3 ms·
Ask HN: Do Apple Maps, Google Maps, Yelp, etc scrap local business listings? Local search still remains very frustrating. I'm baffled how stores, dr offices, p
by specialist 7y ago
Ask HN:
Do Apple Maps, Google Maps, Yelp, etc scrap local business listings? Local search still remains very frustrating. I'm baffled how stores, dr offices, public parks which I know exist don't appear in results. If I was doing the work, I imagine I'd start with every known address and every known business, try to pair them up, and then triage the remainder. Classic data quality efforts. No? I recall an OpenMaps presentation on measuring data quality maturity. Much like bug curves, where rate of changes is used to estimate completeness (coverage). Commercial map vendors do the same, right?
More selfishly, I'm always looking for places to run with my dog. I use a combo of Apple Maps, Google Maps, and AllTrails. I have no idea how local governments account for open spaces, but I imagine they're all in a GIS somewhere, and that Apple & Google have data feeds.
Also local data search (on mobile), if there's a way to geofence results, as in only show shit within my timezone, or even within driving distance, I haven't stumbled across that feature. Driving thru Phoenix, I don't want listings from Indiana, ffs.
- londons_explore 7y agoMap licensing is very tricky. Typically "open" government mapping data is incompatible with both openstreetmap and free Google/apple maps. Also, governments tend to be bad at mapping things they own. The guy who mows the grass knows where it is, so they don't spend money to make a map of it.
- maxerickson 7y agoUS states and counties often have extensive data that is available under what is basically a disclaimer. They don't really analyze or assert copyright. Google sucks that data up for sure. They buy data from some cities and counties too. It's hard to push through imports in OpenStreetMap when all you have is a disclaimer, but the data licenses are probably mostly compatible (public records laws requiring the release and things like that).