3 ms·
I read the article, but it feels like "don't build anything until you are sure users want X". The problem is that nobody knows what users actually want, especia
by ekianjo 7y ago
I read the article, but it feels like "don't build anything until you are sure users want X". The problem is that nobody knows what users actually want, especially when you build something new. And the market will keep throwing ideas in several directions until one day, an idea sticks and becomes successful.
Like, no gamer in pre-Wii times "wanted to play hours standing with a motion controller". Nintendo released the Wii and it was a huge success (for a while at least).
Maybe the author's point is that Stadia is not doing anything "new", and this may be a good point. But it's still early days, and Google has deep pockets. It's a little too early to discard Stadia.
- Someone1234 7y ago> I read the article, but it feels like "don't build anything until you are sure users want X". The article addresses that exact point: > I think the answer's obvious. Because they designed the product backward. They didn't think "what do people want?", or even go Apple and think "what COULD people want, if we showed them why they wanted it?". Your issue is largely addressed by their second Apple example. They're talking about the thinking that ultimately results in the product, and how Google's (and Sun's) thinking is focused on themselves and e.g. Apple's thinking is still user-orientated even if they have to "sell" an original concept. So absolutely try something new, but as the article says, it still has to be designed for an actual audience rather than just being created to further that company's own interests without offering enough value for their market.
- ekianjo 7y ago> rather than just being created to further that company's own interests I find the Apple example unconvincing, especially for "recent Apple" stuff. Removing ports on their laptops, making some models' keyboard worse (most Apple users dislike the touchbar), making them unserviceable, forcing the phone users to buy expensive peripherals (Airpods...), bug-ridden OS updates, all of this point to a disdain towards their users rather than the opposite. Am I missing something?
- seabrookmx 7y ago100% right, and they've been panned for this. The result is a 16" Macbook that's thicker, larger, and has an "old-style" scissor switch keyboard. Even the new Airpods pro finally have silicone tips. Apple has learned the hard way, and looks like they're finally turning around a bit. Maybe even the next iPhone will have USB-C? I don't own a single Apple device but would consider an iPad (a base model.. I don't need/want an expensive "Pro") if it had USB-C.
- ben_jones 7y agoIf you're a serial entrepreneur trying to get rich, or maybe a corporate product manager trying to get a juicy bonus, ya you'll have no clue what the users want because you'll be forcing it. But if you are one of the users you are very much aware of what your problems are and what might solve them - even if you don't have whatever domain experience is necessary to solve them. I agree with your overall point, that things are worth trying even if they don't inherently scream success. But that doesn't mean we need to try everything and abandon common sense at the door. In this case I don't think Stadia defies common sense, I think it defies consumer benefit: gamers should own the games they buy, freemium services powered by ads are dubious, and products which need to be advertised dishonestly to sell well probably shouldn't be sold at all.
- ekianjo 7y ago> gamers should own the games they buy Agree with the sentiment, but almost every digital purchase nowadays does not tie with ownership, but a license to use whatever you pay for - and it can be nullified at any point in time. If Steam were to go bankrupt tomorrow (unlikely, but for the sake of the argument let's imagine it), you would probably lose complete access to your library of games you "bought". One exception may be GOG with its DRM-free policy, but it's a very small part of the online reselling market.
- ben_jones 7y agoIs that true though? When I buy (and install) a game on steam it gets put into a downloads folder with an executable I can use outside of Steam to start the game. Are you saying that Steam would be legally obligated to delete this directory should they go out of business?
- ekianjo 7y agoYou can't use most games outside of Steam to launch them. Most games (but not all) have DRM's and require Steam to be running to launch. You can look it up.