other white people.
- psv1 7y agoThis is has nothing to do with "cultural practices" or the skin color of whoever introduced it. It's more about answering the question "Is the evidence in favor of this practice strong enough to try it for a while?".
- eeZah7Ux 7y agoWhitewhashing indeed. But harris is not just a random white guy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sam_Harris#Reception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sam_Harris#Reception
- henryaj 7y agoNo, the 'mystic bullshit' is very real in e.g. vipassana (for example, anything about "vibrations") regardless of the race of the speaker
- dr_dshiv 7y agoWhy are vibrations associated with mystic bullshit? I've noticed this too, but I don't understand.
- collyw 7y agoThe positive effects (for most people) are also very real as well, in spite of the "mystic bullshit".
- wdrw 7y agoThere's definitely 'mystic bullshit' in Vipassana, but it's not the 'vibrations' part (the Vipassana course emphasizes over and over again that the sensations you're supposed to watch for are real, physical sensations - pressure on the skin, temperature, sweat, itching - nothing mystical)
- nothis 7y agoWow. Rest assured, I still consider these cultural practices mystic bullshit.
- fellow_human 7y agoWhat cultural practices are you referring to? Every non-white cultural practice? That would be proving my point. I never stated there was value in every non-western cultural practice, only that the value that actually does exists is easy to dismiss away as "superstitious beliefs" (or mystic bullshit) until one of the "in-group" convinces us otherwise. No doubt, it's a good thing science now backs up meditative benefits to an individual, but it shows a certain level of arrogance if everyones culture is bullshit or backwards until [insert popular science guy] has confirmed otherwise.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoWell, in my OP that you responded to, I used "eastern mystic bullshit" to explain where I was coming from and why I initially rejected meditation. It was always only something I'd hear brought up from a dread-locked vagabonding white guy with a mandala tattoo on his chest and the desperate need for deodorant. Sam Harris makes the case that you can save the baby (mindfulness) from the bathwater (superstition, etc.) and that these practices were onto something because we share a common human experience. Why not listen to his first chapter that I linked? I can almost guarantee that you would agree with him. You are just having a knee-jerk reaction to what you think is going on. Harris covers the exact things you think you're trying to point out. Also, let's drop the skin-color bullshit. I reject all religion and superstition the same way I reject astrology, which is why I need a rationalist approach to have my mind re-opened to some of these ideas like mindfulness which are almost always couched in superstition. Sam Harris is precisely trying to do this and he starts that chapter making the case for it to people like me who immediately cringe at a loaded word "spirituality".
- fellow_human 7y agoFair enough, I did probably knee jerk or interpret things in the wrong way. Will give it a go perhaps. I'm currently using the headspace app which I suspect is a similar approach.
- Timpy 7y agoI think Harris's perspective is more like, "There's some good stuff here if you ignore the mystic bullshit." That's my take on it, and the message I get behind. I don't care if the person who introduced it happens to be an ethnically Jewish man. Incidentally I have the same take on Western religions, especially the one that I grew up with. I enjoy and appreciate practices from foreign cultures, the "foreign-culture-ness" of something does not lead me to dismiss it. The mystic bullshit part is what I dismiss, in every culture (especially my own).
- ipnon 7y agoUntil neuroscientists began researching meditation, the practice was coupled with various Asian cultural practices and beliefs, some from ancient times. It is reasonable to be doubtful of the efficacy of meditation when the evidence is effectively socio-cultural. Sam Harris is a neuroscientist, so he has scientific credibility when he promotes meditation as a beneficial practice.