4 ms·

All of it is designed hijack your attention against your own interests. What you call "positive emotional response" is only positive from the point of view of t

All of it is designed hijack your attention against your own interests. What you call "positive emotional response" is only positive from the point of view of the advertiser. From the point of view of the victims, it as intrusion on their thoughts of attention, and almost always an attempt to implant a desire into their mind. Ads are art to the same degree that cannibalism is gastronomy.

buboard 7y ago
most apple users here would disagree plus i m not sure if you re aware how extreme your position is Most of our beautiful classical art was advertisements for the Church most graffiti is uglier than ads
- mirimir 7y ago
  > Most of our beautiful classical art was advertisements for the Church I guess that's why I hate so much of it. Also the bloody hymns that are popular this season. Especially the castrati voices.
  - buboard 7y ago
    sorry to shock you, but almost every western cultural artifact you listen or watch is derivative of that art. so i guess u hate music too
    - mirimir 7y ago
      I hate lots of music, sure. My taste runs toward punk, black metal, acid house, and trance.
- normalnorm 7y ago
  > most apple users here would disagree > plus i m not sure if you re aware how extreme your position is Wait, aren't you the person who just wrote "think different"? I'm confused. > Most of our beautiful classical art was advertisements for the Church Sure, and Jesus was a Marxist, or something... If you try to force XXI century concepts into XIV century realities you can arrive at silly over-simplified conclusions such as the one above. > most graffiti is uglier than ads This is your opinion. Graffitis are not trying to manipulate me.
  - ericmay 7y ago
    Eh, I think graffiti is or can be used to send a message or bring to light an issue. So in that way it is trying to manipulate you. That being said I don’t disagree with the rest of your post.
    - normalnorm 7y ago
      Fair enough. I would just argue that they don't try to manipulate you at scale...
mirimir 7y ago
> Ads are art to the same degree that cannibalism is gastronomy. Good one. So maybe a couple years ago, being a klutz, I brushed a finger against a red-hot stovetop grill. There was a hiss, with ~no pain at first. And creepily, a delicious smell. Took months to heal. And hurt like fuck. But that smell. Damn.
- mirimir 7y ago
  OK, so maybe I was unclear. The point is that the delicious food smell from burning myself severely was unexpected, distracting ... and worse, rather invasive, and hard to put out of mind. So that's like being confronted by advertising that triggers some unconscious drive. It puts some new thought in your head, which leads you to do something that you otherwise wouldn't. So that'a invasive just like the smell of ones braising flesh, which bringsd up thoughts of eating. That is, the riff that art to advertising is like gastronomy to cannibalism. Or at least, autocannibalism. There's also similarity between advertising and sexual assault. The possibility that a victim -- like a victim of advertising -- will come to enjoy the experience. And end up being betrayed by their body. Which arguably is one of thge worst parts of the experience. Seeing ads is rather like brain rape.
Simon_says 7y ago
> victims I like you.

buboard 7y ago

most apple users here would disagree plus i m not sure if you re aware how extreme your position is Most of our beautiful classical art was advertisements for the Church most graffiti is uglier than ads

mirimir 7y ago
> Most of our beautiful classical art was advertisements for the Church I guess that's why I hate so much of it. Also the bloody hymns that are popular this season. Especially the castrati voices.
- buboard 7y ago
  sorry to shock you, but almost every western cultural artifact you listen or watch is derivative of that art. so i guess u hate music too
  - mirimir 7y ago
    I hate lots of music, sure. My taste runs toward punk, black metal, acid house, and trance.
normalnorm 7y ago
> most apple users here would disagree > plus i m not sure if you re aware how extreme your position is Wait, aren't you the person who just wrote "think different"? I'm confused. > Most of our beautiful classical art was advertisements for the Church Sure, and Jesus was a Marxist, or something... If you try to force XXI century concepts into XIV century realities you can arrive at silly over-simplified conclusions such as the one above. > most graffiti is uglier than ads This is your opinion. Graffitis are not trying to manipulate me.
- ericmay 7y ago
  Eh, I think graffiti is or can be used to send a message or bring to light an issue. So in that way it is trying to manipulate you. That being said I don’t disagree with the rest of your post.
  - normalnorm 7y ago
    Fair enough. I would just argue that they don't try to manipulate you at scale...

mirimir 7y ago

> Ads are art to the same degree that cannibalism is gastronomy. Good one. So maybe a couple years ago, being a klutz, I brushed a finger against a red-hot stovetop grill. There was a hiss, with ~no pain at first. And creepily, a delicious smell. Took months to heal. And hurt like fuck. But that smell. Damn.

mirimir 7y ago
OK, so maybe I was unclear. The point is that the delicious food smell from burning myself severely was unexpected, distracting ... and worse, rather invasive, and hard to put out of mind. So that's like being confronted by advertising that triggers some unconscious drive. It puts some new thought in your head, which leads you to do something that you otherwise wouldn't. So that'a invasive just like the smell of ones braising flesh, which bringsd up thoughts of eating. That is, the riff that art to advertising is like gastronomy to cannibalism. Or at least, autocannibalism. There's also similarity between advertising and sexual assault. The possibility that a victim -- like a victim of advertising -- will come to enjoy the experience. And end up being betrayed by their body. Which arguably is one of thge worst parts of the experience. Seeing ads is rather like brain rape.

Simon_says 7y ago

> victims I like you.