4 ms·
My dad tried to buy the mortgage on our family home from the local bank. It was at a time of rapidly rising interest rates, and according to the textbook calcul
by analog31 7y ago
My dad tried to buy the mortgage on our family home from the local bank. It was at a time of rapidly rising interest rates, and according to the textbook calculation, our mortgage was costing the bank to hang onto. He figured out the fair market value of the mortgage, and offered to split the difference with the bank. Each side would profit.
The banker's first reaction was: This can't be real. A week later, the banker called my dad back and said: Sure enough, the numbers say that we should sell you your mortgage. But we also found out that it's illegal.
I don't know the details of why it might have been illegal, but it was an amusing episode.
- pedrocr 7y agoIsn't buying your own mortgage from the bank just the same as negotiating conditions to pay off the whole mortgage early? Why would that be illegal?
- Simon_says 7y agoThe dad wanted to pay less than the balance of the mortgage.
- gizmo686 7y agoWhich isn't normally a crime. The lender is allowed to forgive part of a loan if they want to. The borrower would owe taxes on the difference. Normally this comes up with people who aren't paying at all, where the lender (or owner of the mortgage) is happy to salvage any money from the loan, even if less then the face value.
- DennisP 7y agoPeople sell mortgages all the time. Is it just illegal to sell a mortgage to the borrower? If so, suppose two borrowers team up and buy each others' mortgages?
- analog31 7y agoIn response to both the posts here, I don't know. It also could be that the banker was full of it. On the other hand, I could imagine a sort of moral hazard situation where someone could take out a loan, let it go into default, and then offer to buy it back at a massive discount.