4 ms·
Is it time for the blue team to rediscover libertarianism yet? I do miss that aspect of the Bush II years. The general concept you're looking for here is "state
by mindslight 7y ago
Is it time for the blue team to rediscover libertarianism yet? I do miss that aspect of the Bush II years. The general concept you're looking for here is "states' rights".
I don't see what legal basis the EPA would have to nullify emissions standards of the individual states for cars registered there. But I also think Wickard v Filburn was a crock of power-agglomerating bullshit.
Hypothetically, could the federal government declare murder legal and preempt state laws because they disrupt the commerce of contract killing?
- khuey 7y agoWickard v Filburn isn't really relevant here because the Clean Air Act has a specific carveout for California.
- mindslight 7y agoThe need for that carveout is predicated on the assumption that the federal government has the power to regulate internal Californian activities in the first place.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- treeman79 7y agoCivil war settled that question.
- matthewdgreen 7y ago“States’ rights” has always been selectively enforced, and mainly exists as propaganda to justify specific policies to low-information voters. Before you laud the Bush administration on this, go look up their approach to enforcing Federal drug laws in states that legalized medical marijuana.
- mindslight 7y ago"laud the Bush administration" ?!! You grossly misread my comment. I meant I miss having more political common ground with many friends, as it was when their concerns were on the receiving end of the out-of-control federal government. During the Bush years, with the wars/gitmo/patriot act they were reading up on Constitutional law and buying guns. During the Obama years they switched to explaining how pushing people to buy into the corporate health "insurance" racket was a good idea. I've come to the conclusion that the main function of voting is to make the winning voters think they asked for the ensuing policies.
- tomohawk 7y agoMurder is also a federal crime. You can be charged under state law or federal law or both. Not saying it's right, but it is what it is If there is going to be an EPA, then the 14th amendment asserts equal protection of the law. So, states with their own emissions regime are actually nullifying federal law and violating equal protection. The incorporation clause of the 14th amendment would also be in play. How far this goes appears to be a constant battle in the courts and legislatures. The EPA itself is on shaky ground, as there is no authority granted to the federal government to create an EPA. Relying on the commerce clause is pretty lame, and barely a fig leaf. Generally when interpreting a text, the most specific statement is determinative, not the least specific.
- mindslight 7y agoI was talking about hypothetically if the federal government were to legalize murder, and was looking to push that ethic onto the states. > states with their own emissions regime are actually nullifying federal law and violating equal protection Erm, that does not make sense to me. What is legal is the intersection of the state and federal. If a state setting their own laws goes against "equal protection", then any concept of state sovereignty would be gone. Do you have any precedents backing up this line of thinking?
- ReptileMan 7y agoThe main problem with commerce clause is that in 2019 everything is interstate commerce.
- tomohawk 7y agoThe main problem with the commerce clause is that people don't know what it means, or rather, have conveniently changed its meaning. It gives congress the power to regulate interstate commerce. Regulate, as in: make regular or normal. Commerce between the states was not normal, and was subject to tariffs and other restrictions. This clause removes the power to restrict interstate commerce from the states. It's not a license for congress to enact any law that they want. If it was, what's the point of the rest of the constitution?