3 ms·
It's funny that Mastercard can't defend against an attack that my home router is capable of defending against. (A big limit on connections per /24 per minute s
by jrockway 16y ago
It's funny that Mastercard can't defend against an attack that my home router is capable of defending against. (A big limit on connections per /24 per minute should solve this problem. So will using a smart webserver or frontend proxy that doesn't care how many idle connections there are. Then all you have to worry about is bandwidth saturation rather than your servers crashing.)
But the lesson here is, when you visit a web page, a line in a log that identifies you is generated. Generate too many of these lines, and, one line of Perl later, the cops are going to be asking you some questions. Don't participate in a DDoS attack unless you're absolutely sure that nobody is logging your traffic. And that is something that's impossible to be sure of these days.
- magamiako 16y agoNo, your router can't defend against a DDOS. Like you noted at the end, it was data saturation that was the issue. I'm not really sure how the LOIC works (I've never checked out this program), but my suspicion is that it simply floods a connection with ICMP. It's kind of like...one person is only so strong, thousands are much stronger.
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoCome on, quite a few home routers can't even handle an aggressive Bittorrent client. Yes, DDoS can be defended against, and the fact that the LOIC is pretty primitive helps, but it's not that trivial.
- aphyr 16y agoIt seems like it would be trivial to get someone's door busted down by running LOIC aggressively on their computer. I wonder--at what point can the FBI's enthusiastic enforcement be directed, in some sense, as a weapon? Edit: I've watched Anonymous (insert typical disclaimer about the membership of a heterogenous group of net users) attack more than one of my boxes. DDOS's have been traditionally been the regime of surreptitious botnets, not voluntary ones. I'll bet you some unsuspecting soccer mom (or someone who pisses off Anon) gets nabbed at some point.
- forensic 16y agoThe FBI is just sending a message. They cherry picked a few IP addresses, set surveillance on them, and then chose those few which belonged to people who were active on forums revealing that they were in fact probably guilty and didn't just have a trojan or little brother. If the FBI intended to comprehensively prosecute every offender your point would be a genuine hindrance. However they only need a few to deter the behaviour and they know this. Thousands of people participated in these protests, and a handful are going to be made examples of. It's not at all unlike a flesh-and-blood protest.
- axod 16y agoYou can get people to participate in DDoS attacks with a malicious website though. Just use some JS to create image elements, script tags, iframes etc all with sources pointing at the target, should be able to do a few hundred a second at least. Even trivial to get people to participate without using javascript. Just pop in a hidden iframe with a million <img> tags in the source. As things move on, I don't think individuals who happen to fire off a few hundred requests at a website should be investigated/prosecuted/etc. Website owners just need to get better at protecting their systems.
- abstractbill 16y agoJust pop in a hidden iframe with a million <img> tags in the source. Mostly agree, but thought it worth pointing out that no browser will respond to this by parallelizing the million requests - most browsers don't ever open more than a dozen or so concurrent connections to one site. So this wouldn't do as much as you might think, unless you could get lots of users to stay on your page for a long time.
- maqr 16y agoHow about Flash? I'm pretty sure you can have as many open connections as you want that way.
- cft 16y agonot only that, in Flash you can write a for {} loop that will bombard the target with requests, as long as the movie is running. The ultimate example would be compromising Youtube's SWF player, and using it as a DDOS bot.
- axod 16y agoTrue, although you can probably find all subdomains for the target, or if you're lucky find someone who has setup a DNS wildcard then you'll be able to have a bit more fun and run lots of the requests concurrently. Maybe my 'few hundred a second' was a bit off, idk There is a javascript version of the tool (LOIC), so presumably it's effective enough to be useful.