5 ms·
Are suicide rates higher among 'the rich and famous' than among average people? If not, this really has no merit. People kill themselves because they have ment
by keiferski 16y ago
Are suicide rates higher among 'the rich and famous' than among average people?
If not, this really has no merit. People kill themselves because they have mental health issues, not because they come to realize that success isn't the secret to happiness.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- logjam 16y agoProbably many nuances to this question, but there is some literature out there indicating increased income is associated with increased suicide risk. One case control series reported in BMJ in a relatively large sample (~1500) found that "people with a history of mental illness and a high income are at greater risk of committing suicide than their lower income counterparts. This may be because richer people with a mental disorder feel more shameful, vulnerable, and stigmatised." http://www.bmj.com/content/322/7282/0.7.full http://www.bmj.com/content/322/7282/0.7.full From the paper: "In contrast to findings in the general population, the suicide risk for patients admitted to hospital with a mental illness fell significantly with decreasing income (P=0.0001)...In the adjusted analyses, a similar but less pronounced pattern was found in people who had never been admitted to hospital with a psychiatric disorder." http://www.bmj.com/content/322/7282/334.1.full http://www.bmj.com/content/322/7282/334.1.full
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- ramchip 16y ago> there is some literature out there indicating increased income is associated with increased suicide risk. As far as I can see, the study you cited does not support this. The quote mentions "In contrast to findings in the general population". On the same page, a little further, it is written: "There is clear evidence from person based and ecological studies that relative poverty is associated with an increased risk of suicide." (with a couple citations)
- kia 16y agoI don't know about rich/poor suicide rates but in developed/developing countries the suicide rates are higher than in undeveloped world. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_ra...
- mthoms 16y agoCorrelation does not equal causation. From glancing at that chart, there also appear to be correlations with religion and distance from the equator (i.e. regions having more or less daily sunlight).
- rdtsc 16y agoTrue, but it is still an interesting link. I wonder if it is because of the isolation and the breaking of family ties in a developing world, which is is linked to the level of mobility and also with culture.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- someone1 16y agoObviously this is a throwaway account for possibly obvious reason that I don't wish anyone in my life to know this... yada yada yah.... ... anyway, I'd like to add to your comment about people killing themselves because they have mental health issues. Please note this isn't some attack on you and it isn't aimed solely at you it just happens that your comment raised was relevant. It strikes me as odd(not really) that people think that just because you would dare do such a think that you must be mentally ill or be on drugs etc. That is sometimes not the case. I'd describe myself as generally happy and a nice person to be around(this is what I've actually been told) but to be honest I don't want to be here, I never have and can't wait to go. It's possibly hard for you and most people to understand but when you feel out of place often you just want to leave. To give you some context; I don't live luxurious life and I actually don't want one I often give-away most of the extra money I have but I still live comfortably. I love my job and the people I work with. I'm not the greatest communicator - it's not really a problem I just don't like interacting with people (I prefer to listen and observe). Yet I've always had close friends and is always popular with everyone everywhere I go(numerous schools, university, work). By now you probably are guessing that the way I'd like the world to be (simple, happy and loving, etc.) isn't the way the world is, and that's very much the reason I don't want to be here. As I said I just don't feel like I belong here and I don't want to be here, if it were not for the fact that people would be hurt I'd be gone a long time ago. In the past I've talked about my views of life in a discussion similar to this, I asked if that means I also and I also had a mental illness that was causing me to think like this and I was told that yes I do. But noone can tell me how or why that answer is a 'yes'. Perhaps you can, provide a reason for a yes or no nswer, perhaps not but I'll ask away and see what happens. With the facts given above, is it not possible that I'm just one of those people that see life differently from the norm. Do I have a mental illness? can you give a reason why you think I do(or don't)?
- ntoshev 16y agoWhy do you care if you have mental illness or not? Either way, you have a bit different perspective on the world from everyone else, drugs could make you feel better, etc. Mental illness is just a label. Try talking to your close friends about how the world is and how you'd like it to be (no need to get into details about leaving it). Maybe you'll find you can do something about it, albeit small.
- foljs 16y ago> Are suicide rates higher among 'the rich and famous' than among average people? If not, this really has no merit. Who said it has to be higher for this article to has merit? This article talks about "WHY the rich & famous commit suicide" not "IN WHAT NUMBERS the rich & famous commit suicide". What makes the question interesting is that most intuitively believe that a "rich and famous" would have no reason to contemplate suicide. > People kill themselves because they have mental health issues Huh? Who said mental health issues are the only (or even a major) cause of suicide? In contrast to this, at least the article puts forward a reasoning, doesn't state its premise as a matter of fact.