3 ms·
From my understanding, that is incorrect. As more stuff approaches "original" event horizon, the mass of the black hole + mass of stuff near the horizon grows,
by lostmsu 7y ago
From my understanding, that is incorrect. As more stuff approaches "original" event horizon, the mass of the black hole + mass of stuff near the horizon grows, which extends the horizon outwards, effectively consuming stuff, that got close to it.
- lostmsu 7y agoHopefully better explanation: Imagine a black hole with mass M and radius R. Let's assume to have radius R+1m, a black hole has to be of mass M+1kg. Any falling matter trying to approach R will cross R+1m in finite time. At some moment 1kg of matter will cross R+1m. At this moment, that 1kg will effectively be inside the horizon.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- millstone 7y ago"Effectively inside the horizon" isn't a good way to think about GR. Observers have reference frames, and can only observe according to their own clocks and rulers. If you (a distant observer) watched your blinking probe approach a black hole, you would see its blinks slow and red shift as the probe approaches the horizon. You cannot see it enter the horizon, as light cannot escape from inside the horizon. There would be a last blink, as the red shift approaches infinity. If the event horizon were to increase in radius, the effect would be to further slow and red shift the blinks.
- lostmsu 7y agoCan't you claim, that if probe reached R+0.5m (which you could potentially see), and then subsequently BH grew to R+1m, that probe's last blink happened in the area, that later became BH?
- perl4ever 7y agoOk, but what if you take the limit as +1 -> 0?
- lostmsu 7y agoI think you are about to enter /the twilight zone/quantum gravity/.
- mjfl 7y agoYou might be right, but I would need to be further convinced because you could argue that as the event horizon continuously extends towards the particle, the particle slows down, slowing the extention of the event horizon. I'd need to see, with math, that indeed the particle does go past the event horizon in finite time, from the reference frame of an observer outside the black hole.