3 ms·
>It takes some amount of privilege to take part in the conversation that he describes. A person needs literacy and free time, for starters Well, duh. We don't
by coldtea 7y ago
>It takes some amount of privilege to take part in the conversation that he describes. A person needs literacy and free time, for starters
Well, duh. We don't consider someone competent in something if they don't have basic skills and put the hours in to study/try it. So why would art criticism (whether professionally or to have a "good taste" as a consumer of art) be different?
If it's a privilege, it's the same kind of privilege required to be anything: a cook, a runner, a historian, a programmer, etc. Yes, you need to have time to do those things, and for most you also need literacy. Heck, you also need the same time and literacy to be an musician, a novelist, etc -- so it only makes sense it would need time to understand the craft and recognize good ones.
Someone working their ass off because they're poor, might never be able to e.g. read enough books, study how the genres work, read about their history, and ultimate develop a good taste in literature.
But that's a problem we should fix at the equality/free time front. Not a problem with having a taste in art requirements being "snobbish".
- jmilloy 7y agoIt is privilege not because it requires time, but because it generally requires free time, outside of how you make your living. You can't apprentice as someone who consumes art. As for snobbishness, you have it backwards: no one is saying that snobbishness is required to have good taste, but that the privilege required to develop good taste results in good taste being, or being labeled as, snobbish.
- Fricken 7y agoI was priveleged enough to have a library card, and developed good taste using that.
- coldtea 7y ago>It is privilege not because it requires time, but because it generally requires free time, outside of how you make your living. That's the case for all kinds of things that are not jobs but people still want to have an opinion on. Besides, your very distinction is based on the idea that a job someone happens to work is the same as the field they want to work or have an opinion on. Which is not always (even rarely) the case. If I work at McDonalds but aspire to be a programmer, surfer, rapper, journalist, writer, director, whatever getting competence to criticize/have an opinion about that other field (or, even more so, land a programming gig) also requires that I have a free time from "how I make my living". >As for snobbishness, you have it backwards: no one is saying that snobbishness is required to have good taste, but that the privilege required to develop good taste results in good taste being, or being labeled as, snobbish. And my point is, there's no "privilege" or no more "privilege" than any other endeavour one needs to spend time to learn and understand. Everything takes time and effort to achieve, why would "good taste" be any different? Is being a surgeon "snobbish" because you need to study to become one? Plus unlike learning about art, it takes not just free time, but decade of attending classes, plus lots of money.