3 ms·
Wow. This article is truly terrible. > Youtube has one of the worst user experiences out there A bold statement, considering it’s the #1 video website in the
by dangus 7y ago
Wow. This article is truly terrible.
> Youtube has one of the worst user experiences out there
A bold statement, considering it’s the #1 video website in the world.
(Sub-quoted text)
> The ads are incessant, the up next related videos are horrible inaccurate, autoplay is a major pain, and for the last time NO I don’t want to sign up for youtube premium
The author doesn’t want ads but then doesn’t want to pay anything? How would anyone expect a video site to stream 4K video for free then?
YouTube Premium is a product I wish existed for many other social media sites like Facebook. It’s really an excellent option for heavy YouTube users (and includes a music service) and the author shouldn’t dismiss it.
Autoplay can be easily turned off in settings, that’s like YouTube 101.
Relevant videos are often quite within the wheelhouse of your history. And you don’t have to watch them, turn off autoplay and use your subscriptions tab or just search for what you want. They’re recommendations not mandatory entertainment.
> One part that really stands out is how bad is recommendation engine is, and one of the main reasons is so bad is that is the user cannot chose what their recommendations are based on
Yeah and? Is this a problem? Can you choose what’s in a newspaper or what comes back when you type something in a search engine?
Smashing the dislike button is not really a solution and it’s no wonder that YouTube is ignoring that input. The author watched the entire video to the end perhaps even in full screen and then hit dislike, YouTube’s algorithm actually knows they’re just lying because they have that information about your browser behavior.
- flukus 7y ago> The author doesn’t want ads but then doesn’t want to pay anything? How would anyone expect a video site to stream 4K video for free then? I guess I expected free/cheap hosting to scale enough for video by now. Little geocities sites used to only have a a banner ad and many others had free web hosting with their ISP or purchased some web space. We never evolved a video equivalent of this, probably mostly because youtube exists and could take billions in losses for years. There are distributed alternatives but I don't think any of them are quite like cgi-bin for video.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sp332 7y agoStreaming video is freakin' expensive. You have to pay upfront to transcode the video into many formats and bitrates, or pay more per stream to do it in real-time. Also pay for storage for all the video formats, and video takes a ton of bandwidth when you're paying by the gigabyte. (You could maybe run a video site with the quality and device-compatibility of a early-90's video site for free.)
- mattigames 7y ago> A bold statement, considering it’s the #1 video website in the world. Have you considered is the #1 number in the world despite its UI not thanks to it? Maybe more to do with the net effect of people uploading videos since 2006 more than being the best out of the competition. >Yeah and? Is this a problem? Can you choose what’s in a newspaper or what comes back when you type something in a search engine? Comparing a digital personalized experience like twitter/fb/yt offers with a newspaper may be not that apt.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dleslie 7y ago> The author doesn’t want ads but then doesn’t want to pay anything? How would anyone expect a video site to stream 4K video for free then? This, I think, speaks to the true tragedy of our freemium internet culture: users expect all services to be free of cost, free of nuisance, and heavily moderated and curated. Google and Facebook have come to dominate because they offer the best, or least worse, offerings in this regard; and their monopolistic role and ability to run services at a heavy loss has prevented meaningful competition.
- Mathnerd314 7y ago"free of cost, free of nuisance, and heavily moderated and curated." Wikipedia does that, basically. There are a few overzealous donation banners, vandalized pages, etc. but for the most part it's fine.
- xboxnolifes 7y agoWikipedia is amazing in its own right, but there is a significant cost different in hosting and serving text compared to hosting and serving video.
- c0nducktr 7y ago> Yeah and? Is this a problem? Can you choose what’s in a newspaper or what comes back when you type something in a search engine? Isn't YouTube, with all their analytical data, supposed to be smarter and more tailored for me than a print newspaper? Is that really where the bar is? > Smashing the dislike button is not really a solution and it’s no wonder that YouTube is ignoring that input. The author watched the entire video to the end perhaps even in full screen and then hit dislike, YouTube’s algorithm actually knows they’re just lying because they have that information about your browser behavior. If I watch a video, and choose to thumb it down, who are they to assume I actually want to watch more of that content, when I've specifically said I don't. This is just another case of a company thinking they're smarter than the users of the product.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- c0nducktr 7y ago> Yeah and? Is this a problem? Can you choose what’s in a newspaper or what comes back when you type something in a search engine? Isn't YouTube, with all their analytical data, supposed to be smarter and more tailored for me than a fucking print newspaper? Is that really where the bar is? > Smashing the dislike button is not really a solution and it’s no wonder that YouTube is ignoring that input. The author watched the entire video to the end perhaps even in full screen and then hit dislike, YouTube’s algorithm actually knows they’re just lying because they have that information about your browser behavior. Second, if I watch a video, and choose to thumb it down, who are they to assume I actually want to watch more of that content, when I've specifically said I don't. This is just another case of a company thinking they're smarter than the users of the product.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]