7 ms·
A Pragmatic Approach to Thorny People Problems
- dimino 7y ago> If one person’s presence is derailing the conversation for some reason, don’t automatically decide they must be the bad guy. The absolute worst thing you can do is to tell that person to shut up and leave the discussion while allowing other people to keep attacking them in some way. This includes everyone rebutting their comments that they are no longer allowed to defend because they were asked to stop posting. > It is healthier to allow them to vigorously defend their point of view if they wish. If they are the only person representing a particular point of view or experience, do not act like “they are posting too much” if they reply to everyone talking with them about it. Really wish dang would read this. HN takes the exact opposite approach to this and dang prefers to enforce this to avoid confrontation rather than create a space for conversation. Edit: this is a great example. I can't reply to anyone here, because I'm rate limited, so people can say how many ways I'm wrong and I have no real ability to defend my argument. This is what dang wants, and it's incredibly toxic. The downvotes pour in and I'm helpless.
- saagarjha 7y ago> The absolute worst thing you can do is to tell that person to shut up and leave the discussion while allowing other people to keep attacking them in some way. Hacker News doesn't let you respond to dead comments, so this isn't true.
- dimino 7y agoNot talking about dead comments, talking about the rate limiting that's selectively applied to certain IPs/accounts.
- saagarjha 7y agoWhat kind of rate limiting are you seeing? In general, I feel like once you've started feeling the need to post more than once every couple of minutes, then you're more than likely diving in to a nonproductive discussion. (And note that this is different than normally posting more often than that: I am specifically talking about "I need to reply to these four people who are nitpicking me, and I need to rebut their comments now", as opposed to "I'm going through a comment thread and commenting on whatever seems interesting; I would be fine with making this reply at a later point in time".)
- dimino 7y ago> The absolute worst thing you can do is to tell that person to shut up and leave the discussion while allowing other people to keep attacking them in some way. Are you forgetting what we're talking about? Keep in mind you replied to my comment claiming I was wrong, and have since been shown to be wrong yourself. Edit: This is what I see when I try to comment at all on HN for the next ~1 hour: https://gyazo.com/d8ae5c6c5675919f4366b1ce928ad016 https://gyazo.com/d8ae5c6c5675919f4366b1ce928ad016 Dang is not a good shepherd of HN and shouldn't be in the role that he's in. Edit: and now this is flagged. How dare I represent an alternative viewpoint of how dang is performing...
- saagarjha 7y agoNo, I'm still on topic. I did not realize that Hacker News would rate limit for that long, so I had assumed your comments were just being flagged or killed.
- dang 7y agoLow-information/high-indignation comments like this are exactly what we rate limit accounts for, when they post too many of them. That's why your accounts are rate-limited, as we've explained to you a dozen times or more. Most HN users who read this thread, or the history of your accounts, will be surprised how lenient we've been with you.
- Bnshsysjab 7y agoReplying to four different comments can be productive discussion too, when four interesting threads spawn as a result of your comment, for example.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoI don't think people get rate limits for having minority viewpoints. They get rate limits for acting rudely and breaking the site guidelines, none of which are viewpoint-specific. (I know, as someone who once had a rate limit and cleaned up his act.)
- droithomme 7y agoModerators respond to flagged posts. Minority viewpoint posts are the ones that are flagged. Popular viewpoint posts are not flagged.
- dang 7y agoPopular viewpoint posts get flagged, as they should, when they break the site guidelines. We couldn't care less if a view is popular or not. What we care about is that discussion follow the rules at https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mistermann 7y agoDoes the rate limiting code take downvotes into consideration?
- mistermann 7y agoWhy in God's name would a simple question be downvoted? Dang, do you perchance monitor any habitual downvoting of users by particular other users? edit: lol, downvoted within 2 minutes. Here, I'll make it easy for you mysterious friend, here's another new one for you: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21545859 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21545859
- dang 7y agoYes, we monitor that. Could you please stop complaining about downvotes in HN comments? As the guidelines say, it never does any good and it makes boring reading. It's a perennial weed of offtopicness. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- PavlovsCat 7y agoYou are equating "telling a person to shut up and leave the discussion while allowing other people to keep attacking them in some way" with physically and forcefully removing them from the discussion, when it rather refers to a social expectation/demand of a group vs. an individual. Such a signal is also sent by downvotes without argument, not to mention piling on to a downvoted or flagged comment (people can respond to response to a flagged comment just fine, and can agree with each other about how horrible the flagged person is or what else they probably advocate for, and all that stuff), while that person is rate limited if not shadowbanned. I can't vote on comments anymore, neither positive nor negative. No clue why, it's been that way since a few months and I stopped caring, just like I wouldn't terribly mind "writing for the showdead community exclusively". But I know that I upvoted comments that I found reasonable, and unfairly greyed out. So either I was manually selected for that, without any precedent or any communication, or there's an algorithm that blindly removes voting from people who don't agree with the herd enough. Either way, the people who haven't been on the wrong end of the stick much are always super quick to assume that means there's nothing shitty going on. But that has more to do with what people want to believe, not with actually looking into any of it.
- saagarjha 7y ago> people can respond to response to a flagged comment just fine, and can agree with each other about how horrible the flagged person is or what else they probably advocate for, and all that stuff Can people actually do that? I have rarely, if ever, seen this on Hacker News, and I feel like anything like this would be a good way to be downvoted or flagged yourself. > I wouldn't terribly mind "writing for the showdead community exclusively". You're not alone: there are a number of people who do this already. > But I know that I upvoted comments that I found reasonable, and unfairly greyed out. So either I was manually selected for that, without any precedent or any communication, or there's an algorithm that blindly removes voting from people who don't agree with the herd enough. I wonder if this was supposed to be a nudge to use the "vouch" feature instead? Even if it was, it wasn't a particularly good one. Maybe the moderators could tell you why you can't vote if you emailed them?
- 7y ago
- SamReidHughes 7y agoYou can't vouch it, respond, and then unvouch?
- saagarjha 7y agoI guess you could, but I feel like doing that frequently would cause you to lose your vouching privileges.
- andrewflnr 7y agoDoes that work? I guess I assumed vouching just flagged a comment for re-review, rather than instantly reviving it.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoIt often does an insta-revive, but I never tested whether you could unvouch after replying.
- erikpukinskis 7y agoIn my experience vouching doesn’t do anything? I can’t reply after I vouch.
- dredmorbius 7y agoVouching doesn't immediately unflag/unkill a comment.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoThat depends on the comment, and I’d guess the vouchers and flaggers.
- gregoryl 7y agoBut you are still here, fighting against these restrictions to post, which makes me think they are doing something right to create a space so desirable to participate within.
- mistermann 7y agoIt's presumptuous to assume the restrictions are what makes HN desirable to participate in. It's possible it plays a role, it's possible it doesn't.
- Forge36 7y agoI here's hate when this happens and I can't imagine how you feel. You have very strong opinions, from the results and status of this thread I think this response is coming from how strongly others are put off by your aggressive defenses and how you're voicing your disagreement with an article or response. (I want aware of Dang before your posts) The substances on your posts seen very on point, however the tone makes your responses feel personal. I don't like hearing that I'm wrong, combined with a tone where I feel I'm a lesser, stupid, idiot, for having a mistaken brief immediately pushes me defensive. It doesn't matter if I agreed with you initially, if this tone is felt ok the first sentence: I'll never reach your substanive argument for your point to be made. Your responses feel like an attack on Dang not a criticism of HN, this is encouraging others to defend him, and the site, because the principle feeling is a personal attack. I'm worried that by posting I'll get that same for of response from you.
- droithomme 7y ago> for example, homeless people and very sick people and disabled people can join the conversation Also people from different cultures and perspectives whose ideas are far more bizarre to the western middle class mind than those the homeless persons in the US he mentions. But sure, classifying different viewpoints as "obviously" mentally ill and assuming they must be "homeless" or "very sick" is an incredibly useful tactic to a privileged white supremacist such as the article's pseudonymous author. Kudos for that, good job squelching diversity to the OP and the HN mods like dg who will shortly be along to censor all non-privileged opinions, as is their job and solemn duty.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI'm the author. My actual name is Doreen Michele Traylor. I spent nearly six years homeless, in part because I have an incurable medical condition. The point of view of the piece is informed by firsthand experience, not prejudice nor judgment against people like myself. I have spent a lot of years desperately trying to convince people to support my Patreon or leave tips for my blog writing. I get a lot of feedback that I write well, but I also get told a lot "go get a Real Job, writing simply doesn't pay." I was very open about my problems when I was homeless. The vast majority of the time, it got me open hostility, not aid and support. If people threw money at me every single time I mentioned how dire my situation was, I could have paid cash for a house ages ago. That's not how that works. Once in a while, people would take pity on me and kick a few bucks my way. But I lived under constant suspicion that the only possible reason I talked about my reality was that I was de facto soft begging. I would much, much rather be paid for my writing than kicked a few bucks out of pity occasionally. It would be vastly better for both my bottom line and my sense of self.
- droithomme 7y agoWhy shouldn't persons who are homeless and persons who are disabled be allowed to join the conversation, as you asserted? Do their opinions really count for nothing?
- tidenly 7y ago
- cybersnowflake 7y agoToo long, no need to overcomplicate things. Moderation isn't rocket science. All you need to do is delete spam and mod the occasional obviously spammy person and you're 99% of the way there. IME the best moderation is the lightest moderation. Additional good guidelines 1a Simplicity: Simple Rules: If you have to have a set of rules have as simple and clearcut a set of rules as possible prominently posted. 1b Simplicity: Avoid CoCs: CoCs are the opposite of simple rules. They have a tendency to grow and are designed to be used in a proactive rather than reactive fashion that encourages abuse. 2. Transparency: If you mod someone let them know why they're modded and the exact consequences of this (ie precise times etc) as a bonus have a partially anonymized bulletin board showing the public modding actions and even takedown and external requests from outside groups to moderate your content. 3. Politics: Don't mod based on your personal ideology. Seems simple but generally ignored by most places. 4. No protected classes, no divisiveness, neutrality: Rules like "no antiLBGT" or "no sexist remarks" are wrongheaded as much as you might believe in them. Setting aside specific protected classes is inherently a divisive act. Instead have rules like "no personal insults" which apply and are enforced on everybody equally. Moderation in a place which supposedly is about free expression is about removing disruption not enforcing morality. 5. No scummy things: Theres almost never any justification for measures like shadowbanning. If you notice, these guidelines are the opposite of how most of Big Tech does things which is why soapboxes of the internet are becoming crappier and crappier. Most places moderate with a heavier hand than necessary. In most places including here, a big chunk of the moderation is political in nature.
- derekbreden 7y agoThe replies I've seen elsewhere here seem well thought out, and in almost all cases take consideration of the contents of the article into their responses, even if not intentionally. I like what this article says, and would like to support the promotion of it's content without adding further confounding additional language. Should I have upvoted the article and said nothing? P.P.S. This comment could be posted on most things I see on HN without further editing, and would convey what I feel about them.
- Forge36 7y agoI believe you're asking how to best promote this specific content? It depends on who your target audience is: yourself, strangers, coworkers, or friends? If you want others to follow this advice, do those same people use HN? If not, what approach will help them see this? Do you want to save it, and your thoughts on the article for later review? I do this publicly to wrap my head around the problem so I can try to get others to pick apart my mistakes (though perhaps to not great effect due to echo chambers). To your specific post for this thread: does the article pose a question or an answer? I believing that is trying to answer a question. To the boring meta part: It's my common approach to upvote without replying (sometimes I write the post add discard it). I'm not 100% clear on the HN culture and focus my replies to further the discussion (this being a meta post feels weird). Both comments, and upvotes keep a that "alive", having read a few articles due to the sheer number of responses, I believe higher vested effort increases likelihood of others investing time (this is true but only of posts, but work in general). Onto other articles: I like discussing the topics with data behind them. IBMs Mac rollout is interesting, but I'm wondering (given the source) if it's a PR piece. To the target audience: It depends on if it's me as a recipient for practicing or me as a vehicle for spreading more humility when working with others (strangers on the internet). In this case: I'm going to try to remember and reference this article. I don't want to share it yet as I haven't practiced it. (with this post being more a response to your question than the article) Perhaps the best way to promote this post is living it with intent and sharing it when others ask how you deal with the problem (hopefully doing so well), thus directly answering your question: Upvote and thank you for posting so I could think about this more :)
- stochastastic 7y agoThanks for writing/sharing this. It puts words around some dynamics I’ve seen, and not just online. It got me thinking about people and my mental models of them, which I think is helpful.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoFor clarity's sake, I was not talking about HN in this remark: > If one person’s presence is derailing the conversation for some reason, don’t automatically decide they must be the bad guy. The absolute worst thing you can do is to tell that person to shut up and leave the discussion while allowing other people to keep attacking them in some way. This includes everyone rebutting their comments that they are no longer allowed to defend because they were asked to stop posting. I belonged to a different forum for a time where that was official mod policy. Being rate limited, having a comment flagged to death by other users or even being shadow banned on HN where other users can still vouch for your comments is not the same as being publicly told to stop participating in X discussion by a mod and then punished if you dare to defend yourself as others talk all kinds of trash about you while the mods do nothing about it because they are fine with some in-crowd group being awful to some out-crowd group and actively encourage that as a matter of more-or-less official policy.
- dimino 7y agoI can tell you, from experience in this very thread, it feels about as shitty. :/ It's marginalization, fundamentally. A very small group of people (or a single person) decides to use their power to silence you, tell you how wrong you are, and tie your hands behind your proverbial back so you can't defend yourself. Dang supports it, and others join in. I can't tell you how many times I'll be browsing HN and see my score drop from one page load to the next by exactly as many points as I have comments in my history that can be downvoted. Or how many times a comment of mine gets flagged for reasons that have nothing to do with the HN guidelines. This forum is broken, and is in dire need of disruption.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jacobush 7y agoAlso, people are broken.
- pjc50 7y agoDo you have any insight into why this might be happening? I had a look at your post history and noticed you've posted relatively little this year since a large gap from 2016. I generally have a lot of respect for HN mods, it's never an easy job.
- marcus_holmes 7y agoThanks for writing this, it was genuinely interesting and useful. Particularly the parts about negative attention and trolls. I've had a "nice" childhood and don't understand at all how negative attention can be comforting for some people. It really helped to have that explained.
- foobar_ 7y agoCan this be solved by fixing the UI somehow? Half the time I don't remember the guidelines and just go into ranting. The article was definitely eye-opening, I definitely go for negative attention sometimes, sometimes unwittingly and sometimes out of spite for the trends I see. I can certainly see why dang had to remind me a few times about the guidelines. I hate Java and I can be quite trollish about my hate. Oh well, I guess I should just concentrate on what I love. That said I do have a problem with silencing. This problem was solved in USENET with kill-lists, lists where each user can choose to ignore another list of users maintained democratically without resorting to a few mods, who can be benevolent or not. This is how we block spammy ip addresses using the hosts file! This is a solved problem with a simple solution, heck it can even be applied to every major social networking site out there. On a side note, why can't HN code be made available on GitHub? It could be one of the biggest lisp projects overnight.
- firepoet 7y agoNot a bad idea!
- dang 7y agoMuch of the HN codebase consists of anti-abuse measures that would stop working if people knew about them. Unfortunately. There's a very old version of HN that pg published years ago (at http://arclanguage.org/ http://arclanguage.org/). It would be nice to get that updated and maintained, but separating out the secret parts would by now be a lot of work. The time to do it will be if and when we eventually release the alternative Arc implementations we've been working on.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago>> So, for example, homeless people and very sick people and disabled people can join the conversation and their personal problems can be inadvertently disruptive in a way that’s very hard to deal with both humanely and effectively. I feel this is worded extermely clumsimly and it puts people who are homeless, sick or disabled (!) on the spot for causing trouble. From my experience on HN and other internet message boards, people who are healthy and financially well-off can do a fine job of being disruptive and engaging in flame wars. I don't see the reason to single out homeless, sick or disabled people as being particularly notable for being disruptive.