4 ms·
While true, I don’t think it’s as counterintuitive as presented as it doesn’t mean the procedures are unwarranted. It’s only a useful study if deaths over the
by prepend 7y ago
While true, I don’t think it’s as counterintuitive as presented as it doesn’t mean the procedures are unwarranted.
It’s only a useful study if deaths over the entire period also drop, and they don’t. It just moves deaths to the other dates, not reduce them.
For example. If a procedure has 20% chance of death and 80% chance of improving mortality, the more procedures done, the more deaths on the date of the procedures. But overall mortality is reduced.
So the conference just means fewer procedures that week, but not fewer procedures for the year. The procedures just get done before or after the conference with the same rate of death.
I love Gladwell’s stories, but he frequently tells pithy little vignettes that aren’t actually true. He brought up this factoid during his recent appearance on the Joe Rogan Experience.
- billfruit 7y agoWhat interest I had in trying to read Gladwell at some point, has now dissipated after reading this explanation. I wish if writers would be less hypebolic with their presentation of their matter.
- correct_horse 7y agoAs a concrete example of Gladwell's lack of depth, see Igon Value (misspelling of eigenvalue). https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Igon_Value_Problem https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Igon_Value_Problem
- NotSammyHagar 7y agoWow, he really did that? They don't have adequate fact checkers either.