4 ms·
I wonder if we're headed towards a hereditary aristocracy as well, because of assortative mating. People tend to marry others in the same social class; rich ma
by nostrademons 16y ago
I wonder if we're headed towards a hereditary aristocracy as well, because of assortative mating. People tend to marry others in the same social class; rich marry rich, smart marry smart, and highly-educated marry highly-educated. And then they tend to pass on those advantages to their children. It doesn't take all that many generations before that becomes entrenched and it becomes impossible to jump from one class to another.
- hackerblues 16y agoDo you have any reason to believe that this trend has not held throughout history?
- nostrademons 16y agoI think it's held throughout history, but then again, throughout history most of the world has had some sort of aristocracy. The historical exception is the U.S. from 1945 to 1973, as well as perhaps a few other examples (maybe Scandinavia today, or the U.S. in the early/mid 1800s?). In that time period - really, no more than a generation - we saw a big leveling of income distribution, where people born to modest families suddenly had the creature comforts that a generation before had been reserved for the aristocracy. I think most people would agree that this is a generally desirable state for a society, so it might be worth asking what was different about those time periods that made them the historical exception?
- xyzzyb 16y ago"You are descended from royalty":http://www.ancestry.com/learn/library/article.aspx?article=5921 http://www.ancestry.com/learn/library/article.aspx?article=5...
- philwelch 16y agoPeople can move up or down a social class or two. I know people who came from fairly little wealth who earn decent urban-professional six-figure salaries, and people come out of families in the upper-middle professional class and become multimillionaire entrepreneurs. (Likewise, other people move down.) Entrenched aristocracies happen when you have old money that looks down on the "nouveau riche". Every country has an old money class that considers itself more elite than the nouveau riche, of course, but they aren't really an entrenched aristocracy unless the rest of society agrees with them.
- forensic 16y ago>Entrenched aristocracies happen when you have old money that looks down on the "nouveau riche". That's not the cause of aristocracy, that's the effect.
- philwelch 16y agoIt's neither. It's just part of the aristocracy (the other part being the willingness of the rest of society to humor old money in their self-perception as being aristocratic).
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]