4 ms·
Ironically outcomes like this mostly vindicate the regressives. Any society who listened to the environmentalists; phased out fossil fuels and committed to rene
by roenxi 7y ago
Ironically outcomes like this mostly vindicate the regressives. Any society who listened to the environmentalists; phased out fossil fuels and committed to renewables in the late 90s or 2000s would have shot themselves in the foot for nothing. The further renewables prices drop, the more foolish committing to them early looks.
Gas prices is a different issue to that though.
- jayd16 7y agoWe might have prevented a fair bit of environmental damage in that time, even if we're just talking spills from deep water rigs. Price drops come from scale so if we scaled sooner the prices might have dropped sooner. It's impossible to say for sure though.
- ohples 7y agoWrong. People commiting to renewables early drive and support the market, which overtime drives down prices due to more and more people improving the tech and manufacturing process, which is what leads to the prices to come down.
- roenxi 7y agoPossibly that could have been done in a controlled and experimental fashion rather than condemning the infrastructure of entire countries to costing twice, thrice or more? Anyway the point stands. It isn't fair but the people who avoided being involved are going to be much, much better off than those that did.
- D_Alex 7y ago>infrastructure of entire countries to costing twice, thrice or more Citation needed. >the people who avoided being involved are going to be much, much better off than those that did Even if this was true, it does not "vindicate the regressives". We can't all expect to be able to mooch off someone else all the time. It does vindicate those people who were calling for a tax on the externalities of fossil fuels though.
- roenxi 7y agoThis was on the front page of HN just the other day - https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2019/11/france-spent-less-on-nuclear-to-get-about-double-what-germany-gets-from-renewables.html https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2019/11/france-spent-less-on-n... . And nuclear isn't even as cheap to set up as a fossil fuel supply chain. > We can't all expect to be able to mooch off someone else all the time. For technological improvements we actually can. In a way it is the norm. Most technologies start small somewhere, get economic, then scale up (albeit because they had no other choice). > It does vindicate those people who were calling for a tax on the externalities of fossil fuels though. Are these plants closing because of a tax on externalities? The article suggests the alternatives are cheaper in their own right. If coal plants become uneconomic without a somewhat artificial sin tax then the sin tax proponents aren't vindicated. They would be making an inevitable transition more expensive.
- paxys 7y agoPrices for renewables are dropping today precisely because there was a push for them in the 90s and 2000s. These shifts don't happen overnight.