3 ms·
The wikipedia article you linked doesn't actually reference any supposed solar furnaces capable of reaching or exceeding 1000 celsius. Even the project linked i
by gamblor956 7y ago
The wikipedia article you linked doesn't actually reference any supposed solar furnaces capable of reaching or exceeding 1000 celsius. Even the project linked in the 1000 celsius bullet point states it only reaches approximately 500 celsius on its own wikipedia page (and at the project's own website).
Note, importantly, as with all things scale matters. There are solar furnaces the size of a pot that have reached 3000 celsius or more. This is not very useful for industrial scale activities.
Presumably one of the breakthroughs is that Heliogen can achieve 1000 celsius at an industrial scale which is not something that appears to have been done before with purely solar energy.
- kragen 7y ago> The wikipedia[sic] article you linked doesn't actually reference any supposed[sic] solar furnaces capable of reaching or exceeding 1000 celsius[sic]. It does; it references the one at Odeillo, which exceeds 3000°, according to this open-access paper by one of its instigators: https://journals.openedition.org/histoire-cnrs/2661 https://journals.openedition.org/histoire-cnrs/2661 This "supposed solar furnace", as you term it, finished construction in 1969 and receives 75,000 visitors per year. > Presumably one of the breakthroughs is that Heliogen can achieve 1000 celsius[sic] at an industrial scale which is not something that appears to have been done before with purely solar energy. The question of "scale" is essentially one of power — the press release explains that you can expect about one megawatt per acre (250 MW/km² in modern units), and contemplates that you might want to build plants that scale up to two megawatts. To me, that sounds pretty small for industrial scale, but the Odeillo solar furnace is already one megawatt. Why power rather than volume? Well, you can heat an arbitrarily large or small thing to an arbitrarily high temperature with an arbitrarily large or small amount of power if it's well enough insulated, and modern insulation is very good. But if your heating doesn't have enough power, it will be very slow on a large amount of material, and if it's fighting things like endothermic chemical reactions, it may lose. Heliogen's press release explains that their pilot plant has 400 mirrors on two acres, so it's probably about two megawatts — twice the size of the 3500° Odeillo, but much lower temperature, and a tiny fraction of the size of existing commercial CSP plants, which run around 600° as explained earlier.
- gamblor956 7y agoI think you're ignoring a key point of Heliogen's design function. Heliogen is designed to be used directly as the furnace in industrial applications for making steel, cement, etc. The Odeillo solar furnace can reach higher temperatures but can't transmit them--it can only heat steam, which is a poor transmitter of heat energy to industrial materials. Ideally, both of these designs would be incorporated together--one to drive the machinery (the Odeillo design) and the other to do the actual physical work of heating the materials (the Heliogen design).
- kragen 7y agoThere's nothing to suggest that Heliogen's design is in any way particularly suitable for transmitting heat to somewhere else or for putting a cement kiln or blast furnace at the focus of the mirrors. On the contrary, their pilot plant sites the focus at the top of a tall tower, like many existing CSP power plants, which is a particularly inconvenient place to put a cement kiln, though not unheard of. For driving machinery you probably want lower temperatures, like the 600° existing coal, nuclear, and CSP power plants use for driving machinery. Coal and nuclear plants could easily generate higher temperatures, but there are a variety of practical difficulties that arise.