4 ms·
The previous administration had a similar effort that failed. I hope that this effort is successful. >"For instance, it could allow one provider to follow and
by legitster 7y ago
The previous administration had a similar effort that failed. I hope that this effort is successful.
>"For instance, it could allow one provider to follow and match the prices of the other provider (like two gas stations across the street from one another who face no other competition)," Garmon said.
I understand this argument, but I think they underrate how much people are willing to shop around when they actually have prices to use as a metric. I would be willing to travel to get a cheaper hip replacement if I actually know what the local price is, rather than being surprised by it every time.
- bluGill 7y agoI'd pay more for quality. If I knew hospital X is better at hip replacement I'd pay extra to go there. Of course how much extra I'm not sure, and I'm also not sure how you compare hip replacement quality like that. It is only emergency rooms where I don't get a choice - if you need an emergency room close is important.
- legitster 7y agoUnfortunately, under the current system, price and quality of care are relatively uncorrelated. Which makes sense as we learn how arbitrary pricing is. But as I understand how medical billing actually works, if only a single patient uses an MRI machine in a year, they would pass on the entirety of the cost to the single patient. But a hospital that uses the MRI constantly spreads the cost across all patients. In the latter hospital, they would also have better outcomes since they have more experience and specialization in the procedure. This is also the opposite of how it would work in a market-based industry. In an auto-shop, I know how much I can charge for any service, and before buying equipment and personnel to expand my services, I determine if it is worthwhile to invest the capital.
- sigstoat 7y ago> It is only emergency rooms where I don't get a choice - if you need an emergency room close is important. i feel like the folks on here peddling this line have not ever spent any time watching who comes through an ER. most of the people who go into an ER aren't dying, or screaming in pain. they've just got a problem that can't wait until urgent care opens up again in the morning. or they need something done that urgent cares aren't equipped to do (fancier diagnostic equipment; whatever). they've got plenty of time to consult with a hypothetical "find a cheap/good ER near me" app.
- mc32 7y agoI think lots of people say “ER” for trauma center.
- soapboxrocket 7y agoI think lots of people say "ER" for "ED" Emergency Department became the most common term about a decade ago and Emergency Room faded from building guides and hospital documents.
- mc32 7y agoEither way most don’t have trauma centers, in SF I think only SF General is the only level 1 trauma center although some of the people also rotate through UCSF’s ED.
- soapboxrocket 7y agoYea, very true. Up here in Seattle I believe we are in the same boat, a single level 1 trauma center.
- bluGill 7y agoMost people go to the ER for non-emergency conditions... Though I will note that many emergency symptoms turn out to be non-emergency only after more tests.
- jonlucc 7y agoThere are lots of ways to measure outcomes. First, you can look at institutional metrics like nosocomial infection rates. Second, you can look at metrics for that procedure like rate of surgery revision. Many of these kinds of metrics exist, but are never exposed to the public.
- prklmn 7y agoYou compare hip replacement quality by asking what the center's/surgeons complication rate is. How many are they having to go back and redo, a revision as they call it. It would be nice if these rates were publicly accessible in a easy to search database. As it stands now, hospitals market themselves on size, volume, and fancy buildings all of which don't mean much compared to complication rates.
- matheusmoreira 7y ago> It would be nice if these rates were publicly accessible in a easy to search database. That will make surgeons avoid complicated cases due to the risk of failure and its consequences for their careers.
- prklmn 7y agoThey already do that
- nhyun 7y agoIf you're concerned about hip replacement quality, you should care more about the surgeon than the hospital. Check out the ProPublica Surgeon Scorecard: https://projects.propublica.org/surgeons/ https://projects.propublica.org/surgeons/
- smileysteve 7y ago> I'd pay more for quality. If I knew hospital X is better at hip replacement I'd pay extra to go there. Recently, HSAs and transparent prices were proposed by a Marketwatch article on HN. But, assuming you have a average America "Max Out Of Pocket", price transparency over this amount doesn't have the intended effect or perhaps, as you point out, the opposite effect.
- TheSoftwareGuy 7y ago>I understand this argument, but I think they underrate how much people are willing to shop around when they actually have prices to use as a metric. If prices are transparent enough, eventually bored programmers will create websites & other tools that make it super simple to find the lowest cost provider in any non-emergency situation, and probably even emergency situations if you are looking ahead of time
- charwalker 7y agoGoogle Maps does this for gas prices, how much more to implement a public listing or "menu" for a hospital or clinic based on published rates?
- soapboxrocket 7y agoHell a good program could tell me how much time I have to address said emergency and then give me prices and time to locations for said emergency. I bet people would even be willing to take a bit of risk and drive an extra 10 minutes to save 50% with an increased risk of long term damage of say 10%. In fact, let's start A/B testing that!
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 7y agoIf you have the money no one is stopping you from going to India or Mexico. Many of their doctors learn in the US