2 ms·
Sometimes, the best way to change a law is to break it. Very few sit-ins are protesting the same law (trespass) they're breaking. Protesting censorship-via-go
by gojomo 16y ago
Sometimes, the best way to change a law is to break it.
Very few sit-ins are protesting the same law (trespass) they're breaking.
Protesting censorship-via-government-pressure with censorship-via-DDoS is similarly nonsensical, a tantrum more than a statement.
Build censorship-resistant systems instead of more censoring weapons.
- steveklabnik 16y agoPlease see my response to tptacek, it's not about censoring them, it's about dollars. Your point about protesting the same law is a good one, it's the coverage that's really valuable. However, sit-ins are only one form of civil disobedience, and many of them are actually doing the thing that's illegal.
- gojomo 16y agoVote with your own dollars, sure. Boycott Mastercard, sure. But interfering with others' legal expression and commerce is just repeating the same injustice that was done to Wikileaks, and damaging innocent bystanders. Leave their dollars alone.
- steveklabnik 16y agoGetting innocent bystanders involved is literally the point.
- nhangen 16y agoI disagree. I think the point is to grandstand and to pretend to be Neo for a day. Reading the commentary, it seems that these guys were far from familiar with the game they were playing. Furthermore, unless you were involved in the attack, how could you claim to know the point in the first place?
- steveklabnik 16y agoThere are thousands of people involved. I'm sure that some people want to be Neo, but not all of them, not by a long shot. Also, if you'll note, Neo had a political cause... I didn't participate in any DDoS, but it's not like this stuff happens in secret. All you have to do is know where and how to look. It's not exactly secret where these kinds of things are organized and discusssed.
- gojomo 16y agoGetting innocent bystanders involved is literally the point. Indeed, and in a civilized society, there are rules against hijacking others' dollars and interfering with others' lawful commerce, no matter how just you believe your cause to be. Thus, what you call 'literally the point' is also the 'mens rea' for a criminal prosecution.
- steveklabnik 16y agoThat's what makes it so impactful: its important enough that the consequences are irrelevant. It seems that you place a much higher importance on following the law than I do; I don't disagree with what you're saying, but you seemingly imply that that's a bad thing. Generally, following the law is good, but I hold no illusions that there's any connection between legality and morality.
- gojomo 16y agoI think the rules against sabotaging others' commerce are good rules; a moral person would follow them even if they weren't written down. Also, even if you get the desired headlines and attention, I don't think you score points against bad rules by violating good rules. I believe more people concluded Anonymous/Wikileaks are vandals and bullies from hearing about (or being affected by) the DDoS attacks, than came around to sympathy for Wikileaks. So orthogonal from any 'letter of the law' analysis, it was an immoral and counterproductive thing to do. If the 'sit-in' directly blocked the objectionable activity, a different analysis might apply. (And, more bystanders might be sympathetic.) But this, and most other 'sit-ins' I've seen, are just rudeness for attention. Moral and effective activists will choose other tactics. And regarding: "its important enough that the consequences are irrelevant" That way lies zealotry, madness, impotence, chaos. The real consequences always matter. The advocate who forgets, in their passion, that consequences matter becomes others' tool, often against their own interests.
- steveklabnik 16y ago> I think the rules against sabotaging others' commerce are good rules; a moral person would follow them even if they weren't written down. I agree with your statement on its face, but there are certain times when it's okay to break the rules. Sometimes you have to do bad things to achieve good ends. No action is ever white or black, there are only shades of gray. > If the 'sit-in' directly blocked the objectionable activity, a different analysis might apply. They did disrupt. Maybe not as much as Anon would have liked, but they did.
- rimantas 16y agoSo you are saying you are OK with any kind of terrorism? If not, where do you draw the line?
- steveklabnik 16y agosigh. Can this be like the new Godwin? I am okay with 'any kind,' _as long as it's a reasonable response_. For example, if you stepped outside right now and shot a cop, I'd think that you were a bad person, even though I dislike police. However, if some dude in Egypt right now shot a cop, I'd probably give him a high-five. Once the cops start shooting, your escalated response is justified.
- rimantas 16y agoFirst you talk how it is ok for innocent bystander to get hurt, then you talk about shooting cops…
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]