4 ms·
That's lying with statistics. What matters isn't the daily death rate, but life expectancy. If a procedure has a 10% chance of killing you, and a 90% chance of
by TylerE 7y ago
That's lying with statistics. What matters isn't the daily death rate, but life expectancy. If a procedure has a 10% chance of killing you, and a 90% chance of extending your life by 30%, it's a net win.
- Retric 7y agoThat doesn’t always mean you should have the surgery any time soon. Suppose that surgery can be put off for 10 years without any loss of effectiveness or short term risk of death. Now you’re going to wait even if it’s eventually a good idea. Some people that either have the surgery or waited are killed off by other issues, making the waiting group have a higher expected life expectancy overall. That’s just one example where seemingly useful treatments are less useful than initially assumed.
- raverbashing 7y agoOr 10 years later the surgery is seen as less or more effective, or a better version of it is developed.
- perl4ever 7y ago"If a procedure has a 10% chance of killing you, and a 90% chance of extending your life by 30%, it's a net win." I think it obviously depends on the specific probabilities and your current life expectancy, not to mention whether you are risk averse when it comes to the possiblity of immediate death. For me, based on actuarial tables, I should expect to live for 36 years more. So the net expected gain with your example numbers is (0.9 * 10.8) - (0.1 * 36) = 6.1 years more. So that's a net benefit of ~17%, at a significant risk of dying right now. If it was normal to like that kind of deal, why would we buy insurance? Also, there's something fishy about the problem statement in the first place, because a successful operation doesn't extend your life by 30%, unless nothing else was going to kill you before your originally anticipated lifespan.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tomjakubowski 7y agoSuppose you've just had a newborn. The doctor offers to perform surgery on your child which 10% of the time kills them, and 90% of the time extends their life expectancy 30%. Do you agree?
- TylerE 7y agoAbsolutely.
- tomjakubowski 7y agoI don't think so. All else equal, a 75 year old is more likely to drop dead tomorrow than a 25 year old (or healthy newborn) is, so the 10% death probability is less of a problem for them. Moreover, the years at the end of one's life are not quite the same as years of youth.
- TylerE 7y agoThat's exactly why this is an _easier_ question for a newborn... the 30% is on their entire life and not their remaining years. Like, if the upside is living to 80 instead of 50, that's easier than it being the difference between living 5 months and 6 months.
- cgriswald 7y agoSure, but that 10% chance for a newborn represents basically their entire life while for a 50 year old it’s a life mostly already lived.
- oldgradstudent 7y agoObviously not. No sane person would believe such a promise. Just imagine the scale and length of the clinical trials that would be required to test such a claim.
- paulcole 7y ago> That's lying with statistics That’s Malcolm Gladwell’s bread and butter.