4 ms·
"didn't really want to participate" is basically the definition of sexual assault.
by cmrdporcupine 7y ago
"didn't really want to participate" is basically the definition of sexual assault.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoYour definition of sexual assault is dangerously lacking in nuance. Most people who have had long term sexual partners have had a time or two where they "didn't really want to participate" but did anyway without much/any complaining for the sake of their partner. Are all all those instances "basically sexual assault"? Watering down the definition of sexual assault to include instances where nobody felt assaulted in any way does not result in it being taken more seriously.
- pluma 7y agoSpousal rape and sexual abuse were legal in many places for a long time (and still are in some), doesn't make it not rape and sexual abuse, though. "Informed enthusiastic consent" isn't so hard to figure out, is it? If you feel like you're being pressured into something you don't want, that's still non-consensual even if you don't put up a fight.
- zepto 7y agoI think most people feel like they are sometimes pressured into work they don’t want to do, but we don’t call that slavery. Frankly maybe we should, but until we do it’s going to be hard to make this a bright line.
- wang_li 7y agoVoluntarily doing something you’re not excited about is different than having something done to you you don’t want done. It’s not kidnapping if I agree to go with my wife to visit her sister. It is rape if I agree to sex with a condom but the other party removes it. It’s also rape if I agree to sex with someone and then they engage in sex a second time while I am asleep hours later.
- happytoexplain 7y agoWhile there are situations like you describe where "didn't really want to participate" represents something immoral and selfish but less insidious than what we think of as rape, there are also plenty of situations where it does represent the weighty event of sexual assault. I think your simplification is less nuanced and much more dangerous than the parent's simplification. I also think "overwhelming majority" is a scary assumption, in terms of what it says about your experiences, unless we are mapping "didn't really want to" very differently onto real examples of emotional state. *Disclaimer: The parent post was edited after I began replying to be worded a bit less absolutely.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>While there are situations like you describe where "didn't really want to participate" represents something immoral and selfish but less insidious than what we think of as rape, there are also plenty of situations where it does represent the weighty event of sexual assault. I'm talking strictly about situations where there is no threat of violence. Obviously there is a spectrum of varying degrees of consent from "perfectly ok" to "definitely rape" and somewhere in there is a range that constitutes sexual assault but to say that the lack of specifically enthusiastic consent defines the floor of the sexual assault range is farcical when there are so many other variables to consider. >Disclaimer: The parent post was edited after I began replying to be worded a bit less absolutely. I changed the order of the three points. >we are mapping "didn't really want to" very differently onto real examples of emotional state. I think a lot of people find "didn't really want to" to be equivalent to "really didn't want to"
- pvaldes 7y ago> "didn't really want to participate" is basically the definition of sexual assault. Yes, but is also a case of "your word against mine" unless supported by verifiable data.
- wolco 7y agoDidn't really isn't = decided not to. It could be didn't feel like it but did it anyways. Ever heard someone say this.. I didn't want to go to school but I did. It's like saying I didn't want to kill that person. It is an unfinished statement to what the final decision is. It could be: So I did or so I didn't.
- BigJ1211 7y agoIf we go by that definition then everytime your partner is horny and you're not, but you have sex with them regardless you're "sexually assaulted". As you didn't really want to participate.
- claudiawerner 7y agoThat's rubbish; you may not be in the mood, but you still consent to it - wanting to do something isn't the same as being horny. The point isn't about being horny, it's if you want to do it - being aroused is a factor you're introducing.
- BigJ1211 7y agoMy point was that your partner can be pushy enough that you participate even though you didn't really want to. I.e. they are horny/want to have sex, you don't, yet you still have sex. By the definition above that is sexual assault. If you don't communicate that you don't want to have sex it becomes a really murky topic, as you didn't give verbal nor non-verbal consent. But you also didn't give verbal nor nnon-verbal disconsent. This could be something you regret afterwards, but I don't think you can attribute that to malintent (or rape/sexual assault) on your sexual partner's side. So removing the condom mid-act would be sexual assault, a broken condom wouldn't be. But the partner consented to sex with a condom. Or in case a woman says she's on birthcontrol (or has a spiral) and it later turns out that was false, then you also didn't consent to that. So basically my second point is that it takes a lot of language to define what is and what isn't sexual assault or rape. Condensing it down would be harmful to victims and people accused.
- happytoexplain 7y agoTrue, but I think the parent's absolutism is closer to reality than your absolutism. I.e. it's essentially a pointless semantic argument - "didn't really want to" doesn't have enough context to decide in either direction.
- BigJ1211 7y agoI agree with you there, my point was that his definition is highly fallible and easily abused. And I was attempting to point that out with an example. It might seem pointlessly semantic, but I think it's important with issues such as sexual assault and rape. Especially considering the people on either side of this likely have their lives ruined.