7 ms·
I'm curious why Al Jazeera has such a negative reputation in the US. Is their Arabic-language reporting different? I don't regularly follow them, but their Engl
by _delirium 16y ago
I'm curious why Al Jazeera has such a negative reputation in the US. Is their Arabic-language reporting different? I don't regularly follow them, but their English-language reporting seems to be professional and not greatly slanted whenever I've run across it. It's actually less obviously partisan, from what I can tell, than a lot of typical Western news sources (think MSNBC v. Fox News), even well-respected ones (think Libération versus Le Figaro), possibly due to their attempt to appeal to a fairly broad pan-Arab-world audience.
- neilk 16y agoWhen America was invading Iraq in 2003, al-Jazeera was called out by Bush and Rumsfeld as the network of terrorist propaganda. This was partially because it was the network of choice for Osama bin Laden to release his taped announcements, but also because they tended to report from a point of view that wasn't in line with American wishes. If you are interested in this topic check out The Control Room, a 2003 documentary about al-Jazeera and the Western media in the runup to war. The best part is when they're all holed up together in a military briefing center in the middle of nowhere; tension is high and all the differing agendas are laid bare. It seems to be available in full on Google Video. http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=3977004463731346350 http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=3977004463731346350
- vimalg2 16y agoJust done watching it since i found a copy earlier today. Makes the US military's spin sound like Goebbels all over again.
- neilk 16y agoI didn't get that sense at all. The US military are great at spin, but what's really amazing is the eagerness of the US media to be spun.
- jacquesm 16y agoThe secret word is 'access'.
- cosmicray 16y agoPart of that the result of the Vietnam Conflict. The US military did not control the spin of the daily war news, and suffered mightily as a result.
- aaronblohowiak 16y agoSome people believe that Al Jazeera is Anti-Israel, which would make it out of alignment with US foreign policy.
- idiopathic 16y agoYou know Al Jazeera is reporting the truth because every side is complaining it is against them. Every Arab country - including my own, Bahrain, has thrown out Al Jazeera at one point or another, for being "anti". For the record, for the Israeli side, I gather they actually (privately) like the station because it was the first Arab station to interview them. Whenever they report about an Israeli issue, they actually get an Israeli to talk about the Israeli point of view. The problem is not with Al Jazeera, it is that it is the only station with global reach that actually speaks truth to power, challenging those with power on any side. They alone remember that the journalist's role is to comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable. (The one exception is Qatar, which they never report on, but frankly nobody cares about that.)
- Pahalial 16y agoFrom what I understand, this stems largely from the fact that they were the only major news organization with an embedded presence in Gaza during the Israel-Hamas war (others being unable to get in after it broke out due to the lockdown.) Their ability to report the actions of the IDF and provide graphic images to back it up did far more to generate international condemnation of Israel at the time than any other voice. They played a similar role more recently with a reporter aboard the Mavi Marmara, although he was able to get far less real-time footage out.
- nborgo 16y agoAfter watching a little bit, its reputation seems unfounded. To anyone interested in streaming: http://english.aljazeera.net/watch_now/ http://english.aljazeera.net/watch_now/
- bane 16y agoBeing the source of news for most of the useless major U.S. news outlets at the moment is probably doing more to fix their image in the west than anything else I've seen in the past.
- orangewarp 16y agoI also think this is interesting. It seems like only yesterday that Al Jazeera was ridiculed by people as well as the industry in our neck of the woods around the time 911 happened and afterwards. Now that the stories are more aligned with our values they seem to be heroes at least amongst Internet circles. One take away perhaps is that people will consume what they want to hear. To navigate the complex world and gain a critical advantage is to understand that these outlets represent one perspective that to many people is very real, even if we personally don't agree. You could compare this in some ways to outlets like Fox News. I'm often skeptical about the reporting, but considering the number of people that do see this as their major meal of the day, I'm going to listen every now and then so I can try and understand where others stand and come from. News will always be inherently biased because people construct what is truth regarding their world. While we aren't directly involved in what comes out, we have the ability to process the stuff that comes in and make our own understanding.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoVery interesting question. I'll try to answer. I feel this way myself although I haven't taken much time to consume their material or examine why I have my opinions. I believe it was because that I figured that any network owned by a bunch of dictators from the Middle East wouldn't have my best interests, or the interests of the average citizen, in mind. Seems like I also remember OBL releasing tapes to AJ -- they always seemed to have a magic touch of finding these terrorism videos nobody else could get. From the rumors I heard, they ran so much pro-terror and anti-Israel commentary and opinion shows (in my mind) I began to think they were part of the problem and not part of the solution. I also remember quotes from some of their shows with the most ridiculous Islamist propaganda. Seems like there were some spying allegations involving their reporters too. And IIRC, didn't they have reporters/producers that were so close to insurgents that it was difficult for the U.S. Military to separate where journalism ended and where terrorism began? But thanks for asking that. I need to reexamine my feelings and make sure they are valid. Most of the items I bring up above I heard third-hand or from rumors. Perhaps they run a fine news organization and just have editorial content I might find objectionable. No reason to throw the baby out with the bath water.
- hcho 16y agoAFAIK they are now owned by a sheikh from Qatar not a bunch of dictators. Granted a sheikh is not a democratically elected person but it's a bit far from being a dictator too.
- nodata 16y agoWhile you're re-examining, throw in Russia Today (http://rt.com/ http://rt.com/). Not quite the same calibre, but interesting to watch your thoughts while watching it.
- protomyth 16y agoClips from Russia Today seem to end up on Reason.TV's podcast feed a lot.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- ErrantX 16y agoSystemic bias, plus negative media during the Bush period (i.e. Iraq war). I think receiving the Bin Laden tapes was probably what ruined their US reputation (which is ironic; seeing as getting those tapes is what any good, objective, media agency in that region should have been doing! :D) Al Jazeera is one of the best news sources I know of - they report on a region fraught with extreme opinions, differing cultures and a lot of nastiness (both from within and without). And manage to do it well/consistently. That is my impression of English Al Jazeera anyway, have no experience of the Arabic arm (and I feel it would be silly to automatically assume they are the same :)). Interestingly I find them a good source on Western stories too; when writing Wikipedia articles I will often use Al Jazeera both as a source & to cut down into the meat of the story - they tend to have a "back to basics" style of journalism. EDIT: BTW, over the Egypt issue I have been enjoying their coverage; a lot less flag waving than the Western media. They just had an interesting report about the problems of looting and thugs inciting violence in the crowds.
- berntb 16y ago>>Al Jazeera is one of the best news sources I know of Hrm, got any references for that? I just found this and posted on another thread: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_and_antisemitism#Yusuf_al-Qaradawi http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_and_antisemitism#Yusuf_al... In a sermon, which aired on Al-Jazeera TV on January 9, 2009 [...] "Oh Allah, take your enemies, the enemies of Islam. Oh Allah, take the Jews, the treacherous aggressors. Oh Allah, take this profligate, cunning, arrogant band of people. [...] Oh Allah, take this oppressive, Jewish, Zionist band of people. Oh Allah, do not spare a single one of them. Oh Allah, count their numbers, and kill them, down to the very last one." Edit: I realize that racist hate mongering and asking ghod for genocide is removed in the English versions... But can any sane person claim that those showing such content on TV is "one of the best news sources"?
- ErrantX 16y agoYou have a point; but that is more editorial (well, live "opinion") than the news side. I don't think such an incident is representative of a general trend at Al Jazeera. But the media all over the world has problems with anti-Semitism; just because they don't advocate death does not make it any better :)
- jdp23 16y agoGreat question and great discussion. As well as the topics other people mentioned, I'd also add two more things: 1) Al Jazeera's model and cost structure is incredibly threatening to large US media corporations, which influences their coverage 2) There's a fair amount of anti-Arab feeling in the US -- some political, some historical, some flat-out racist.
- pmorici 16y agoThis may sound cynical, but people like to hear a point of view they agree with. By being less partisan Al Jazeera is pissing 100% of the people off some of the time.
- arethuza 16y agoI don't think it's cynical at all - you see the same thing in the tech world when people try and do an objective comparison of two competing technologies, the comments that get the most hate are the ones trying to take a balanced view.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI don't think Al Jazeera is less partisan, they just have partisan biases that don't align with anyone in the west. One thing I observed while watching them - they have a very distinct pro-Arab bias. It's readily apparent if you watch their reporting on the occupation of Kurdistan and the occupation of Palestine (Arabs are the victim, whether they are the occupier or the occupied). That's partisan, but very few Americans have much of an opinion on it. The small minority with an opinion are pro-Israel and think Kurdistan is in Russia.
- _delirium 16y agoI do think they have a general pro-Arab bias, but that's sort of what I'd expect, and it's not particularly egregious I don't think. It's pro-Arab sort of in the way that most French media is pro-French, most Greek papers are pro-Greek, etc., and on the more moderate side of that spectrum--- it's not the Arab version of Jean-Marie Le Pen or anything.
- pnathan 16y agoThere is sort of a perception that they are - in part - a mouthpiece for Al Quaida and other hardline Islamist groups. Not completely different from, say, Fox and the Republican party.
- jdp23 16y agoI was surprised to see the parent downvoted. Some people do think AJ is at least partially a mouthpiece for AQ and Islamists; some people think that Fox is a mouthpiece for the Republican party. It's a defensible comparison, and not something others had said.
- martyhu 16y agoAl Jazeera is actually the only source that I generally read when I'm looking for actual news. They come off to me as not only significantly less biased, but also bring up issues that are missing from US newspapers. For example, I discovered on Al Jazeera that the US had begun its first stem cell test on humans. FYI,http://english.aljazeera.net/news/americas/2010/10/2010101123617207960.html http://english.aljazeera.net/news/americas/2010/10/201010112...