5 ms·
500 flushes is less than a year for a toilet used twice a day (say before and after bed), I hope that coating is cheap, easy to apply, and doesn't create substa
by gpm 7y ago
500 flushes is less than a year for a toilet used twice a day (say before and after bed), I hope that coating is cheap, easy to apply, and doesn't create substantial pollution either as it is created or used.
I hope the sewer system doesn't need to just add water as a result.
Toilet water use doesn't seem like a big enough contributor to the problem that it's much use optimizing it in most places. But there are probably some where water is locally scarce and it makes sense.
- HorizonXP 7y agoI tend to agree, but I (and maybe you) live in the Great Lakes region where water is abundant and cheap. Optimizing water use just doesn't seem worth it. But I can totally see this coating helping in regions like India, who have a real problem with open-air defecation.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- newen 7y ago...so to solve that, you would put this stuff on the ground so that shit slips easily into the nearest river?
- HorizonXP 7y agoI think you're deliberately misrepresenting what I meant. The current PM of India campaigned on a "Clean India" effort to tackle open-air defecation by building millions of toilets. Now, you can argue the efficacy of this effort, but arguably, the entire scheme requires adequate means to actually flush the toilets, which requires water, which requires infrastructure. All I meant is that efforts to minimize the amount of water required (i.e. the coating in the article) could be helpful here. Another place where this can be helpful is in areas that aren't covered by sewage infrastructures, like houses that are on septic tanks, or campgrounds/parks with outhouses. I'm not an expert on this matter, I'm just suggesting that I can see how it might be helpful.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y ago> the entire scheme requires adequate means to actually flush the toilets, which requires water The vast, vast majority of these toilets are basically just holes in the ground. They do not flush.
- HorizonXP 7y agoExactly. In our village, it was a latrine. We were lucky enough to have ceramic ones. When I first encountered this as a 4 year old, I was so disgusted with the idea of squatting over a latrine that my parents had to have a Western toilet installed in our house in the village. When I returned at 10 years old, I was more amenable to the idea. Every time you had to go, you had to fill a bucket of water from the well, and carry it with you to the outhouse. Then you’d squat over the latrine, do your deed, and then use a cup (a lota) to pour water over your backside, using the other hand to help rinse. Heaven forbid you had to do all of this at night. When I got back to Canada, it was the toilet that I missed the most. Now, I appreciate the sheer convenience and modern marvel that is modern plumbing and sewage.
- adrianN 7y agoComposting toilets seem much better suited for locations with scarce water, or scarce water infrastructure.
- gpm 7y agoI do live near the great lakes, but my comment about not worth optimizing is really just that as a percentage of global water usage toilets are tiny (compared to agricultural and industrial. Agricultural is 80-90% in the states for instance). Optimization only really makes much sense where locally that is false. There are definitely plenty of deserts in the world though, so it's not much of a nitpick.
- ac29 7y ago> Agricultural is 80-90% in the states for instance Actually, irrigation uses less than 40% of water in the US. The largest use is thermoelectric power generation. [0] [0] https://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/2018/3035/fs20183035.pdf https://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/2018/3035/fs20183035.pdf
- kortilla 7y agoInteresting. It’s not like water used for thermoelectric cooling becomes compromised. In many cases don’t they just return it directly to the supply after it cools down?
- hvidgaard 7y agoThe majority of that water is surface water - that is only used for consumption if there is no suitable groundwater reservoir, and it is returned. So the environmental impact is less that irrigation as that removes the water from the source.
- xiphias2 7y agoThe additional maintainance maybe doesn’t worth it for homes, but clean toilets would be important in commercial space.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sitharus 7y agoAs someone who lives in an area without water and sewerage services anything to reduce water consumption is a bonus, especially if it's biodegradable. Sure, a flush is only 3-4 litres but that could make the difference in a dry summer.
- gnicholas 7y agoSounds like it has to be applied to a dry toilet, further complicating the reapplication process.
- fireattack 7y agoYou only use toilet twice a day? Keep in mind you need to flush after pee too.
- gpm 7y agoI was being conservative, since the number of times any given toilet is used per day is pretty variable and the conservative result was already enough to say "this needs to be re-applied frequently".
- robocat 7y ago> Keep in mind you need to flush after pee too. When you only have restricted water, you shouldn't flush after peeing. There's even a saying to help conserve water this way: "If it's yellow, let it mellow".
- gnicholas 7y agoyou left off the ending: "if it's brown, flush it down".