3 ms·
You don't need to "expropriate" anyone, and I'd rather not experiment on the folks running the companies (Google, Microsoft, Apple, etc.) that make America the
by rayiner 7y ago
You don't need to "expropriate" anyone, and I'd rather not experiment on the folks running the companies (Google, Microsoft, Apple, etc.) that make America the envy of the world.
Folks at the top 30% mark still benefit from income inequality. (That is to say, they earn a larger share of national income than their share of the population.) If you tax the entire top 30% an average of 25% you could increase revenues by double what Warren's proposed wealth tax would bring in. (And you wouldn't risk driving businesses and jobs to Canada.)
- perl4ever 7y agoBut folks (Sundar Pichai, Satya Nadella) running large companies are not usually billionaires. Bill Gates isn't running Microsoft any more, you know. And if he was, what difference does it make to anyone exactly how many billions in stock he has? The difference is the delta between the benefit of his charitable efforts and what anyone else would do with the money, and the parsimonious assumption is that it's about zero. Since, you know, he didn't get rich by solving the problems he's trying to solve now.
- rayiner 7y agoThe difference is that soon as he gets successful, he reincorporates Microsoft in Vancouver BC. Or people like Musk, who continue to use their personal wealth to bankroll new companies, move to Toronto.
- pen2l 7y agoThat's not the only single factor for them to consider though. I doubt Musk would move to Toronto, or that he would ultimately benefit from moving to Toronto in the long run were these taxes to go in effect. Of the sea of other things to consider, including the pool of candidates, the business culture, the social culture, the infrastructure already in place, types of grants available, the federal funding available (which can come with strings attached, like: "you gotta stay incorporated in the States"), etc. it makes sense for them to stay in America more than any other place. Not to mention, the safety that is here for these people and their children, the great schools, the best medical care, their ties, and so on.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- perl4ever 7y agoI have no idea who benefits from corporations being incorporated in Delaware, but I (and the vast majority of Americans) don't live there and I don't care. The location of incorporation is not the headquarters or where the workers are. This "Atlas will shrug" thing is trite posturing, not to say that there cannot be other drawbacks to populist revolutions. From Matt Levine's column describing people threatening that Argentina will become "uninvestable" if it doesn't do what bondholders want: "[Argentina] defaulted in 2001, imposed 70% haircuts in 2005 and 2010 restructurings, was in default on interest payments on the new restructured bonds from 2014 until 2016 due to legal disputes, finally cleaned up its act and returned to the international bond markets in 2016, and then in 2017 issued a hundred-year bond that international investors lined up to buy. Now those bonds trade at about 40 cents on the dollar, and international bond investors have the gall to be like “well if you default nine times we won’t lend to you a tenth time,” come on. They bought 100-year bonds one year after the last default ended! “There is a limit to what they will endure,” sure, but after two centuries of diligent searching Argentina hasn’t found it. "
- rayiner 7y agoIt’s not an “Atlas Shrugged” point. What’s the difference between Bangladesh and America? It’s not that we have more people with bachelors degrees in psychology. It’s not that we’re smarter. Or nicer. It’s partly our civil society and lack of corruption, but a big part of it is access to capital. We have Silicon Valley. Bangladesh does not. My family left Bangladesh for the US 30 years ago because America offered more opportunities. What does that mean? It means there was capital available to do things and build things. Interestingly, some of the latest generation of my family aren’t leaving. Amazingly, over the last 20 years major increases in foreign direct investment have resulted in opportunities in Bangladesh. Not for John Galt. But for young programmers looking to join a tech startup: https://www.forbes.com/sites/theyec/2018/08/02/why-bangladesh-is-making-waves-in-the-tech-scene https://www.forbes.com/sites/theyec/2018/08/02/why-banglades.... Taxing away your capital is like selling your furniture for quick cash. You’re not skimming the fat, you’re cutting into muscle and bone. As to Argentina, it had to offer a 7.9% interest rate to move those bonds in 2017. If we refinanced our national debt at those rates, we’d be paying $1.5 trillion a year on debt service, about what we spend on Medicare/Medicaid and defense out together.
- selimthegrim 7y agoIf Pichai is making $100m a year it won’t be long