2 ms·
I think the rules against sabotaging others' commerce are good rules; a moral person would follow them even if they weren't written down. Also, even if you get
by gojomo 16y ago
I think the rules against sabotaging others' commerce are good rules; a moral person would follow them even if they weren't written down.
Also, even if you get the desired headlines and attention, I don't think you score points against bad rules by violating good rules. I believe more people concluded Anonymous/Wikileaks are vandals and bullies from hearing about (or being affected by) the DDoS attacks, than came around to sympathy for Wikileaks.
So orthogonal from any 'letter of the law' analysis, it was an immoral and counterproductive thing to do.
If the 'sit-in' directly blocked the objectionable activity, a different analysis might apply. (And, more bystanders might be sympathetic.) But this, and most other 'sit-ins' I've seen, are just rudeness for attention. Moral and effective activists will choose other tactics.
And regarding: "its important enough that the consequences are irrelevant"
That way lies zealotry, madness, impotence, chaos. The real consequences always matter. The advocate who forgets, in their passion, that consequences matter becomes others' tool, often against their own interests.
- steveklabnik 16y ago> I think the rules against sabotaging others' commerce are good rules; a moral person would follow them even if they weren't written down. I agree with your statement on its face, but there are certain times when it's okay to break the rules. Sometimes you have to do bad things to achieve good ends. No action is ever white or black, there are only shades of gray. > If the 'sit-in' directly blocked the objectionable activity, a different analysis might apply. They did disrupt. Maybe not as much as Anon would have liked, but they did.
- gojomo 16y agoYou're misreading directly blocked to mean something else, what you want it to mean, general disruption. Directly blocking the objectionable activity would be something like blocking a disputed eviction, or preventing the deployment of people/resources that are necessary to enforce a bad law. The disruption actually stops or reverses the objectionable activity, for the duration it can be maintained. That's targeted, and far more understandable as a (possibly) principled, non-hypocritical tactic. Disrupting other things, because you hope to break your opponents with discomfort inflicted through uncivil means, is what crosses the line, a line beyond simply 'law'.