2 ms·
While this article is correct and talks about Ioannides's work—which is good, respectable stuff by the way—it does paint a picture like this should be a shock t
by KirinDave 16y ago
While this article is correct and talks about Ioannides's work—which is good, respectable stuff by the way—it does paint a picture like this should be a shock to you.
Folks, it isn't just medicine; Science in general must be comfortable with the proposition of being wrong. The more complex the field, the more often replication will fail (and the tighter standards need to be). There are very few pursuits that our race engages in that are more difficult than understanding life itself.
One of the biggest problems is that physicians and the press tend to get very hasty with pushing new research. It's not their fault, mind you, they're trying to inform us about health. If a doctor could save a life with an experimental treatment that has yet to reach thorough replication, shouldn't s/he? And it's the media's job to get us interesting new stories (albeit they could be far better at putting their information into context).
The nature of science is such that refinements occur over time. Unfortunately, the nature of most people receiving medical treatment is to believe it works or doesn't work based of extremely subjective data. If we want to attack that problem head on, we should begin with education. All the improvements in methodology imaginable cannot stop science from being what it is, and as such cannot eliminate the sawtoothed slope of medical progress.