7 ms·
A thought: the Half-Life games have always essentially been explorations of the possibilities behind new technologies. • HL1 was an exploration of the possibil
by derefr 7y ago
A thought: the Half-Life games have always essentially been explorations of the possibilities behind new technologies.
• HL1 was an exploration of the possibility-space of having objects interact through emitted “energy” (i.e. by broadcasting messages that get attenuated by distance.)
• HL2 was an exploration of the possibility-space of putting a dynamics simulation engine in a game (and also spawned Gary’s Mod to continue said exploration.)
• The major offshoots of the series, Portal and its sequel, were explorations of the possibility-space created by combining “beams” of matter or energy (lasers, hitscan gunfire, tractor beams, paint), gravity, and wormholes.
In other words, each major new entry in the Half-Life universe was essentially a narrative wrapped around the results of playing around with implementing some journal paper (or reimplementing some prototype) of a novel type of realtime physical simulation, that had obvious game-mechanical implications.
I’m not surprised that we never got an HL3, because for the past 10-odd years, there hasn’t really been a big new obvious realtime physical-simulation tech to turn into game mechanics.
I’m also not surprised that Valve would return to making games under the Half-Life brand in order to explore the implications of a new technology (even if it’s not a new realtime physical-simulation technology. Or maybe they’ve got one of those up their sleeves as well...)
- shantly 7y ago> • HL1 was an exploration of the possibility-space of having objects interact through emitted “energy” (i.e. by broadcasting messages that get attenuated by distance.) I played FPS games before HL, and I played all the original HL games including Blue Shift and Opposing Force, plus a bunch of single-player fan-produced games and even Gunman Chronicles, all using the engine, and I don't follow what you mean here.
- seminatl 7y agoYeah I thought it was about smashing facecrabs with a crowbar.
- wishinghand 7y agoThe big idea that the first Half Life explored was never breaking from first person. No cutscenes. Sometimes they’d trap you to focus your attention on something but they never took away the player’s control to look at what they wanted to.
- nsxwolf 7y agoAnd it worked so well for immersion, and is the most natural and comfortable way to tell a story in VR.
- weaksauce 7y agoWell that and the fact that they had a writer and a story instead of a free for all killing spree like their contemporaries.
- laumars 7y agoThere were already a lot of FPS around that era that had a proper story.
- skyyler 7y agoCan you provide some examples? I don't remember Turok or Unreal having gripping stories.
- mietek 7y agoPathways into Darkness (1993), Marathon (1994), Marathon 2: Durandal (1995), and Marathon Infinity (1996) all precede Half-Life (1998). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pathways_into_Darkness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pathways_into_Darkness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marathon_Trilogy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marathon_Trilogy The stories of these games have been the subject of discussions for many years. http://pid.bungie.org http://pid.bungie.org http://marathon.bungie.org/story/ http://marathon.bungie.org/story/ You may know Bungie as the studio behind Halo: Combat Evolved (2001) and subsequent games.
- derefr 7y agoHalf-Life 1’s “thing” is sort of like Breath of the Wild’s “thing”: every object in the game has physical attributes, and these physical attributes can cause the sim to emit signals from particular objects that interact with other sim objects through general interfaces (rather than only interacting with specific “compatible” objects), with the results differing depending on source attributes, target attributes, and the distance between the source and target; and with the same attribute of the target often taking on a weighted-average of the sum of the input signals it’s been receiving lately. When an HL1 object is “on fire”, for example, it’s emitting “infrared-radiation particles” as hitscan shots off of a point-source at its center. If these hit something, the physics sim checks the “on fire” object’s “hotness” attribute, and its distance from the target it hit, and from these computes a “heat impulse” that should be given to the target, which may or may not be enough to set the target “on fire.” Different things burn with more or less “hotness”, and for more or less time before burning out, depending on the material they’re made of. Explosive barrels don’t have any special code—they’re just “on fire” for a very hot, very short time (but they’re also “concussive”, which is a separate instantiation of this same logic.) The Crossbow’s alternate fire just slides a physical object that’s intensely “on fire” through the scene at high speed. Etc. This system continues into HL2 as well. Pheropod/bugbait objects are just a copy of this system, where “on fire” is instead “acts as ally”, and antlions can be temporarily or permanently caught “acts as ally” by getting hit by a strong enough dose of pheropod radiative signalling. This system is basically why HL1 and HL2 play the way they do: rather than only being able to kill things with weapon-objects programmed to emit “kill” signals toward enemies, you can kill things with pretty much any object, in a variety of ways, as enemies are physical-sim objects that can die for physical-sim reasons. And it’s very easy to make a useful new object in these engines, as you can just model something, give it some interesting physical attributes, and plop it into a level. The sim will then take care of making it useful.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoYeah, I remember being surprised at the interactivity even HL1 had, like that crates were destructible, and not in a super simple, binary [completely intact] vs [completely obliterated] kind of way. You could break them down more gradually with the crowbar.
- 7y ago
- kipchak 7y agoI think a lot of the AI functions like smell, Grunt AI and houndeye group behavior rely on this. A lot of it is easy to miss, like Vortigaunts fleeing, hiding and not attacking below a certain health. Houndeyes for example will react differently to quiet/far away noises than loud startling ones. https://youtu.be/1tvz0WVaQGg https://youtu.be/1tvz0WVaQGg https://youtu.be/9jO-P3kXlCI?t=105 https://youtu.be/9jO-P3kXlCI?t=105
- kompakt 7y agoYes, and this should be listed as HL1's main advance, its brilliant AI, which at that time of the release was unlike anything else. https://youtu.be/cOSCBMHGE18 https://youtu.be/cOSCBMHGE18 https://youtu.be/GjDY3m1SMpw https://youtu.be/GjDY3m1SMpw
- ykl 7y agoIn the cases of Brave and Moana at Pixar and Disney Animation respectively, the story definitely came before the tech was developed. I was an intern at Pixar during the production of Brave, and I worked on Moana, and I can say that in both cases, there was a mad scramble to develop the tech to catch up with the story. We didn't really have the water on Moana working completely correctly until like 6 months before the movie came out.
- jdormit 7y agoWhoa, cool! What sort of work did you do during your internship? Pixar is definitely in my top-5 list of companies I would love to work for.
- ykl 7y agoRendering. :) I worked on a GPU-based real-time path tracer prototype at Pixar, which became the RTP renderer used for their in-house lookdev tools [1]. [1] http://on-demand.gputechconf.com/siggraph/2017/video/sig1738-florian-hecht-peter-roe-go-with-the-flow-pixar.html http://on-demand.gputechconf.com/siggraph/2017/video/sig1738...
- jdormit 7y agoThat's dope. Thanks for sharing!
- chuckdries 7y agoThat's so interesting! I think the fact that they nail the tech so well makes it intuitively surprising that it didn't come first. Not pixar but similarly, when I saw the siggraph talk where Disney Animation showed off how they do snow rendering in Frozen I wondered whether the tech came first
- ykl 7y agoThat's also a case where the tech came a while after the story. Our early snow tests on Frozen looked pretty terrible until the MPM simulator [1] came online later. [1] https://www.disneyanimation.com/technology/innovations/matterhorn https://www.disneyanimation.com/technology/innovations/matte...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- aerovistae 7y agoMoana wasn't Pixar btw.
- willis936 7y agoOne could argue that real time ray tracing is a jump forward in this area.
- ArtWomb 7y agoTo continue your line of reasoning. And I think it's what makes XR so immersive, with immersion being a hallmark of the HL franchise. Is the opening of a possibility-space in VR of having any human player "thought" made manifest as "material" in the virtual world. HL:A possibly represents a watershed. The 40-hour, single-player narrative action VR experience (not to mention a Counterstrike VR mod). What recently released Asgard's Wrath referred to as "God-scale" gaming https://uploadvr.com/asgards-wrath-review/ https://uploadvr.com/asgards-wrath-review/
- soulofmischief 7y ago> The major offshoots of the series, Portal and its sequel, were explorations of the possibility-space created by combining “beams” of matter or energy (lasers, hitscan gunfire, tractor beams, paint), gravity, and wormholes. This isn't a technology, rather it's a set of game mechanics.
- derefr 7y agoIt’s a technology for simulating the interactions of these things. Point the paint gun in Portal 2 through a portal into an area with different gravity and you’ll see something that required the invention of novel tech. That system “worked” since Portal 1; they just didn’t fully explore it in Portal 1.
- meheleventyone 7y agoThat technology has worked since at least Quake FWIW! Shooting rockets through teleporters into zones with different gravity. Both Portal games are cool though.
- soulofmischief 7y agoEvery game mechanic requires a technology behind it. However, the mechanics you described did not require new technology. It was simply a novel application of existing technology. It doesn't fit in with the rest of your tenuous examples.
- inerte 7y agoNintendo is well known for making some games like this too. It's a bunch of cool tech and physical controllers generating new interaction models, and game designers stretching that as far as they can, sometimes cohesively as a full game sometimes a collage of mini-games.
- derefr 7y agoSome Nintendo games are definitely explorations of their own novel input methods; and also, earlier on, explorations of the possibilities of the console’s fancy custom hardware features. (Whether you got one or the other often depended on whether the software/product department, or the hardware/R&D department, was responsible for the game’s design—the product folks [Nintendo EAD] tended to push for the inclusions of novel input methods on new hardware designs, so they built games around those; while the R&D folks were more intimately familiar with the more “gimmicky” hardware features they had included into new console designs, and so only they really understood what could be done with them, until they demonstrated it to the world and to the other departments with a tech-demo game.) But I would say that, most of the time, Nintendo (and similar allied shops like HAL and Intelligent Systems) just invent novel game mechanics out of thin air, then ask how the player should interact with those mechanics; they make the interaction with the mechanic as a prototype, and playtest it on its own; and then, if that turns out to be fun, they wrap a game around that. This is why, for example, the Paper Mario series looks the way it does. Nintendo + Intelligent Systems both agree that you can’t just take the same mechanics and make a new game, even if the mechanics you came up with the first time were really good. They already explored the possibility-space of those mechanics as well as they could manage in the first game!
- simonsarris 7y agoHL1 had a good story and narrative arc. You, the first person scientist are pressed into shooting things, confused as hell about what's going on. You had a direct line of sympathy into the situation, as player. It was very easy to feel the dreamlike-yet-horror narrative, from start to finish. It was quite compelling just how well they did it. HL2 had some interesting mostly-environmental exposition intermixed with an extremely lame narrative arc. You are basically just a guy with a gun who spends most of your time in transit. If you swapped places with Barney or a random citizen in an early scene, nothing would have changed. Your character is sterile. The main character was the environments, some of which were very good, but it felt more like a very long "demo" than a game. Everyone expressing surprise at how you are in fact Gordon Freeman and it just doesn't matter at all. You're a lunatic with bullets to spend, plus a couple science fair level physics ramps to complete. Tomb raider, every single one of them, did physics puzzles better, and they didn't have a physics engine! I think everyone was wowed at the tech at the time and didn't realize just how bad the rest of the experience was. Replaying it, its very easy to feel (compared to replaying Deus Ex or Thief or HL1) There was no emotive force in HL2. The story become uncompelling. I think they realzied HL3 would fall super flat without some new technology to showcase, because they made the Gordon story so damn boring. (You'll notice in a lot of fanfics, people actually talk, or they aren't about Gordon at all.)
- PascLeRasc 7y agoI don't think it's a mistake that we don't hear Gordon Freeman talk, and barely ever see his face. I think the burden is on the player to feel connected to HL2. It's more an exploration of a dystopian landscape, which wasn't as played out 15 years ago as it is now. You get NPCs with excellent-for-the-time voice acting and huge landscapes to explore. You get to insert yourself into the character of Gordon, it's kind of "2004's VR" in that way.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoExactly. Now combine that with what the GP said about HL1, some A-tier object manipulation and the impressiveness of VR and you have a game that's a lot of fun to play even if you're just along for the ride (in terms of plot). Throw in a decent story arc, hook people with letting them actually make some tough decisions (earth is descending into a dystopia in the time it's set so plenty of opportunities to force the player to choose between a bunch of bad options and feel guilty about whatever they choose) and you have a highly immersive experience. I don't mean to make it sound trivial, each one of those things is hard to do right and they all have to be done right but it should not be rocket science. Valve just needs a Decent(TM) game using their existing principals. The hard part is going to coping with the constraints of VR without neutering player freedom within the story or botching the VR part.
- hyperpallium 7y agoThe Portal team was acquired by Valve, based on their demo. VR could play a part in a physics simulation.
- CivBase 7y ago> for the past 10-odd years, there hasn’t really been a big new obvious realtime physical-simulation tech to turn into game mechanics Idk about that. I think Valve has simply changed their identity from "Game Developer" to "Gaming Platform Holder". They have continued to experiment with new tech like they always have. They've made significant contributions to VR, streaming, and (for better or worse) monitization - technologies that are in service to their platform. Valve as a game developer isn't dead. It just takes the back seat to Valve as a platform holder.
- derefr 7y agoYou might be right on their priorities, but I think my reasoning also holds, even if it’s maybe not the primary reason they didn’t make an HL3. I’ve given some thought to this, and I invite you to do the same: if there was an HL3 that continued in the tradition of serving as a tech-demo for a new kind of realtime physics-sim tech, what are the possibilities for the tech it could be showcasing? I’m not too deep into physical-simulation research, so I can’t say whether there’s something just sitting around as a journal paper. What I can say is that I haven’t seen anything in a modern title (even an artsy indie title) that would have made for a good basis for an HL game. Have you?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mikewhy 7y agoGabe said as much himself[0]: > Products are usually the result of an intersection of technology that we think has traction, a group of people who want to work on that, and one of the game properties that feels like a natural playground for that set of technology and design challenges. > When we decided we needed to work on markets, free to play, and user generated content, Team Fortress seemed like the right place to do that. That work ended up informing everything we did in the multiplayer space. > Left 4 Dead is a good place for creating shared narratives. [0]: https://www.reddit.com/r/The_Gaben/comments/5olhj4/hi_im_gabe_newell_ama/dck8n80/ https://www.reddit.com/r/The_Gaben/comments/5olhj4/hi_im_gab...
- ehsankia 7y agoGoing a step aside from the technology itself, here's another way of looking at those games: Half-life basically helped kick start story-driven FPS games (Bioshock, etc) Half-Life 2 helped kick off physics based FPS games. Portal basically kicked off the FPS puzzle genre (Talos Principle, QUBE, Quantum Conundrum, etc). L4D basically kicked off FPS co-op games (Borderlands, Killing Floor, PayDay), as well as asymmetric co-op. For better or worse, TF2 with hats and later CSGO basically started the microtransaction/crate system. Lastly, Dota 2 did a lot to push e-sports forward too. This is the kind of advances Valve is interested in. It's hard to tell now, but this game could easily have a huge impact on how VR games are made in the future.