7 ms·
Of course the monopolist is warning against having to allow competition to their market. Nothing to see there. If Apple Pay is so much better than what the ban
by izacus 7y ago
Of course the monopolist is warning against having to allow competition to their market. Nothing to see there.
If Apple Pay is so much better than what the banks offer (which it probably is), then there's no issue, people will continue demanding and using it. It will force Apple to improve their product over what the banks can do constantly and that's how we customers win.
- simonh 7y agoOne of the ways it's better is by being extremely secure, and anonymising customer data to ensure privacy. Their argument is that forcing them to allow other companies to implement parts of the system could compromise those advantages for consumers. I don't know if they're right, but then I don't know exactly what this law requires them to do, or what the implications of that would be.
- izacus 7y agoThe law demands that they allow non-Apple apps to use NFC to process payments. > Their argument is that forcing them to allow other companies to implement parts of the system could compromise those advantages for consumers. Why would that ever be the case? The demand is for Apple to extend that secure payment processing to other companies on their locked down platform, not to compromise their payment product.
- amluto 7y ago> One of the ways it's better is by being extremely secure, and anonymising customer data to ensure privacy. Can you clarify? As far as I can tell, Apple Pay looks more or less like a regular credit card, and it even has a credit card number that apparently never changes. Plenty of merchant apps will recognize Apple Pay users because they once used it at a different merchant. Security? The day Apple Pay prompts, on the phone, “authorize $X to merchant Y?” I’ll grant them a meaningful security improvements. Other than that, it’s just a contactless card with biometric authentication.
- briandear 7y agoAre you confusing Apple Card with Apple Pay? They are two different things. I can use my Chase card with Apple Pay. I can also use my Apple Card with Apple Pay.
- criddell 7y ago> it even has a credit card number that apparently never changes The credit card account number doesn't change but every time you use it, a new number token is generated and that is what the merchant sees.
- mercutio2 7y agoThis is a common misconception, but it is unfortunately not accurate. The Device Account Number is different for every device, but it is the same for all vendors, unless reset by the issuer.
- criddell 7y agoYou're right! I had misread how it works. TechCrunch describes it this way: > Apple provides a virtual card number and confirmation code (CVV) for the card in the app. You can use this for non-Apple Pay purchases online or over the phone. This number is semi-permanent, meaning that you can keep using it as long as you want. > But you can hit a button to regenerate the primary account number, providing you with a new credit card number at any time. This is great for situations where you’re forced to tell someone your card number but do not completely trust the recipient.
- Angostura 7y ago> It will force Apple to improve their product over what the banks can do constantly and that's how we customers win. Currently, I add my bank card to the Apple Wallet, tap my phone/watch on a terminal and payment goes through. It's not entirely clear to me how this ruling will force Apple to 'improve their product' from a consumer point of view. I'm not even sure what it will achieve, other than perhaps forcing Apple to engineer interoperability with institutions that don't want to accept ApplePay restrictions on privacy or simple UI.
- izacus 7y agoFor me it's pretty clear - it'll allow me to use my iPhone to pay for things since Apple won't work with my bank and my bank wants to support payments anyway. On Android my bank released their own app to process contactless payments. It works well and it's secure by all legal standards required here in EU. Even though Google doesn't support my region, payments work fine. This is an option that I want Apple platform to offer as well. Not that it's an OPTION - Apple Pay is still there and can still be supported and used by whoever. Noone is interfering with that.
- msh 7y agoApple does not prevent banks to release their own payment apps. There are several on the app store in my country.
- icebraining 7y agoNot to process contactless.
- Telluur 7y agoAlthough you are correct. Apple does deny access to the NFC contactless for payment applications.
- cynix 7y ago> Apple won't work with my bank More likely your bank won’t work with Apple because they don’t want to pay Apple a cut of the fees. > Note that it's an OPTION - Apple Pay is still there and can still be supported and used by whoever. It’s highly likely that if Apple opens up NFC access to bank apps, they’ll stop supporting Apple Pay and force you to use their app, so there won’t be an option.
- Matt3o12_ 7y agoI think the problem here is that Apple wants payments on the iPhone to be secure, easy and private. If they gave banks full access to the api, they would do what’s in their best interest (reusing CCs numbers accross vendors, making it harder to use more beneficial cards, less transparency). This would mean that paying on iPhone would be considered harder or more inconvenient then using a card because many consumers don’t know the difference between Apple Pay and their bank app’s payment system. It would also mean that fewer banks adopt Apple Pay, which is already not that great in many countries. I’m honest not sure if opening up the system would be a net benefit. There are certainly advantages to keeping it closed but we also miss many great opportunities with NFC because of that. I would expect Apple to open it up eventually, when users become used to using Apple Pay and expecting the same convinces from their bank app
- rat9988 7y ago> Apple wants payments on the iPhone to be secure, easy and private. I don't trust apple for that more than I trust my bank anyway.
- AmericanChopper 7y ago> I don't trust apple for that more than I trust my bank anyway. Having worked for many banks, I’d advise you to reconsider that position.
- wsy 7y agoIt is a simple matter of competition. As a customer, if I consider Apple Pay so much more convenient, I'll choose a bank which supports it. So banks are under pressure to either support Apple Pay, or create an equally customer-friendly offer. If I consider another offer better for me, I will use their App instead of Apple Pay. So Apple can't just enjoy their monopoly, but is under pressure to be the best option for customers.
- AmericanChopper 7y ago> It is a simple matter of competition. It’s most certainly not that simple. Anybody who wants to is free to compete with Apple, and many, many companies already do. But this is legislators dictating what 3rd party software Apple must support in its operating systems. Why stop there? Why not force Apple to support 3rd party providers as an alternative to iCloud? Why not mandate a 3rd party App Store? Why should Apple be allowed any control over which operating system or hardware features it exposes to 3rd parties at all? Why should Amazon be allowed to ship a kindle that only supports their book store?
- scarface74 7y agoWhy is it that the definition of a “monopoly” on HN is “any company that does something I don’t like”? Have you seen the marketshare of the iPhone in Germany?
- docdeek 7y agoExactly - Apple has about 20% market share in Germany (https://www.statista.com/statistics/461900/android-vs-ios-market-share-in-smartphone-sales-germany/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/461900/android-vs-ios-ma...). When 80% of people are using a competitor to your product, it’s hardly a monopoly.
- oceanplexian 7y agoIt seems like people are misinformed and think that "monopoly" means someone who has the all the market share. That's not how it works. A monopoly is the control or advantage obtained by an entity over the commercial market in a certain area, who uses that advantage (willfully) to fix prices or exclude competitors. Granted, control or advantage of the market is a component, but what really makes a monopoly a monopoly is the intent behind the actions of the entity. If a memo, or meeting minutes were to come out showing that Apple was signing exclusivity agreements, or disabling payment apps on the iPhone (NFC) to specifically put competition out of business, well then that would be monopolistic. By the way, even when this sort of behavior can skirt the law, it's still unethical. I'm not saying businesses need to actively support their competition, but seeking to put them out of business through backroom deals and price fixing is wrong. It's the antithesis of a free market and unfortunately is rampant in the tech industry.
- Despegar 7y ago>If a memo, or meeting minutes were to come out showing that Apple was signing exclusivity agreements, or disabling payment apps on the iPhone (NFC) to specifically put competition out of business, well then that would be monopolistic. I think people get confused because the way APIs work on Apple's platforms, effectively open to all subject to you agreeing to their license, that people don't realize there's no obligation for Apple to create APIs for anything. Literally every app or feature could be the result of one-on-one business development agreements.
- AmericanChopper 7y ago> Of course the monopolist is warning against having to allow competition to their market. What market is Apple monopolizing here?
- briandear 7y agoThe market for payments using Apple devices. The anti-Apple brigade desperately wants iOS to be Android, yet many of us buy Apple specifically because it’s not Android. We use Apple Pay because they know more about privacy and security than “John’s Community Bank” who would love to force their customers to use their own bank payment app that they had some Infosys guys in Bangalore write for them. Then the credit card companies will all make their equivalently shitty app that we then have to use.. so payments becomes a mass of disparate apps instead of the flawless Apple Wallet experience we have now that works on all your devices, including Mac. The critics of Apple Pay almost certainly haven’t used it on Mac, or Watch, because it’s pretty darned magical.
- hesarenu 7y agoThose Bangalore guys might have a hand in UPI. Transfer to anyone anytime. it's more then magical!!!
- izacus 7y agoThe market of iOS devices.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoBy this logic we can assume that every company in existence is a monopoly, by being the only company that makes their products and services?
- colejohnson66 7y agoSo Samsung has a monopoly on Galaxy phones?
- sbuk 7y agoCan we stop misusing words? A ‘monopolist’ does not have a market share of 20%. It makes any argument you have farcical. Competition? If we leave it to the banks we will have a slow, anti-privacy, insecure mess. I deal with banks in the cyber-resilience world, and these institutions do not have a clue.