3 ms·
In my opinion, debates are all about spin. They're too short to allow proper analysis of the responses, and mostly concern the personalities of the people. Two
by mcguire 7y ago
In my opinion, debates are all about spin. They're too short to allow proper analysis of the responses, and mostly concern the personalities of the people.
Two examples: T.H. Huxley and Samuel Wilberforce, and a round-table I once attended with Dijkstra and Larry Loucks of IBM, along with a couple of other professors who were completely outclassed by those two. EWD was slow and very precise, it was clear that he was thinking deeply about the topics, but he didn't actually say much in the time alloted; Larry was fast, facile, and rather shallow, he was of the IBM style (he who talks loudest is in charge).
- what-do-I-know 7y agoI agree that typical debates are far from perfect, but NY Times and many other media outlets are reporting a very biased slant on this topic. There’s effectively only one voice on the debate stage. We’ve seen this many times before. A cartoon character of a complex issue is created, and the media pump out clickbait stories based on that. What’s the most effective way to motivate a more accurate discussion of this topic?