12 ms·
This is how capitalism works. As oil's price rises, the expected return to investing in alternatives increases. That's what drives research ultimately, not "bli
by barrkel 16y ago
This is how capitalism works. As oil's price rises, the expected return to investing in alternatives increases. That's what drives research ultimately, not "blindfolds". If you think oil is running out faster than its price warrants (ie you think serious work on alternatives isn't being done), you're free to buy oil futures, since it seems you think oil doesn't have its future scarcity priced in sufficiently today.
- _delirium 16y ago> you're free to buy oil futures If you think oil's near-term value is mispriced, then oil futures are a solution, yes. But oil futures basically don't trade past the 5-year contract, and contracts longer than 10 years don't even exist. So if you think oil is mispriced in the 20-year timeframe, oil futures don't do you any good. There seems to be a persistent misbelief that futures markets are a way of hedging or speculating on long-term price movements, but they're really a way of hedging or speculating on short-term price movements, e.g. for airlines to hedge against near-term supply shocks. By far the largest volume is for less-than-a-year contracts, and there is virtually nothing out past 5 years, so they're not really useful or intended for long-term planning.
- barrkel 16y agoYou don't need to go with a standard contract if you really believe this, though; you could go with forward contracts, or - ultimately - by stockpiling oil.
- yason 16y agoI do think that oil doesn't have its future scarcity sufficiently priced in today's numbers because for most people and especially oil companies and oil-based economies it would be too scary to think about it. The root of the problem itself is not at all related to capitalism or other economic models. Capitalist countries are no better off with regard to this than other economies. The problem is related to the fact that in the coming decades the energy needed to pump a barrel of oil will increase, up until the threshold in the far future where it costs a barrel of oil to pump a barrel of oil. And because modern economies are based on the availability of cheap oil, this change will transform or shatter these economies. It's an universal cost. If it's not about the price of pumping and buying oil in dollars, it will be the time, effort, and availability of oil. Like you said, serious work on alternatives is only as serious as dictated by the lack of availability of cheap oil. I call exactly that wearing blindfolds because it is about betting entires nations on the possibility that we'll find an alternative energy store or energy source, in time, that allows us to maintain roughly today's standard of living. I would like to see it happen, too, but from the viewpoint of a contemporary man we'll be just totally and ultimately screwed if it doesn't. What I suggested is that we should take this into account already and not after 50 years when it might not be possible to do really serious work on alternatives. It's really about taking the hit slowly and adaptively or getting it slammed on your face at once.
- khafra 16y agoBuying oil futures does not help, because cheap oil is a fundamental part of the economy. As we already found out, when oil reaches a certain price, it stops rising because of demand destruction. Instead of paying more, industries dependent on it simply shut down. The only way to bet on peak oil, at this point, is bet against the economy as a whole--and that exposes you to huge counterparty and currency risks.