5 ms·
Why is it that the definition of a “monopoly” on HN is “any company that does something I don’t like”? Have you seen the marketshare of the iPhone in Germany?
by scarface74 7y ago
Why is it that the definition of a “monopoly” on HN is “any company that does something I don’t like”?
Have you seen the marketshare of the iPhone in Germany?
- docdeek 7y agoExactly - Apple has about 20% market share in Germany (https://www.statista.com/statistics/461900/android-vs-ios-market-share-in-smartphone-sales-germany/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/461900/android-vs-ios-ma...). When 80% of people are using a competitor to your product, it’s hardly a monopoly.
- oceanplexian 7y agoIt seems like people are misinformed and think that "monopoly" means someone who has the all the market share. That's not how it works. A monopoly is the control or advantage obtained by an entity over the commercial market in a certain area, who uses that advantage (willfully) to fix prices or exclude competitors. Granted, control or advantage of the market is a component, but what really makes a monopoly a monopoly is the intent behind the actions of the entity. If a memo, or meeting minutes were to come out showing that Apple was signing exclusivity agreements, or disabling payment apps on the iPhone (NFC) to specifically put competition out of business, well then that would be monopolistic. By the way, even when this sort of behavior can skirt the law, it's still unethical. I'm not saying businesses need to actively support their competition, but seeking to put them out of business through backroom deals and price fixing is wrong. It's the antithesis of a free market and unfortunately is rampant in the tech industry.
- Despegar 7y ago>If a memo, or meeting minutes were to come out showing that Apple was signing exclusivity agreements, or disabling payment apps on the iPhone (NFC) to specifically put competition out of business, well then that would be monopolistic. I think people get confused because the way APIs work on Apple's platforms, effectively open to all subject to you agreeing to their license, that people don't realize there's no obligation for Apple to create APIs for anything. Literally every app or feature could be the result of one-on-one business development agreements.
- scarface74 7y agoExactly. For instance I don’t know of any other company that has access to Apple’s iTunes movie library to add movies that are considered as “purchased” when the movie is purchased from a competitor except for Movies Anywhere. Yet there is a setting for allowing access to your iTunes library for it.
- izacus 7y agoGermany just created that obligation for Apple.
- Despegar 7y agoNot necessarily. The law will be challenged in the courts and they'll have a strong case that it infringes their intellectual property rights.
- izacus 7y agoWhat court would this law be challenged at when its... a law built by lawmakers?
- colejohnson66 7y agoLawmakers can make illegal laws. Not sure how it’d work in Germany, but in the US, for example, it’d be challenged on the basis of constitutionality.
- scarface74 7y agoSo that still goes back to my other response and their is a reason that neither the US nor EU has ever defined “monopoly” as broadly as HN not-lawyers do. Every platform has certain technologies it doesn’t allow competitors to access and have exclusive deals. Should Apple be scrutinized because it harmed potential suppliers for its cameras and screens by making “exclusive deals” with Sony, LG, or Samsung for their respective components? Apple is not “price fixing”. Price fixing is when competitors get together to “fix prices” not when one company gives another company a good deal to be the “exclusive provider of X”.
- Youden 7y agoHere the market is "things that can be installed on iOS" or "NFC payment providers that can be installed on iOS", where I don't think you can deny Apple has 100% market dominance. You could argue that the market should be "things that can be installed on smartphones" but that ignores that people with iPhones really need things that work on their devices. It's akin to saying that if one company had a monopoly on car tyres, it'd be okay because people could just replace their car and buy a tractor with tractor tyres instead.
- scarface74 7y agoSo now that’s how we carve out “monopoly”? So in that case are the console makers monopolies? Does Apple also have a “monopoly” on music services that work on HomePods? Phones that take complete advantage of AirPods Pro? Should that be regulated too? Should we go after Apple because Google’s and Amazon’s voice assistants don’t work on the Apple Watch and the AirPods since Apple has a “monopoly on voice assistants that work on those devices?”
- mindslight 7y agoTo the extent that many of those conditions result from anticompetitive behavior (eg preventing interoperability), rather than a lack of outside development interest, probably.
- scarface74 7y agoSo now you’re saying that the government should tell every company that they must inter operate with third parties? Would you like that every piece of software you write to have features forced on it for interoperability before you can release it? Should every website and every web service also have a publicly accessible API? Do you want a government committee to decide when your service or software is interoperable enough before you can release it?
- mindslight 7y agoYou're strawmanning with an ominous "government committee", implying the situation requires deep analysis. But really, vendors are deliberately preventing interoperability with competing products through technical means such as digital restrictions management. If they stopped doing that, there would be no argument. After an item is sold to a user, that item shouldn't be working to undermine the interests of its owner. Those interests include being a market participant for other products to use with it. If giving a user the option to eg change a data source or trust authority would be too much of a mandate for specific development, then manufacturers can just fall back to releasing the basic documentation that would allow straightforward re-implementation. > Should every website and every web service also have a publicly accessible API? Sure, why not? Anything a user can do, a program representing the user should be able to do. The alternative is computational disenfranchisement.