8 ms·
“Royalty-Free” Music Supplied by YouTube Results in Mass Video Demonetization
- sly010 7y ago> "SonyATV & Warner Chappell have claimed 24 of my videos because the royalty free song Dreams by Joakim Karud (from the OFFICIAL YOUTUBE AUDIO LIBRARY BTW) uses a sample from Kenny Burrell Quartet’s ‘Weaver of Dream`" Isn't that protected use anyway?
- londons_explore 7y agoJust because it's protected in law doesn't mean YouTube can't have more IP-owner friendly policies.
- jandrese 7y agoFrom YouTube's perspective this makes total sense. Their takedown system is heavily automated because they deal with hours of new video every minute. There are two possibilities for error: 1. False Positive -- Video is brought down despite it being technically legal. Creator is mad, but YouTube suffers no more liability. 2. False Negative -- Big corporate lawyers sue YouTube for hundreds of trillions of dollars for copyright infringement. Also, these corporate lawyers would very much prefer it if you didn't believe in fair use at all. They will try to convince the court that fair use isn't a thing for weird technical reasons, and they might succeed. So naturally the system is tuned to error on the side of generating excessive false positives. Unfortunately the enforcement side doesn't seem to understand how bad the false positive problem is and hits creators with draconian punishments for errors on YouTube's part.
- Hamcha 7y agoI don't think there's anything wrong with erring on either side, but at least the appeal process should be better vetted. If you know your system is going to fail, which YouTube has so often it generates drama every month, at least avoid putting more salt in the wound by auto-rejecting everything.
- jandrese 7y agoThe media cartels are going to get quite testy if they flag someone's videos time and time again and yet the person is allowed to continue posting. They get especially testy when YouTube tells them "no, you are wrong" and put a video back up even though it contains a 2 second segment that your algorithm clearly believes is infringing on something you own. Remember, these are the people who sued individual Napster users for $1.9 million for sharing a single album, and won.
- wolfgke 7y ago> 1. False Positive -- Video is brought down despite it being technically legal. Creator is mad, but YouTube suffers no more liability. Solution: Create a law that makes it possible for the creator to sue YouTube for a false positive for the same sum that a media company could sue YouTube for for a false negative. This would counterbalance the scales of both types of errors.
- jakelazaroff 7y agoThe problem is that a lawsuit takes time and money. MegaCorp Inc. has plenty of both of those, whereas Bob Youtuber probably doesn't want to (or can't!) fight a protracted court battle against an adversary with effectively infinite resources about getting paid for their videos.
- tempguy9999 7y agoSoutions: a) youtubers can collectivise b) expensive law firms pick it up with the resouces to win (bob gets nothing but knows MegaCorp gets stung) c) use bad publicity - MegaCorps hate bad publicity d) rich people pretend to be bob, get sued, unleash lawyers on MegaCorp and make lots of money, so MegaCorps get very wary of the 'little' people.
- jakelazaroff 7y agoA and B still mean YouTubers have to dedicate a lot of time and energy to a lawsuit. C is possible today (this article is an example). D is interesting but I am skeptical that even in this hypothetical scenario, "do a thing, wait to get sued and then counter-sue" is the most efficient way for rich people to make more money.
- b3kart 7y agoUnfortunately, even if that law existed, how many creators have the financial resources to go to court with someone like YouTube (i.e. Google). I don't think this is the only case where even if you are technically right, you will go bankrupt before you prove that in court. Case in point: the whole existence of patent trolls.
- theobon 7y agoIt isn't just the detection algorithm that is tuned to benefit big corporations. The end to end process is asymmetric with automated issuance of copyright claims which need to be manually disputed which appear to be automatically rejected. Then the appeal process has a three strikes rule against channel owners but no apparent punishment for corporations. I can understand tuning the detection algorithm but to balance the dispute process needs to take this into account. The fact that it doesn't shows where Youtube stands on the issue.
- msla 7y agoA video of white noise was hit with multiple copyright claims: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-42580523 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-42580523 > A musician who made a 10-hour long video of continuous white noise - indistinct electronic hissing - has said five copyright infringement claims have been made against him.
- jobigoud 7y agoCan we bisect this to figure out the exact fingerprint that triggers a claim?
- tempguy9999 7y agoIt's the bit that sounds like cashhhhhhhhhhhhhhh....
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- aidenn0 7y agoIIRC when you want to dispute a claim of copyright infringement there is no box for "This is fair use." Either you assert you have a valid license to use it or say you do not and submit to the removal or monetization by the copyright holder.
- microtherion 7y agoThat's a case by case distinction anyway. But as far as I can hear, "Dreams" does not use one short quote, but basically the entire melody of "Dreams" consists of snippets of "Weaver of Dream" looped over and over again. If you believe in music copyrights at all, this looks like an open and shut case of infringement to me. Plus "Dreams" is a godawful piece of music. That said, YouTube represented this as safe to use, so it seems to me that the onus should be on them to work out a license and pay the associated costs. I'm sure Google can find enough change in their couch pillows to pay off the rightsholders.
- jedimastert 7y ago> If you believe in music copyrights at all, this looks like an open and shut case of infringement to me. There are some that truly don't believe that sampling copyrights should be a thing. They think it's just a way to stifle creativity. One could also argue that Dreams is so completely derivative that is bears little to no resemblance to the original recording it samples, and as such does not infringe on any intellectual property. > Plus "Dreams" is a godawful piece of music You opinions on a piece have no legal bearing on what does or does not constitute copyright infringement. The comment was completely unnecessary and uncalled for.
- microtherion 7y ago> There are some that truly don't believe that sampling copyrights should be a thing That's why I said "if". > One could also argue that Dreams is so completely derivative that is bears little to no resemblance to the original recording That's not what "derivative" means. > You opinions on a piece have no legal bearing on what does or does not constitute copyright infringement. Maybe not, but in light of your general point about "stifling creativity", it might be worth pointing out that this is hardly a good piece to highlight said creativity.
- emilecantin 7y ago> That said, YouTube represented this as safe to use This is the crux of the issue... As someone who's dabbled in video creation, I have other things to do than look around for "safe" music to use. If I can't even take YouTube's own word on what music I can use, what the hell is there left?
- cuboid 7y agoSomething is going to have to be planned. YouTube is very quickly becoming something we won't like.
- b3kart 7y agoThis something that is going to have to be planned will also need a way of dealing with copyright issues. It sounds like an extremely difficult problem, which is why YouTube is having trouble in the first place. I doubt they enjoy these (very public) mistakes. For example, how exactly do you catch videos using copyrighted material and deal with disputes when thousands of hours of video are uploaded every hour? Doing this manually is likely infeasible. But algorithms are error-prone, as YouTube exemplifies very well. Or how exactly do you stand up to these massive billion-dollar media companies without going bankrupt during your first court case? Which (I think) is why YouTube currently simply goes along with whatever these companies demand. Criticizing YouTube is easy. What is hard is coming up with better solutions that could actually be implemented in whatever YouTube could potentially be replaced with.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wolfgke 7y ago> What is hard is coming up with better solutions that could actually be implemented in whatever YouTube could potentially be replaced with. Anonymous, encrypted, censorship-resistant peer-to-peer networks.
- aphextim 7y agoLbry.io Think torrenting + youtube + blockchain had a baby. https://lbry.com/faq https://lbry.com/faq
- alextingle 7y agoI don't think they care a fig, tbh. If they did, then they'd have a small department that watched for bad publicity like this, and proactively fixed it ASAP. It would cost them virtually nothing, and solve the reputational problem overnight.
- wolfgke 7y agoIf the media groups apply violence (by using the law enforcement agencies as goon squads) even though you did nothing wrong, give the media groups back violence - that's self-defense.
- rezeroed 7y agoIs it possible for a youtuber to switch their videos to silence/mute/delete the audio, while leaving up the video?
- mchristen 7y agoYes, you can edit out the audio from the file on youtube, but it's my understanding that it removes ALL the audio from the segment you delete so any voiceovers will be lost.
- rezeroed 7y agoFar from ideal, it would at least prevent royalties on future viewings of existing videos from going to the music companies.
- znpy 7y agowhy people don't use music from sites like Jamendo ? Is jamendo still a thing btw ? also: friendly reminder that peertube exists.
- type0 7y agoBecause it would be copyright claimed in mass, even more so than the tracks from youtubes own media library.
- JeremyMorgan 7y agoIf you rely on YouTube for income, the time to diversify was a couple of years ago. It seems like they have a whole team of people whose sole job is to mess with the creators. Squeezing out the "little guy" so they can be the sole provider of content. They don't need you anymore.
- benologist 7y agoIt's the teams Google doesn't create that tell the real story. Nobody is paid to care about these users, it's just one big accounting scam contributing to their $100+ billion in savings. Wherever there are consequences for not providing support... Android users get phone and email. Domains users get phone and email. Everyone else collectively enriching Google gets nothing. https://support.google.com/googleplay/answer/7299936 https://support.google.com/googleplay/answer/7299936 https://support.google.com/googleplay/answer/7100415?hl=en https://support.google.com/googleplay/answer/7100415?hl=en Their support is so bad they literally stole $75m from their own customers while support repeatedly said checks were coming and it was nobody's job to fix it until they were being sued. https://marketingland.com/class-action-lawsuit-accuses-google-of-improperly-withholding-refunds-for-ad-fraud-261219 https://marketingland.com/class-action-lawsuit-accuses-googl...
- Keverw 7y agoI have never really been a fan of the YouTube Audio library, a bunch of channels use the same music and I think it subtracts from the video when another video you seen earlier has the same music. I know there's paid libraries of royalty free music, but even then they still get claimed so got to dispute it but it seems some of those libraries have their own form or canned message to paste in to help. I know I've even heard Apple Loops from Garageband get claimed too even those you are licensed to use them. Even public domain NASA clips got someone flagged, because some news company used them in their broadcasts. Then fair use isn't always considered too, like if you were walking and a little bit of music was picked up in the background of your vlog, say maybe from a car driving by blasting loud music. I know with the DMCA there's legal penalties for filing false ones, but Content ID isn't considered a DMCA, so why it doesn't count as a strike unless you disputed it and then the company can then create a DMCA actually reviewing. Really feel like automated technology for policing isn't really ready yet, even flaws in red light cameras.
- aidenn0 7y agoThere are no legal penalties just for filing false claims, only if it's false and made in bad faith. This is an important distinction because "I hold the copyright and disagree that the usage qualifies for fair-use protections" probably doesn't fall into the category of "bad faith"
- matheusmoreira 7y agoWhat makes it bad faith is: > I own the copyright and will use an automated system to spam massive amounts of complaints to anything that even remotely looks like my content without even thinking about whether it's fair use > sending these complaints costs nothing for me and require lengthy appeals and manual review for the affected party who will likely face reductions in revenue in the mean time > if someone successfully appeals the complaint I'll just send it again until they tire of it because I suffer no consequences
- kd3 7y agoYouTube is in dire need of competition.
- coreyp_1 7y agoA few days ago, I wrote about a very similar problem that I'm going through at this very moment. Basically, I recorded myself playing a song that was written 133 years ago, whose composer died 118 years ago. The copyright claim is that I used a melody owned by ASCAP, ICE_CS. But the melody is long in public domain. It is impossible for this melody to be copyrighted. (Also, just to cover the bases of "what if...", I want to clarify that the melody has been correctly identified as the melody written (and published) 133 years ago.) And yet, they have claimed copyright on my music and monitized it. I, on the other hand, can't monitize it at all because my channel is very small. This is theft.
- raverbashing 7y agoIt's probably matching an existing recording, not the composition. (Which does not excuse YT or the claimant in the least for this BS)
- rtkwe 7y agoThat's clearly what's happening and it's the problem with the system, it has no way to determine if a song is actually the original recording or if it is an original performance based off of a public domain song played correctly the two will be largely identical (to the satisfaction of an algorithm designed to not be fooled by small pace changes in the different performances). It seem ridiculous that (it seems) the Youtube provided royalty free tracks aren't explicitly stored in the Content ID system as un-claimable songs. It would probably require modifications to privilege those matches before others but if you can't even count on music provided by YT I don't see how any creator could feel safe using any music in their work.
- e40 7y agoSame happened to me years ago, when I uploaded my son playing a piano piece written in the 1800's. Immediately locked. What a complete joke. It's theft and someone should be criminally prosecuted.
- chimi 7y ago
- buboard 7y agoIt should be possible to source-separate the music from any voiceover and surgically remove it. Google should implement this feature.
- mnm1 7y agoSo Google is encouraging illegal copyright usage to make other companies more profit. Do they at least get a kickback? And why doesn't the government go after them like they do after pirate sites then?
- rebuilder 7y agoThe update to the article seems pretty relevant. YouTube says the music is not from the official Youtube Audio Library, but could be from a channel titled "YouTube Audio Library".
- justinclift 7y agoIt'll be interesting, if this update turns out to be correct.
- tastroder 7y agoThere's plenty of people on Twitter specifically denying this, e.g. https://twitter.com/Matt_Lowne/status/1196928532510851073 https://twitter.com/Matt_Lowne/status/1196928532510851073
- rasz 7y agoand yet its right there uploaded under "Dreams - Joakim Karud [Vlog No Copyright Music]" to a channel with an enticing "Audio Library — Music for content creators (Verified)" name with "This channel is not an official YouTube channel." in the description. You can tell its in Content ID database because whole video clip is "protected" (web server will 403/wont play without Google generated crypto signature token).
- otterpro 7y agoThe music in question is Joakim Karud's "Dream" song, which was made famous when Casey Neistat used it for his vlog. It's also popular with Youtuber since Joakim's music are all free to use on Youtube. Apparently the song sampled from short guitar riff from a musician from the 1955. However, the samples are usually sped up or its pitch made high as to not be recognizable from the original source. It's unfortunate, because some of my videos use his songs.
- helloworld2019 7y agoHello! I need to finish my college homework, but I have no money to get survey responses…… If you have about a 1-minute spare, please help me do this simple survey with only 5 questions about Youtube recommendation system: https://forms.gle/5nmQFWxMX2P47wqx8 https://forms.gle/5nmQFWxMX2P47wqx8 Your response will be appreciated so much! Thank you very very much!