3 ms·
Sadly, courts will laugh and proceed. The same argument could be done for firearms – it’s just physics, and not even space/quantum physics. Really, a device pus
by wruza 7y ago
Sadly, courts will laugh and proceed. The same argument could be done for firearms – it’s just physics, and not even space/quantum physics. Really, a device pushing a small body to some direction via expansion of another body. It’s all bodies, you can’t stop people from surrounding them with these.
If adopted, a law will state “the piece of information for which format and representation cannot be detected in a considerable amount of time” and then a judge to decide. Send some random bytes and you’re in trouble.
- protomyth 7y agoCourts are not our worry. Politicians making the laws are the problem. We need to focus on those passing these laws and make them fear any law limiting encryption. Encryption isn't even complicated math, and can be done with a deck of cards. We need to emphasis there is no safe backdoor, and all politicians are doing is ensuring our money will be stolen and our pictures of our children will end up in the hands of perverts and freaks because of unencrypted data breaches. "Why do you want your constituents ripped off?" "Why do you want little Timmy's picture stolen by perverts?" Turn it around, make them the evil ones. The only real way to protect ourselves is to actually make this a voting issue and make the other side out to be the villain. Its been a while since politics was logical arguments and being a victim of these idiots is getting old.
- KingMachiavelli 7y agoLuckily speech (math, algorithms, etc) are protected in the US and many other developed countries so even when the PGP code was considered a 'munition', at the end of the day they couldn't/wouldn't bother charging the creator of PGP with exporting munitions[0]. Currently the same shame 'investigation' is occurring with 3D blueprints to print firearms[1] but it's almost certainly going to fall under protected speech as well. The difference between the two is that encrypted data can also be considered speech while the actual manufacture/printing of a gun can be regulated. The big IF at least in the US IMHO is whether the government can force private companies to not offer E2EE but there is 0% chance that encryption in general could be criminalized. i.e it will always be legal to send PGP encrypted text through WhatsApp or a private Chanel (self-hosting IRC, email, etc.) So the hypothetical law you proposed wouldn't be legal in the US. On the other hand, if major companies are forced to break their E2EE, it will make the rest of us stand out like a really sore thumb.