3 ms·
Here's a personal opinion that might be wildly unpopular with entities whose revenue stream is primarily composed of advertising. I work in network engineering
by walrus01 7y ago
Here's a personal opinion that might be wildly unpopular with entities whose revenue stream is primarily composed of advertising.
I work in network engineering for an ISP, which is a mid-sized regional ASN.
there is no reason why the internet needs to have advertising on it at all, for people to both make use of it and pay for it as end-user residential consumers, or businesses.
as an ISP that has both wholly-owned facilities-based last-mile services, and that uses third-party last-mile services, these are entirely paid for by the subscriber revenue.
Our revenue is also sufficient to pay for inter-city transport services, IP Transit upstreams, various colocation costs, and all of the infrastructure needed to connect to various IX points and content delivery networks.
Essentially, look at it as the same difference between Netflix, Amazon Prime, or traditional advertising-supported cable television.
Residential end-user internet service is now just as essential as having functioning water, sewer, or electrical grid connection. The monthly subscriber fee per connection when aggregated between dozens of thousands of individual endpoints, is more than sufficient to support a robust, redundant ISP that can pay competitive salaries to its staff.
- buboard 7y agoISPs also pay wages which support the economy. There is a 500B industry which subsidizes the web. If you remove it, the cost will be deducted from the wages of everyone who works in tech. Also, this will lead to even more centralization as ads are the only channel for still-small businesses to reach critical mass.
- walrus01 7y agoI have very little objection to seeing targeted, specific ads in certain places. For example if I'm browsing the Anandtech website, and there's ads for technology/hardware enthusiast stuff, that's both relevant and helps pay the bills for Anandtech, enabling them to pay their staff. I don't see why advertising needs to pervade every aspect of social media. Imagining Facebook's advertising revenue cut by 85% really doesn't make me sad at all. Facebook has to lay off some people, who will then go out into the economy and get jobs possibly doing something more productive with their time than selling advertising. There is not a 1:1 venn diagram overlap between "the internet" (the actual backbone and middle mile infrastructure that runs underneath) and "the web" (http/https based content websites and social media things like instagram).
- buboard 7y agoadvertising will go wherever attention is. If you want facebook to stop making uber-profits, fund an alternative, sell your FB stocks, lobby its engineers to work for half as much money etc etc etc.
- mistermann 7y agoI want Facebook and similar companies to stop doing things that are causing significant harm to society. Your approach seems unnecessarily complicated and prone to failure, I prefer we instead pass legislation and solve the problem quickly and with largely guaranteed success. Will this cause disproportionate harm to a relatively small number of mostly wealthy people in the process? I imagine, but sometimes life's not fair. Roll around crying tears in your piles of money. Or, recognize that tempers are rising and mass torch construction planning is underway, and adjust your business practices accordingly. No one is forcing them to do anything, yet. They might not be so lucky if someone like a Bernie Sanders was somehow able to slip through the political filters like Trump managed to.
- buboard 7y ago> to stop doing things that are causing significant harm to society. When people say this, what they really mean is they prefer a society where people are less empowered to speak their minds, looking into the past with rose tinted glasses. Meanwhile, society today is more educated, richer, healthier and more cognizant of its problems than ever. Try telling a 50s housewife to stop driving around her gas guzzler while smoking. > I prefer we instead pass legislation and solve the problem quickly and in the process demolish liberties - that's something only dictatorships do. > and mass torch construction planning is underway That sounds a horrible thing to wish for. Such talk is purely vengeful. Even if i don't care if facebook is shut down tomorrow (don't use it), it's pretty clear people will start using the alternative the day after tomorrow, and that may be VK or the chinese alternative. The social media cat is out of the bag and it's wrong, indeed violent to take away people's empowered rights to speech Taking away people's rights to force-install someone's idea of utopia in a society is called authoritarianism