3 ms·
Is getting docked points for bringing religion into an answer on physics, or biology, or chemistry religious discrimination or is it requiring an answer to be g
by pc86 7y ago
Is getting docked points for bringing religion into an answer on physics, or biology, or chemistry religious discrimination or is it requiring an answer to be germane to the question?
If I'm asked a question in a biology exam and I start talking about computer science, losing part of the score doesn't seem completely egregious.
- krapp 7y ago>Is getting docked points for bringing religion into an answer on physics, or biology, or chemistry religious discrimination or is it requiring an answer to be germane to the question? IANAL but reading the text of the law, I honestly can't tell. It seems like it says a teacher can't go outside the bounds of normal academic standards for grading in regards to religious content, which if true doesn't actually change anything, since it's already illegal to discriminate against people for their religious beliefs, but it would be acceptable to do so in the specific context of education if religious beliefs aren't germane or factually correct IRT a test or curriculum.... so what's the point? Although it does use the weasel word "legitimate" which makes me suspicious that the real purpose of this is a bait for pro-religious lawsuits.
- NovemberWhiskey 7y agoWhenever you see "legitimate pedagogical concerns" in the scholastic context you should probably understand it to be referring to the Hazelwood standard: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hazelwood_School_District_v._Kuhlmeier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hazelwood_School_District_v._K...