48 ms·
The problem with this theory is that it doesn't align with facts. Google and most of the other major tech companies don't actually sell user data. They collect
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
The problem with this theory is that it doesn't align with facts.
Google and most of the other major tech companies don't actually sell user data. They collect it to use internally. The biggest companies who actually do that are the ISPs, but that doesn't really fit the same narrative, and I doubt they donate a lot to privacy groups.
The reason a lot of privacy groups don't try to restrict selling user data is a combination of a potentially legitimate first amendment problem with restricting it and a finite amount of political capital. Sometimes political capital has to be spent making sure that e.g. the FBI director doesn't push through a law against strong encryption. Sometimes it's better to have a bill that improves privacy a little and actually passes than a bill that improves privacy a lot but never makes it into law, or start with one that isn't as easy for Comcast to have struck down by the courts and in so doing create a problematic legal precedent.
Meanwhile you ask why Google and Facebook donate to privacy groups, but their goals are actually aligned on a lot of things, like promoting the use of HTTPS over HTTP and opposition to draconian copyright laws.
This is gotcha journalism, and it's problematic because what are you proposing as a solution? That privacy groups stop accepting money from tech companies? What that would do is cause them to have less money for privacy advocacy. Ask yourself who benefits from that.
- amilein7minutes 7y agoCould you explain why the restriction over selling user data would be a violation of first amendment rights? Overall, isn't your last point also the source of problems? If the whole idea is to be able to exert regulatory control, to protect users, over companies that seem to have a huge share on decision-making in this space due to their unmatched wealth, how is their parting with a minuscule portion of their wealth so they can potentially influence a decision made on the topic of restricting them, solve any problems in the first place? It seems like a stretch to suggest that privacy advocacy groups need money from tech giants to support themselves. I agree that every organization needs the money but the problem at hand is that every organization should not ideally depend on tech company donations because they have amassed the largest sums. Since this is the problem these laws are trying to address in the first place, I am not sure taking donations from tech giants would solve the problem, even if it doesn't exacerbate it (assuming for a moment that the tech giants are actually being a force of good here).
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Could you explain why the restriction over selling user data would be a violation of first amendment rights? Start with the premise that you're passing a law against people telling other people anything they know about you (especially if they would otherwise be able to without compensation), then add in the "money is speech" thing, which is existing precedent whether you like it or not. > If the whole idea is to be able to exert regulatory control, to protect users, over companies that seem to have a huge share on decision-making in this space due to their unmatched wealth, how is their parting with a minuscule portion of their wealth so they can potentially influence a decision made on the topic of restricting them, solve any problems in the first place? It seems like a stretch to suggest that privacy advocacy groups need money from tech giants to support themselves. Privacy advocacy groups don't just have binary existence where either they exist or they don't. Every dollar is more advocacy. And you can't have it both ways. Either the amount they receive is insignificant and consequently shouldn't affect their overall policy positions or it is significant and losing it would be a meaningful hit.
- pvg 7y agoStart with the premise [...] This sounds extremely vague and contrived - something something, the money is speech thing, 1A issue. We regulate all sorts of sales, data collection practices, etc, all the time. Can you find a concrete example, especially in a non-political, plain business-to-consumer context where such regulation has received 1A scrutiny? Even a description by Google or FB or their surrogates of such a potential problem will do. Every dollar is more advocacy. The question is advocacy for what. To square this circle you have to argue that the interests of Google and FB are aligned with the privacy interests of individual users - those are the interests such groups tend to claim to represent. This seems implied in your line of argument as I read it and, to me at least, appears glaringly inaccurate.
- ahelwer 7y ago> what are you proposing as a solution? That privacy groups stop accepting money from tech companies? What that would do is cause them to have less money for privacy advocacy. Ask yourself who benefits from that. This is a classic case of zooming in too far with your politics. You can maybe make this argument if you put blinders on and only consider the next best option in this exact political system, but really this is a paradigmatic example of Google & Facebook attempting both regulatory capture & crowding out organizations who would authentically advocate for users rather than gigantic corporations. If you wake up every morning and choose the least evil of the options directly in front of you without once thinking of the bigger picture, you go to some truly bad places.
- Someone1234 7y agoSo the facts are wrong because rather than selling the data directly they only exploit it themselves for profit? That only holds while ignoring the fact that most of that profit comes from third parties who they're effectively selling data access to (e.g. ads where the profit is from Google's ability to know which ads to put in front of which users, effectively selling that user's privacy for profit). Pointing out that ISPs are worse is really neither here nor there. Just because big tech isn't the worst does absolve them of criticism nor is a compelling argument for why we cannot talk about them lobbying for the law to allow them to continue to do what they're doing or even expand it. I'm not even going to try and address why we cannot have privacy because of "legitimate first amendment problem[s]" or because it would result in "law[s] against strong encryption." I don't consider those arguments to even pass the basic sniff test, they feel like throwing out every argument under the sun and seeing what sticks. Almost to Gish Gallop levels. > This is gotcha journalism That isn't what "gotcha journalism" means. Collecting facts, presenting those facts, and putting a negative spin on it isn't "gotcha journalism" because the journalist didn't trick Google or Facebook into doing these things, they're simply telling the public that they did. In fact the term doesn't really to apply to journalism outside of interviews, see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gotcha_journalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gotcha_journalism
- Nasrudith 7y agoYes the facts are wrong and there is a major difference between selling the data and using it. It is like the difference between a salesman asking a bartender what type of drinks you prefer and them having a transcript of everything you ever said in the bar.
- thfuran 7y ago>It is like the difference between a salesman asking a bartender what type of drinks you prefer and them having a transcript of everything you ever said in the bar. What? That's a difference in scale, not in kind.
- shadowgovt 7y ago
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 7y ago>Google and most of the other major tech companies don't actually sell user data. They collect it to use internally. Why do so many people think that these companies sell your data?
- shadowgovt 7y agoBecause people are profoundly bad at understanding how modern online advertising works and the companies profiting from it have done a notably bad job of consumer education. The most common behavior people observe that makes them think companies are selling their data is when they visit some site P that sells widget p and then on completely unrelated site Q they start seeing ads for p. The obvious conclusion to draw is that Q now knows they visited P. In reality, ad broker X knows the user visited P, and is satisfying queries from Q (really, from the user agent visiting Q) by vending ads for p to the user agent that is displaying site Q's content alongside that ad. But the ad and Q's content are generally sandboxed from each other the same way that your bank account login state is sandboxed from Q also (1). In reality, Q has no idea the user has visited P, but the content on the page strongly suggests that Q does. (1) note: It is possible there are holes in the security model that an unscrupulous Q could use to gather information on a user about their history on P; that's generally considered a violation of the ad vendor's policy and will get Q kicked off the ad network.
- edmundsauto 7y agoThere is also an element of people (esp. on this forum) who strongly dislike big tech companies, and want to use inflammatory language to strengthen their point.
- Shivetya 7y agowell politicians certainly can make hay of it, in fact they seem to be the biggest spreaders of misinformation. most don't get called out on it because of either that it sounds good or because people who could aren't in positions to be heard. throw these companies have lots of money to pay fines, suits, and campaign donations with, and the outcome is decided
- tus88 7y agoAnd this, ladies and gentlemen, is what a paid shill smells like.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoWait, I'm supposed to get paid for this? Who sends me the... is it a W.2 or a 1099? Somebody call my agent. I think I'm getting ripped off. That's funny. Was that meant as a joke? It's like the reverse variant of the fallacy of the article. You imply that I'm getting paid based on my positions, the article implies that they're taking positions based on getting paid. No consideration of the possibility that the same positions could be held without compensation.
- ben_jones 7y agoDoes Google BUY consumer data as Facebook does? Do any of Google's acquired companies buy or sell user data? Do any of Google's expanding enterprise products buy or sell user data? If the answer is yes to these questions Google may have a clear competitive reason to lobby for pro data selling/buying legislation to the detriment of users which may signal that these privacy advocacy groups may not actually be privacy advocacy groups as the article alludes to.
- Spearchucker 7y agoThe distinction is meaningless. My data, and data about me is collected against my will without my consent for a third party's financial gain. It, ALL OF IT, is wrong. There is no nuance that legitimizes ANY of it.
- Spearchucker 7y agoThe distinction is meaningless. My data, and data about me is collected against my will without my consent for a third party's financial gain. It. Is. Wrong. There is no nuance that legitimizes any, or even any part of it.
- brtt 7y agoEhhh, the 'collect it to use internally' is a bit inaccurate. While not literally saying 'here buyer is user data that we are offering to sell you' Facebook, Google, and every other platform do sell user-derived data to advertisers in the form of native audiences or other targeting products. 'Oh you want to to serve ads to individuals that shop at Uniqlo? Here's a list of profiles to target that have checked into a Uniqlo three times in the past 6 weeks'. 'New-Parents? here are inds that have dwelled on babies-r-us (I have no idea if they still exist) or clicked to learn more about a stroller ad that was served in their Instagram feed'. It's not 'here's all the activity data about Anthony Mouse', and user data is collected internally, but it is also baked into targeting products that they sell to brands and agencies.
- mic47 7y ago"Oh you want to to serve ads to individuals that shop at Uniqlo? Here's a list of profiles to target that have checked into a Uniqlo three times in the past 6 weeks" No, this is not true. It's more like "Oh you want to to serve ads to individuals that shop at Uniqlo? Give us your ad creative and we will show you to the profiles that have checked into a Uniqlo three times in the past 6 weeks" Additionally, at FB ads, often it's custom audience, and in that case it's "Oh you want to to serve ads to individuals that shop at Uniqlo? Give us your ad creative and list of email addresses of people you want to target and we show them your ads." (though you can actually do "similar audience" and so on.
- user601 7y ago> Google and most of the other major tech companies don't actually sell user data This is not correct. Google and Facebook may not sell PII directly to third party but most lower/medium size tech companies do sell PII to third party (insurers, credit co, erc) and most of them even say it explicitly on TOS or privacy policy. Now, because it's written deep down inside some TOS doesn't mean users are fully informed and people certainly are not making truly informed decisions. Now, the fact is: people do not understand whats going in and tech companies are abusing this. And the question is: are we OK with that?
- smnrchrds 7y ago> Google and most of the other major tech companies don't actually sell user data They certainly buy data [0]. Whether they are the seller or the buyer, they have vested interest to make sure the trade can continue. [0] e.g. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-08-30/google-and-mastercard-cut-a-secret-ad-deal-to-track-retail-sales https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-08-30/google-an...
- CaptainZapp 7y agoThat privacy groups stop accepting money from tech companies? Yes; absolutely! He who pays the piper calls the tune. If you accept money from a company, which is actually completely contrary for what you claim to represent you're compromised. Period.