6 ms·
The problem is that it's hard to create a high status item. Say you invent the "US Govt. Certified Top 0.1% Badge" - do you really think Peter Thiel, John Pauls
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
The problem is that it's hard to create a high status item. Say you invent the "US Govt. Certified Top 0.1% Badge" - do you really think Peter Thiel, John Paulson or Alex Rodriguez will really give a crap?
Taxing existing luxury status symbols could work, and is very likely a good idea. Creating new status symbols is likely to fail horribly.
Also, the tax on certain neighborhoods neglects the very large non-status reason why those neighborhoods are valuable: proximity to something cool. Manhattan is expensive not just because it raises your status to live there, but also because if you work at Goldman Sachs, you are willing to pay $3000/month rent + ridiculous NYC income taxes to avoid a 1 hour commute.
I suppose we could also bring back the Sumptuary laws:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sumptuary_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sumptuary_law
- awakeasleep 16y agoWould they give a crap? Possibly, when you consider that the badge would symbolize an investment in the infrastructure that supports everyone's lives.
- justin 16y agoA special ID that gives you status isn't so hard to imagine: it is basically like the Black Card, which is actually pretty shitty in terms of benefits but rich people (and people who want to appear rich) want anyways because it is a status symbol you can whip out when ever you want.
- nostrademons 16y agoOne could imagine an ID card that gives you the right not to be violated & degraded in TSA screening lines...
- alsomike 16y agoMy tax plan is to eliminate income tax up to $90,000. After that, income is taxed at 100%. The government awards tax credits for everyone making less than that, so that everyone's salary + tax credits = $90,000. "But wait," you say "How will we incentivize entrepreneurs if they can't earn more money?" For everyone making over $90,000 (approx. 11% of the population), their pretax salary is used to assign them national ranking that's publicly available, much like a ladder tournament, which could be subdivided into regions, industries, etc. The rationale for this system is that we use one system - money - for two unrelated social purposes: reducing suffering and establishing status which incentivizes production. In my system, these purposes are less coupled. The $90,000 number was calculated by dividing the total US income by the number of workers, so this would need to be adjusted yearly. If this system was applied globally, the average salary would be $25,000 which is quite a step up for billions of people. It means that today, humans create enough wealth annually so that every two-parent household on the planet could live like the American middle class.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoOk - if your system is ever enacted, I'm cutting my work hours back by 50% or more. I'm also hoping that not everyone does this, because if everyone did, there would be far less than $90k/person floating around. But that won't happen, right? It means that today, humans create enough wealth annually so that every two-parent household on the planet could live like the American middle class. This assumes that the total cost of providing the same middle-class resources to everyone in the world is equal to the present marginal cost of doing so.
- alsomike 16y agoThat's fine, you'd get 50% of the tax credit.
- joelhaus 16y agoSounds a little bit like the NFL: http://www.realfootball365.com/articles/nfl/14905 http://www.realfootball365.com/articles/nfl/14905 The major sports leagues in the U.S. (football/basketball/baseball) are definitely an interesting microcosm of various economic systems.
- getsat 16y agoYou might want to go read Atlas Shrugged.
- LiveTheDream 16y agoIf the plan provides for everyone to earn 90k regardless of what they actually do, there is no incentive to be productive at all, (much less to be productive enough to account for those who produce very little). Having my name on a list as the X most productive person is not incentive. Being able to spend the money I earn, is.
- nostrademons 16y agoWhat do you need to spend money on that you can't afford with $90K? And why do you want to buy it over something that you could afford? In my experience, virtually everything that falls into that category is some sort of status symbol. The grandparent poster is suggesting replacing these implicit status symbols with an explicit one. The part about his proposal that I'd miss is the ability to save up your high income for a few years so that you could compensate for a low income the next few years, and then do something more interesting during that time. But if you're earning $90K regardless, that wouldn't matter, because you'd be able to do the more interesting stuff anyway. Actually, that leads to the real problem in his proposal: you lose the information-carrying capacity of money. I'm basically ambivalent about most of my income over a number that's a lot less than $90K; I don't spend it anyway. But if I'm faced with two jobs that look equally interesting, I'll take the one that pays more; the additional money is a proxy for how much that business is valued by the marketplace, and I'd rather work on things that will make lots of people happy. Same with when I start a business: there're lots of projects that are interesting, but profit is a way of telling which ones are interesting and useful to others. OTOH, a stack ranking does that as well. The problem with the stack ranking is that you can't pass along that surplus down the value chain. So, for example, if you provide some useful service and that service would be made more useful if you could hire a graphic designer to make it pretty, you wouldn't be able to, because the government would take the money you would otherwise have paid the graphic designer.
- eavc 16y agoYou could maybe reward the wealthy in the same way people currently reward philanthropists -- offer to name things for them.
- elai 16y agoThe top %0.1 card that basically give's tourist visa-free Permanent Residency status in nearly every country in the world? Kind of like clear/nexus cards for immigration? That would be an awesome 'status' badge.