3 ms·
Notes on scheduling for anyone who wants to follow along: Google now has 45 days to file a brief on the merits that explains their position. Once that is f
by gpm 7y ago
Notes on scheduling for anyone who wants to follow along:
Google now has 45 days to file a brief on the merits that explains their position.
Once that is filed, Oracle has 30 days to file a brief on the merits that explains their position.
Google then has 30 more days to file a reply to Oracle's brief. That brings us to the 28th of February, assuming everyone uses all their time (and no more).
The court can extend all those deadlines.
Once all the briefs have been filed the case will (probably) be scheduled for oral argument. It looks like oral argument is usually scheduled several months out, and the last day for oral argument this term is April 29. It might meet that deadline, otherwise it will be pushed to next October. If the oral argument is heard this term then we can expect a ruling by the time the court goes into recess for the year (end of june).
Of course a ruling doesn't mean the case is over, it may well then return to lower courts for more argument. (It almost certainly will for various details, like attorney's fees and/or damages).
This case started August 13, 2010. It's been almost a decade. Something is very wrong with how our court system functions.
- kijin 7y agoA decade is obviously too long, but there is some value in taking a long time to decide important matters. If you rush everything in a short time span, you risk getting carried away by the public opinion and political environment of the moment. This can be especially problematic when it comes to the kind of deep constitutional issues that we expect the Supreme Court to grapple with; the court needs to keep a certain distance from the propaganda du jour. Besides, it's not uncommon for people on the death row to dig up evidence that exonerates them many years after the case was deemed closed. If we sped up the whole legal system and carried out sentences asap, they might not have been given enough time to do so. Meanwhile, the system can be surprisingly agile if it needs to be. New York Times Co. v. United states only took 12 days from the first hearing to the Supreme Court ruling! Of course that was because Nixon wanted to rush the case, but in the end he lost hard and the heat of public opinion probably didn't help, either. In the case of Google v. Oracle, nobody seems to be particularly in a hurry. Both sides can afford to drag out the dispute as long as they want to.
- gpm 7y agoI mean, it's a fair point that the schedule of this case doesn't matter that much. But cases of nearly every sort take too long. To be honest I mostly included that line out of frustration with a Canadian Supreme Court ruling today, that said having a juvenile trial go on for 18 months can be "sufficiently speedy". Which is definitely off topic here, but still one I consider important. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/supreme-court-youth-justice-1.5359939 https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/supreme-court-youth-justice...
- kijin 7y agoI agree that it's ridiculous to drag a kid through the legal system for 18 months. Ideally, criminal cases involving minors (and individuals in general) need to be fast-tracked, and there should be a strict limit (measured in weeks, not months) on how long prosecutors can take to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that somebody committed a crime. If they can't prove it before the timeout, the defendant goes free. This should also reduce the incentive to stack one frivolous charge upon another for psychological effect. Aaron Swartz committed suicide just over two years after he was first arrested. He never faced an actual trial during those two years, only an endless series of indictments with minor changes. But as I said, this is a double-edged sword. People need time to collect evidence and arrange witness testimonies, so insisting on a quick resolution could create bias in favor of those who can pay for a lot of lawyer-hours up front.
- zucker42 7y ago> This case started August 13, 2010. It's been almost a decade. Something is very wrong with how our court system functions. For civil cases between large companies, this speed doesn't seem entirely terrible. Criminal cases and civil cases between individuals are another story.
- nojvek 7y agoA decade tho. If this was between a startup and Oracle, the startup would have long been crushed by stalling. I don’t understand court systems but man I would love to have some sort of SLA.