4 ms·
I'm the author. My actual name is Doreen Michele Traylor. I spent nearly six years homeless, in part because I have an incurable medical condition. The point o
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
I'm the author. My actual name is Doreen Michele Traylor.
I spent nearly six years homeless, in part because I have an incurable medical condition. The point of view of the piece is informed by firsthand experience, not prejudice nor judgment against people like myself.
I have spent a lot of years desperately trying to convince people to support my Patreon or leave tips for my blog writing. I get a lot of feedback that I write well, but I also get told a lot "go get a Real Job, writing simply doesn't pay."
I was very open about my problems when I was homeless. The vast majority of the time, it got me open hostility, not aid and support. If people threw money at me every single time I mentioned how dire my situation was, I could have paid cash for a house ages ago.
That's not how that works.
Once in a while, people would take pity on me and kick a few bucks my way. But I lived under constant suspicion that the only possible reason I talked about my reality was that I was de facto soft begging.
I would much, much rather be paid for my writing than kicked a few bucks out of pity occasionally. It would be vastly better for both my bottom line and my sense of self.
- droithomme 7y agoWhy shouldn't persons who are homeless and persons who are disabled be allowed to join the conversation, as you asserted? Do their opinions really count for nothing?
- tidenly 7y agoWell now you're really just projecting. The author's point, made in your quoted paragraph and then again in the following two, was clearly that people who are in difficult situations or neuroatypical may be disruptive to "the norms" a lot of users are used to and how to accommodate that. I think you would have to intentionally take the most uncharitable interpretation of this article to think the authors point was "these people shouldn't be able to take part".
- droithomme 7y agoNo. That is false and disingenuous. They explicitly stated concern that homeless etc people would be able to "join the conversation." It's not an interpretation. It's what they actually stated clearly and explicitly, as a matter of fact on record. This is their exact quote about categories of contributors they had concern with: > for example, homeless people and very sick people and disabled people can join the conversation
- tidenly 7y agoSorry, I might be missing something but can you point out where the author is saying they're against this or that its a "concern"? They say it can be disruptive - and explicitly say to whom it is disruptive ("people who don't run into the kinds of people normally" i.e the masses) but I'm not seeing this explicit point where the author says it's a bad thing - only that it's a challenge to moderate everyone tactfully. Can you help me out?
- andreareina 7y agoThere are whole paragraphs devoted to how to let these people give their relevant first-hand experience without derailing the conversation or getting ganged up on. That doesn't read to me like not wanting them to voice their opinion. But yes, a moderator should be concerned when groups with very different needs and motivations interact. Not because it's undesirable but because it can easily devolve into nonproductive and even harmful "discussion". It's the same concern a shop manager has when someone is new to using the table saw or torch or whatever. Except, table saws don't have a mind of their own.
- dang 7y agoObviously DoreenMichele isn't asserting that. She was on HN for years herself whilst being homeless. If that doesn't give her legitimacy to talk on this subject, from a homeless perspective and an HN perspective, what would? Since you care about homeless people and people with disabilities being able to participate in forums, why not listen to someone who did just that? Edit: Apart from everything else, it's an incredibly interesting combination. Other HN users have posted about homelessness from personal experience too. Cross-examination is out of place here. Though I doubt you intended to come across that way.)
- mkl 7y ago> She was on HN for years herself whilst being homeless. To be clear, in case anyone's confused by that statement about a 2 year old account, DoreenMichele used to have a different username: https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=Mz https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=Mz
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- soneca 7y agoHave you heard about Substack? Not big, but YC company, so it's kind of easy to bump around here. They are a platform to host your blog/newsletter and allow very easily to monetize it. You can charge at least $5/month from readers that want to get a paying-reader-only emails. Still allow you to post free posts/emails. I am using them basically as a free blog and newsletter hosting service for now, but with the hope that I grow an audience big enough to charge and earn some extra income. I think it would fit your desires quite well