3 ms·
It's not particularly insightful or correct. It is absolutely true that our traditional NATO allies (except maybe Turkey) cheapen out on defense spending in rel
by rayiner 7y ago
It's not particularly insightful or correct. It is absolutely true that our traditional NATO allies (except maybe Turkey) cheapen out on defense spending in reliance on U.S. protection. Their leaders admit that themselves: https://apnews.com/0229dd7556264040810d9e7f96f3aa0a/France%27s-Macron-urges-Europe-to-take-charge-of-own-defense https://apnews.com/0229dd7556264040810d9e7f96f3aa0a/France%2...
> In a speech to French ambassadors in Paris, Macron said “Europe cannot rely on the United States only for its security. It’s up to us to meet our responsibilities and guarantee our security, and therefore European sovereignty.”
Nobody has decided that "human life can ... be more peaceful" without military superiority. Now that Trump has given Europeans reason to be skeptical about America's commitment, there is already a push to build up Europe's military forces. Macron will increase defense spending by 35% over six years, reversing a decade of decline: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-france-defence/france-commits-to-boosting-defense-spending-by-35-percent-over-six-years-idUSKBN1FS18Q https://www.reuters.com/article/us-france-defence/france-com...
https://www.euronews.com/2019/04/29/eu-countries-increase-military-spending-due-to-growing-perceptions-of-russia-threat-report https://www.euronews.com/2019/04/29/eu-countries-increase-mi...
Ukraine is not a particularly good counter-example of that theory. First, Trump is the first U.S. President to exhibit some isolationist tendencies since Carter. But European disinvestment in defense has been going on since the USSR collapsed. Second, Ukraine is a former USSR country with a complicated history with Russia. It's not indicative of whether the U.S. would come to the defense of a real U.S. ally.
- jessaustin 7y agoParent already excepted "formal" allies, so we're not even talking about France. Incidentally, France is unique among the nations of western and central Europe in spending more than 2% of GDP. Ukraine (and Russia) spends more, but that's kind of the point: Ukraine is one of the few nations that rationally fears external aggression. Taiwan is another such nation. They don't imagine we'll go to war with China for them, anymore than we went to war for Crimea or Georgia. In general, nations that spend more than 2% of GDP on the military are more concerned with internal enemies and local opportunities for plunder than with a real war with another nation. The world ain't perfect yet. Even so, lots of nations in Europe, Latin America, Southeast Asia, etc. aren't afraid to spend reasonable amounts on armaments.