4 ms·
For clarity's sake, I was not talking about HN in this remark: > If one person’s presence is derailing the conversation for some reason, don’t automatically de
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
For clarity's sake, I was not talking about HN in this remark:
> If one person’s presence is derailing the conversation for some reason, don’t automatically decide they must be the bad guy. The absolute worst thing you can do is to tell that person to shut up and leave the discussion while allowing other people to keep attacking them in some way. This includes everyone rebutting their comments that they are no longer allowed to defend because they were asked to stop posting.
I belonged to a different forum for a time where that was official mod policy. Being rate limited, having a comment flagged to death by other users or even being shadow banned on HN where other users can still vouch for your comments is not the same as being publicly told to stop participating in X discussion by a mod and then punished if you dare to defend yourself as others talk all kinds of trash about you while the mods do nothing about it because they are fine with some in-crowd group being awful to some out-crowd group and actively encourage that as a matter of more-or-less official policy.
- dimino 7y agoI can tell you, from experience in this very thread, it feels about as shitty. :/ It's marginalization, fundamentally. A very small group of people (or a single person) decides to use their power to silence you, tell you how wrong you are, and tie your hands behind your proverbial back so you can't defend yourself. Dang supports it, and others join in. I can't tell you how many times I'll be browsing HN and see my score drop from one page load to the next by exactly as many points as I have comments in my history that can be downvoted. Or how many times a comment of mine gets flagged for reasons that have nothing to do with the HN guidelines. This forum is broken, and is in dire need of disruption.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jacobush 7y agoAlso, people are broken.
- pjc50 7y agoDo you have any insight into why this might be happening? I had a look at your post history and noticed you've posted relatively little this year since a large gap from 2016. I generally have a lot of respect for HN mods, it's never an easy job.
- dimino 7y agoI usually post from diminoten, but moved to this account to try and figure out why I was getting downvoted instantly nearly every time I commented, and why I was losing the same karma as votable posts that I had in the span of seconds sometimes. HN is not built to handle dissent. Privileges are based on votes, there are minimal to no vote protection tools in place, the guidelines are used as cudgels to beat people who disagree with the popular view, and the moderator (there's more or less only one, dang) prefers to smokescreen and gaslight anyone he doesn't like with generic comments that don't follow the very guidelines he's trying to enforce. Just look at his comment history; it's full of "This doesn't follow guidelines" without any elaboration, and when he does elaborate, it's an incredibly cynical and not-generous interpretation of the comment he's saying isn't acceptable, which is itself a violation of the HN guidelines, specifically the one about addressing the best form of an argument. Most of the problem is the fact that dang is the primary active moderator on HN. If others were to take over, and he were to be removed or retire, HN would become substantially better, possibly overnight. Dang needs to be removed for this site to grow and improve. People think HN is growing; it is not. The quality people who used to post here are more or less gone, and HN isn't attracting new quality posters to fill their shoes, precisely because dang moderates very poorly, which pushes away prospective high value posters. The reality is, it's high time for a replacement to HN.
- de_watcher 7y agoFirst rule of the downvotes: "Never talk about the downvotes".
- humanrebar 7y agoSeems in bounds for a thread about moderation.
- Forge36 7y agoI read through a few of your posts on your other account. In this case am I right to say you feel you are the recipient of unfair abuse? More so then single individual downvotes can be expected? When this happens you feel your opinions aren't respected and valued? I feel shitty when that happens too. I've avoided commenting on controversial threads as a result. I think the problem is what you're saying is lost in your tone (it also appears to be happening in this post too).
- dimino 7y agoPeople don't like hearing dissent, or people who disagree with them. My tone is a reaction to the hostility I'm experiencing as a result of that friction. Most forums have some kind of backstop that prevents the vindictive from causing too much harm. This forum has a vindictive moderator. He needs to go.
- Jarwain 7y agoIt must be frustrating to feel like you're being singled out. More so when you feel hostility from individuals who disagree with you. It can feel very personal, when someone is attacking you and your ideas. Especially when you Know you have a point and it feels like you aren't being heard. I've spent a lot of time trying to deal with this conflict & trying to be heard and understood. Part of the trick is not taking things too personally, not Making things personal or directing them at an Individual, and instead continuously focusing on the topic at hand. If things devolve to personal attacks of Any sort, I disengage or try to re-focus. My goal is to be heard and understood, and that doesn't happen when the argument devolves to a personal level. It's hard not to react, but sometimes not reacting & taking the high road is the most productive way forward.
- sambe 7y agoThe effect is extremely similar though, don't you think? If not worse, for e.g. shadow banning.
- dang 7y agoShadowbanning on HN is mostly for spammers and new accounts that show evidence of past abuses. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20shadowban&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... Once an account has a history on HN, we tell people that we're banning them and why. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=by%3Adang%20banned%20account&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoPerhaps you should have a public transparency log for all mod-determined transgressions. Might allay some of the accusations we're seeing here of accused abuses.
- dang 7y agoMy sense is that it would lead to an order-of-magnitude explosion of litgious meta discussion, which is last thing we we need or want. If that's right, then it's worse than that, because then metaness would consume a lot more resources than it already does, starving the rest of the site of other things we need to work on. That would be a vicious feedback loop; I'd rather look for virtuous ones.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoHN is quite a lot larger than anything I've personally moderated. There are scaling issues involved.
- tptacek 7y agoHN moderation is far more transparent than it was before Dan took over (when 'pg moderated, things like subjective shadow bans really were a norm), and more transparent than it was when he started --- I hesitate to explain how, for fear of fulfilling Dan's prophecy, but one simple, not-fraught example would be the expansion of the guidelines. I perceive no corresponding change in the amount of meta threads about mis-moderation; noodling debates based on random accusations are still evergreen here. If I were involved in moderating HN (thank Christ I'm not), I'd conclude that substantive process-level changes aimed at quelling these kinds of debates probably aren't a productive goal.