4 ms·
But you don't actually know that this practice is wasteful. That all depends on the numbers. Let's say that Amazon sends out 100 books, and 1 or 2 get damaged.
by dangus 7y ago
But you don't actually know that this practice is wasteful. That all depends on the numbers.
Let's say that Amazon sends out 100 books, and 1 or 2 get damaged. But if they add some extra bit of packaging to every single one of those 100 books, zero will get damaged.
Did this save cost or materials? I don't know, it depends on how much extra packaging was needed, whether the damage was serious enough to initiate a refund/re-send, and whether adding packaging to every single order was less environmentally impactful than having to print and send an extra book to those who received damaged ones.
It's going to be a simple dollar value equation for companies like Amazon, and make no mistake, they have the data and have made these decisions consciously.
- fenwick67 7y agoI think the poster may have meant "a waste of a good book" not "a waste of money". It's like how throwing produce away at the grocery store is "a waste" but the system is cost-effective.
- LordDragonfang 7y agoThe environmental impact of extra plastic packaging is much greater than the impact of compostable produce. And anyway, if Amazon has to ship extra books, they pay the publisher an extra time, and you can always donate the damaged book as well.
- AlexandrB 7y ago> It's going to be a simple dollar value equation for companies like Amazon, and make no mistake, they have the data and have made these decisions consciously. I suspect they're not counting the damage this is doing to their brand. I've kept items that were slightly damaged, but it slowly eroded my trust in Amazon. Now I avoid Amazon if I can help it.
- wpietri 7y agoIf it's a simple dollar-value calculation on the part of Amazon, then it's sure to be wasteful, in that negative externalities will be ignored.
- perl4ever 7y agoIs that a sensical definition of waste here? The difference in externalities has to be greater than and opposite to the delta in cost, in order for their decision to be wrong, I think. Just because externalities are ignored doesn't prove anything in particular if you don't know the relative change.
- wpietri 7y agoFair point. Let's say, "Sure to be wasteful compared with a decision that takes everything into account." Or, more simply, "Sure to be more wasteful." Although for the people who experience the negative exernalities, by their account it will always be wasteful, in that they only experience costs, not gains.
- perl4ever 7y agoWell, I'm specifically saying that it's not sure to be wasteful compared to a more informed decision. That's a general fact about the world, that making decisions on incomplete information does not necessarily produce worse results. Sometimes things turn out better than you expected and sometimes worse. People are often significantly biased, but that's separate from the issue of not taking "everything" into account. It also seems obviously wrong to say that a negative externality is or should be considered in isolation. It's just silly to say that people who experience negative things only experience negative things or that any category of things that includes negative things must be net negative.
- wpietri 7y agoWell if I'm saying a lot of things that are taken as just silly, clearly this discussion is wasteful of my time.