5 ms·
Agreed! I've been running my own mail server for 20+ years, and I would not recommend that anybody do this on a lark. Deliverability to GMail is a huge problem
by wpietri 7y ago
Agreed! I've been running my own mail server for 20+ years, and I would not recommend that anybody do this on a lark. Deliverability to GMail is a huge problem for me and has been for years. I even asked friends at Google to find out what the story was. All I got back is that the mail group was so careful/paranoid it wouldn't talk to them either.
I would long ago have switched over to a vendor, but I use qmail-style tagging for sub-addresses (that is, instead of user+sub@domain, I use user-sub@domain). Almost nobody supports that. Especially not GMail (where my friends could tell me that was tagged as WONTFIX).
If anybody has solved this, please do let me know (on here, via Twitter, or the email address in my bio). It's maddening.
- mgalgs 7y agoCurious why you're so attached to the qmail style subaddressing. Personal preference or is there a technical advantage?
- big_chungus 7y agoPossibly not getting blocked. Many sign-up fields will block foo+spam@bar.net if I try to use it.
- 77pt77 7y agoThat's why I use "." as the separator. Now try using an email from a domain name with more that 3 letters in the TLD. Almost no one considers that a valid address.
- zigzaggy 7y agoSo if I bought my “name.rocks” I’ll have trouble using that as an email? I was looking forward to “firstname@lastname.rocks” and I never even considered it would be a problem. I’m disappointed
- voltagex_ 7y agoI have something similar - I haven't had many problems with the not being accepted online. The few times I've had issues are with old point-of-sales or appointment booking systems.
- wcip 7y agoI have a .help domain for handing out to services and it works without issue.
- 77pt77 7y agoYes. I'd say way more than half of sites won't accept that as a valid email. And you'll be flagged for fraud as well. It's very frustrating.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dewey 7y agoI've ran into this issue maybe twice in years and I'm always using that for websites. I'm having a feeling that issue is a bit overblown.
- yabadabadoes 7y agoI just add . in arbitrary places to distinguish sources. Since there's no telling what dots a gmail user thinks are a significant part of their address.. (plus I have seen fail and late enough to be a pain, but due to http parameter escaping, etc, rather than intentional fitering.)
- jethro_tell 7y agoProbably because s/he has those addresses out there in the wild starting from a time that it was still reasonable to run an email server, so like 10+ years and probably a bit more.
- bdamm 7y agoThat's exactly the case for me, but I've been handing out these addresses for nearly 20 years. I also suffer from the problems with gmail that the GP referred to. I can't even forward all my email to myself without having it dumped into gmail's trashbin!
- wpietri 7y agoI've given out hundreds and hundreds of them. Almost any time I fill in an email address on a form, I'll tag it so I know where spammers and other miscreants get their addresses from. As have a number of friends I host mail for. Swapping to a mail provider that doesn't support them would be a giant pain for all concerned.
- colonwqbang 7y agoI don't see why sub-addresses would be a problem with regards to sending mail. Isn't it wholly up to the receiver to interpret the username part of the address (or not)?
- wpietri 7y agoIt's not. It's a problem for me just paying somebody to host my mail entirely, as most vendors don't support it.
- BenjiWiebe 7y agoFunny. I'm somewhat new to the game but my email server has had very few problems delivering anywhere (hosting a small business' email, and personal email for the employees.) I've got spf, dkim, and dmarc. I use tls on everything. Got a static ip (linode) with rdns. I've never had a problem delivering to gmail. For a while i had problems delivering to Hotmail/outlook, but participating in some sort of junk mail reporting program (JMRP i think it was) fixed that issue. Now, if i have deliverability problems, it's cause something broke, or my tls cert expired, or i added a new ip that the email server decided to start using. (Sorry for formatting, on mobile)
- slenk 7y agoSounds like you have the same setup I have. I never get bounces from Google. And after the first day or two of removing yourself from 2 or 3 blacklists, its great. I use mailcow FWIW
- Aaronstotle 7y agoWhich mailserver are you using? I'd love to try hosting my own email.
- berkes 7y agoI would advice to try with mailinabox.email . It is very opinionated, which, for a beginner, is a good thing with mail. I'd encourage everyone to try this on a tiny droplet or linode with an unimportant domain (don't just migrate your entire companies' exchange into it on a Friday afternoon). It takes you an hour tops, after which you can poke around and see all the moving parts that make a good mailserver tick. You'll also be contributing to a stronger, more resilient internet, by making it a tiny bit more decentralized.
- thiagoeh 7y agoWhere your IP came from? More specifically, who is the IP block owner? Ana ISP? A cloud provider, like AWS?
- TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
- darkpicnic 7y agoFastmail allows this, if I’m understanding your need correctly. I’ve been using it for years.
- rytis 7y agoYou mean you can send emails to <user>-<tag>@<domain> and it'll be delivered to <user>@<domain> account (assuming MX for <domain> is pointing at fastmail)? Is there anything you need to enable to allow this? I just tried, and the email got bounced back. Or are you talking about email aliases? As in, you register <user>-<tag>@<domain> first before sending emails to that address?
- wpietri 7y agoThis is true! But when I last talked with them, I couldn't figure out a disaster recovery plan. They had no way for me to back up my users' mail aside from IMAP syncing. Which means I'd have to know my users' passwords. Which seemed slightly more ridiculous than just continuing to host my own mail.
- brongondwana 7y agoTwo options: 1. share everyone's mailboxes to an admin user who does the backup via IMAP. 2. create an app-password for each user which can be used to backup that user. This can be done as an admin user on your account. Neither of them require knowing the user's password - an admin can override into each account unless it's specifically locked down to deny that. It does require a separate app password per account, we don't have a way to create a single password which can view each user's account without them explicitly sharing the folders, but I'm not sure how you reasonably do anything else without it being a backdoor behind all the privacy settings on each account.
- wpietri 7y agoAh, interesting! Yes, I'd be fine with either of those. Right now I'm just backing up via rsync of the maildir tree, so it's not like these are any worse. I just didn't want to a) know my user's passwords, and b) have to have them give it to me any time they changed it. Thanks for the tip. Maybe my Christmas present to myself will be to murder my mailserver!
- JonathonW 7y agoYahoo's disposable addresses are constructed in that form (basename-keyword@yahoo.com), but I'm not sure if they support them on business/custom domain accounts. (The base name also has to be different from your real email address, but that's a fairly desirable feature for disposable addresses since it doesn't reveal the real address like the '+' suffix on Gmail does.)
- berkes 7y agoJust to be clear: the plus(+) thing is not a gmail thing, it's part of the RFC for mail-addressing. A standard.
- pera 7y agoI don't have any problems with Gmail, but there is no way to know why :) As far as I know the most important factor for deliverability is your IP address: my /24 have been clean for many years because the network operator actually respond to abuse@ reports. If you have problems my first advice (aside from checking that SPF+DKIM+DMARC+PTR+banner+etc... are OK) would be to find a better ISP.
- wpietri 7y agoThis is a physical server (at Datacate [1] in Santa Clara), so switching ISPs is not a small undertaking, especially given that I'm only using 1U of space. Last I looked the netblock reputation seemed fine, so I'd only be inclined to switch if I had clear evidence that was the real problem. [1] in this block if it matters: https://rdap.arin.net/registry/ip/198.167.232.0 https://rdap.arin.net/registry/ip/198.167.232.0
- bluedino 7y agoThat is such an overblown issue unless you're coming from a spammer network or trying to use something like a VPS to send mail.
- mxab 7y agoCheck out uberspace.de. They are great and use qmail.
- wpietri 7y agoFor what it's worth, I don't even need to use qmail. I've been using Postfix for years, which allows this as a configuration option. But I'll check them out for sure.
- XorNot 7y agoWouldn't tagging only affect inbound mail? I would've thought a domain forwarder would work around this for migration?
- abecode 7y ago+1 about the opaqueness of gmails spam filters. I once had an email from a google recruiter (@google address) go to spam in gmail so at least it's somewhat egalitarian (that was 5+ years ago).
- 77pt77 7y agosame thing. Had an email from a recruiter and another from financial go to SPAM in gmail. More, google knew this was a thing because they warned me.
- ben_jones 7y agoThat makes sense though. An aggressive recruiter overusing their work email to contact cold leads will get flagged a lot, even if the domain is clean I imagine they also train based off of individual addresses.
- wvh 7y agoI run my own mail server for receiving, but send through a commercial provider (Fastmail). I also use user-sub@domain style email addresses. If I have occasionally have to send email from those addresses, I edit the From line in the Fastmail web interface or my email client. I don't have a problem setting up a full email server, but I don't want to babysit it for just one person using it. I have too many real life obligations these days to try and fix the mess if a problem would arise.
- wpietri 7y agoInteresting! Maybe I should try doing the outbound via Fastmail or some other provider. I couldn't shut down my mail server entirely, but it might solve my deliverability issue.
- nullwarp 7y agoI use postmark to do my delivery. They support outbound smtp that my internal postfix relays to and you pay per email even tho they gave me so many free credits I havent paid anything.
- w0uld 7y agoI was thinking about doing the same with mailgun. Do you have any obvious delivery issues with outgoing mail marked as spam?
- jimmaswell 7y agoIf nobody supports it then why did you choose it?
- wpietri 7y agoThis sort of snotty reply is one of the reasons I discourage people from using HN. I chose it 20+ years ago because that's what qmail supported, back when subaddresing was a new idea. Over the ensuing years, most people ended up converging on + as the more common option, but that's only convention, not a standard. And what standard exists wasn't written until 2008: https://tools.https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5233ietf.org/html/rfc5233 https://tools.https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5233ietf.org/ht...
- jimmaswell 7y agoIf you took that as snotty then that's on you. Maybe people who can't take every simple question not being a delicately delivered paragraph full of qualifiers should be discouraged from using HN, yeah.
- wpietri 7y agoYes, please continue to blame readers for your words landing badly. That will surely work out well for you.
- goatsi 7y agoI use Migadu.com for my email and they allow you to create regex based catchalls [0]. I have one that accepts every email address that begins with "cat". it makes it dead simple to create a fresh email for new services. [0] https://www.migadu.com/en/benefits.html#anchor_catchalls https://www.migadu.com/en/benefits.html#anchor_catchalls
- Jaruzel 7y agoI do two things: 1. Send mail via a static IP (that I pay extra for) 2. Send all mail through a reputable 'smarthost' (mine is provided by my ISP as part of the 'business' package). This fixes all sending mail problems. For extra fairy-dust, I added SPF records to my mail server IP. The BIG problem is Spam. Unless you pay for an intermediary spam filtering service, you will NEVER be on top of it. After self-hosting my own mail system for decades, I am now seriously planning a migration to Office 365.
- huhtenberg 7y ago> The BIG problem is Spam. YMMV, but a combination of graylisting, RBL and "sender address valiation" tends to drop inbound spam rate to nearly zero.
- Jaruzel 7y agoI'm currently hosting a spamassassin instance, and route incoming mail via that, however a lot still gets through :(
- wpietri 7y agoI'm using SA as well; it's fine for me. My big trick is to route a bunch of stuff right into the spam training system. E.g., when a tagged address I've given out is compromised, that goes right to training. The same goes for spam to random names: also right to SA spam training. My theory here is that statistically, by the time a spammer tries to send one to an active address, they're likely to have already fed things into the trainer, often multiple times.
- dgl 7y agoI switched over to Gsuite and I use qmail style addresses, it’s not as friendly as using + addressing (as in it just works) but you can use regexp rewrites on the paid versions of Gsuite to fake it. (Disclosure: xoogler, but still happy with Gsuite...)
- throw0101a 7y ago> I've been running my own mail server for 20+ years ... Out of curiosity, where does your MTA live? Do you have a VPS? VM/instance at a cloud provider? ISP with static IP? Other?
- wpietri 7y agoI have a physical server colocated with Datacate in Santa Clara. As far as I can tell the address space is good, and I've had the server there for a number of years.