3 ms·
Indeed, this seems to be needlessly kicking life back into SMS when it was already being replaced by better systems that respect privacy. Of course the decentr
by dmix 7y ago
Indeed, this seems to be needlessly kicking life back into SMS when it was already being replaced by better systems that respect privacy.
Of course the decentralized nature of SMS is a good benefit but given how most telecoms are oligopolies disinterested in customers concerns about privacy (and plenty of other things like customer service) it pretty much defeats the value in it.
- pathartl 7y agoI wouldn't say needlessly. There's still something to be said for basic technologies that all devices can support.
- dmix 7y agoSure, agreed it's useful as a backbone sort of system like phones. Which will always be the biggest fundamental flaw with something like Signal or WhatsApp (the need for centralized servers, the requirement to install 3rd party software). There may be a role for these telecom services to exist perpetually as a backup services, while everyone still uses apps as their primary communication method. But RCS seems to be trying to bring SMS to parity with messaging apps supporting emoticons and media-heavy content, the intention is the same "conversations with friends" use-case as the messaging apps. There may even be an argument to keep SMS dumb and simple like phone lines. Especially if they aren't going to adopt encryption with the rest.
- kbenson 7y ago> But RCS seems to be trying to bring SMS to parity with messaging apps supporting emoticons and media-heavy content I think it's more that RCS is attempting to bring SMS into the 21st century, if barely. Those aren't exactly amazing features, they're the lowest bar for entry you could meet for a messaging app in 2010. 2019 has a much higher bar, as everyone here is noting.
- dmix 7y agoIt's not just the features but them combined with a very cleanly designed messaging app ala WhatsApp. They aren't amazing or new on their own but they've become standard and essential in the 3rd party messaging apps. There's a lot RCS is going to do to make SMS difficult to distinguish from WhatsApp for most people, especially these days as they've matured and everyone has finished copying the other guy.
- kbenson 7y agoTo be clear, I was saying the RCS features aren't exactly amazing, and are 2010 level standard, not that WhatsApp's features aren't good. If the base level RCS features make it hard for WhatsApp to stand out, and the base level RCS features are really fairly poor in comparison to what can be offered, that begs the question of what WhatsApp is bringing that's worth it's use. End-to-end encryption is the answer, but there's other apps that may do that better. If the real big differentiator is end-to-end encryption, then I think the solution isn't to push people to not use RCS, which has inherent qualities that mean it will always have at least some market, but after it's here we immediately push for extensions to it that allow end-to-end encryption. If that's accomplished, that immediately sets the real floor for every messaging app, and if they aren't offering the same the two questions are why bother with it at all if the built in stuff is better, and why aren't they doing it if it's the market floor, what are they gaining from being able to see the messages? SMS is the lowest common denominator of messaging. RCS will be the lowest common denominator of messaging. We should use this opportunity to cement that, and then keep the momentum up and use it to push for other essential features like encryption.
- kbenson 7y agoIt's a phone based messaging medium. If you have a phone number, you can send a message. That's not nothing. I know the phone numbers of far more people than I know the name of their apple account, or google account, or facebook account, or whatever. The general answer to that is to exchange account information, but the easiest way to do that is through SMS... and here we are. Upgrading SMS so it's better. It's not perfect, but I'm happy for any advances they can make to it. And as for why it's not encrypted end-to-end, the spec started back in 2008. That wasn't even on most people's radar back then. It's possible once we see some actual uptake of the protocol, we might see some more movement towards adding features (continuously adding features before something is in use is just a good way to make sure it never actually makes it into use).
- telcodud 7y agoKnowing someone's phone number means you can reach them on WhatsApp. At least, that's true for 2B (out of 5B) of phone numbers, which is likely to be 1,000 times the number of RCS users. The second and most important advantage of WhatsApp is that you don't have to maintain an address book anymore. People change phone numbers and the new number is automatically reflected in WhatsApp. It's quite likely that address books on phones are outdated and thus stale.
- kbenson 7y ago> Knowing someone's phone number means you can reach them on WhatsApp ...that would be super useful if I had WhatsApp installed. It also means that WhatsApp is tracking the phone number of all the people and doing selective (assuming only your friends can see it) publishing of it. I guess that's usually okay, but it also kinda wierds me out that it leaks info that way. My phone number is already managed by me, I've given it to the people I want to have it. This really just limits any WhatsApp messaging I would to to entities that I want to have my phone number. It's probably much easier to block WhatsApp accounts (and attempted messages) than calls (phone calls which are synchronous communication have a much higher urgency to me than some random phone ding that's async).
- ta999999171 7y ago