4 ms·
Everyone in the comment thread seems to be focused on whether each proposition can be true. This is looking for your keys under the lamppost despite the fact th
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
Everyone in the comment thread seems to be focused on whether each proposition can be true. This is looking for your keys under the lamppost despite the fact that you dropped them in the dark. It's easy to determine whether a proposition can be true.
But the question doesn't ask about that. It just asks "which of these is the correct answer to this question?" There are no stated criteria for being the correct answer, and there is no reason to assume that the correct answer must be true or even capable of being true.
Consider this other question:
Which of the following is the correct answer to this question?
(A) This one.
(B) This one.
- decasia 7y agoThis seems like a crucial problem with the initial question. As with so many puzzles like this, it assumes that the reader will make similar (unargued, unstated) assumptions as the writer. But what justifies that methodological assumption? Nothing, as thaumasiotes is pointing out.
- PeterStuer 7y agoAny communication relies by necessity on a mutual implicit frame of reference, and while there most certainly are cases where question tread the line of unambiguous interpretability (I have suffered these many times, especially in education tests), I'd say in this case the demands are rather benign.
- zyx321 7y agoThat's arguing about semantics. It seems obvious from context that the intended interpretation of "the correct answer" is "the only true answer" — since "true" and "correct" are nearly synonymous, and the use of definite article singular implies that there exists exactly one answer.
- gmfawcett 7y agoTo be fair, making the argument that something is obvious from context is also arguing about semantics. The other poster makes a defensible point (as do you!).