7 ms·
I don't think that approach is going to work. For any clearly bounded and delineated task, such as a game, the most optimal, lowest energy and lowest cost solut
by simonh 7y ago
I don't think that approach is going to work. For any clearly bounded and delineated task, such as a game, the most optimal, lowest energy and lowest cost solution is not AGI but a custom tuned specialist solver. This is why I don't think Deep Blue or Alphago are paths towards AGI. They are just very highly advanced single-task solvers.
Now Alphago and it's implementation framework are much more sophisticated than Deep Blue. It's actually a framework for making single-task solvers, but that's all. The fact it can make more than one single-task solver doesn't making it general in the sense we mean it in the term AGI. AlphaGo didn't learn the rules of Go. It has no idea what those rules are, it's just been trained through trial and error not to break them. That's not the same thing. It's not approaching chess or Go as an intelligent thinking being, learning the rules and working out their consequences. It's like an image classifier that can identify an apple, but has no idea what an apple is, or even what things are.
To build an AGI we need a way to genuinely model and manipulate objects, concepts and decisions. What's happened in the last few decades is we've skipped past all that hard work, to land on quick solutions to specific problems. That's achieved impressive, valuable results but I don't think it's a path to AGI. We need to go back to the hard problems of “computer models of the fundamental mechanisms of thought.”[0]
[0]https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2013/11/the-man-who-would-teach-machines-to-think/309529/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2013/11/the-man...
- lawlessone 7y agoThe only way i think it can be done is simulated evolution.. be that simulated evolution of neural nets or something else. As others have mentioned here though.. this becomes horrifying if we've created something sentient to kill in games or enslave.
- arethuza 7y agoReverse engineering a human mind would be another approach.
- olalonde 7y agoThis is often overlooked but it's the only approach that is pretty much guaranteed to succeed given enough time. That said, it's also likely that AGI will come about way earlier from another approach (just as planes came before the "robot birds").
- Quarrelsome 7y agoWhile I agree this leads to haunting outcomes. e.g. If we create a successful interface then whats the point of building our own digital pastiches if we can just strap in the real thing?
- Animats 7y agoCheck out OpenWorm. They're trying to reverse engineer the simplest organism with a nervous system, a nematode with 302 neurons. They're making progress, but not very fast. That approach is going to be a long haul.
- loquor 7y ago> simulated evolution Isn't that what genetic algorithms are?
- lawlessone 7y agoyeah, one kind i guess. Or perhaps they cover all kinds?
- codeulike 7y agoI've been thinking for a while that use of AI in games might become a civil rights frontier in about 30 to 50 years or so
- betageek 7y agoTed Chiang wrote an interesting novella, The Lifecycle of Software Objects, about that very subject https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lifecycle_of_Software_Objects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lifecycle_of_Software_Obje...
- sampo 7y agoAnother one is Crystal Nights by Greg Egan. Full text here: https://web.archive.org/web/20090604111226/http://ttapress.com/553/crystal-nights-by-greg-egan/ https://web.archive.org/web/20090604111226/http://ttapress.c...
- marcus_holmes 7y agoOr Iain Banks' take on the subject, in Surface Detail(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surface_Detail https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surface_Detail) edit: wrong book ;)
- state_less 7y agoThe open ended simulations, similar to earth conditions, might general enough to sprout some artificial general intelligence. Put multiple intelligences in a massive multiplayer online world and have them compete for shelter and resources. It's an environment that we know has produced intelligence. It may be a brutal struggle, but perhaps that struggle is important. Perhaps having a simulated tree fall on you is more meaningful than being reaped by some objective function at the end of an epoch.
- simonh 7y agoI think you’re on a potentially productive path, but it took 2 billion years of evolution in a staggeringly vast environment like that to produce results. The question is really how to shortcut that process, but training environments may well have a role to play.
- marcus_holmes 7y agowell, "kill" becomes moot if the code is preserved. Like "killing" another player in a multi-player game. You're not actually killing them.
- bumby 7y agoThis may be a clunky analogy, but is this fundamentally different than a killing a human as long as we keep a record of their DNA sequence? Maintaining the information doesn't seem enough to negate snuffing out the execution of that information
- BjorksEgo 7y agoNot if we persist the state of the mind before we turn them off. Can't do that with humans
- marcus_holmes 7y agoyet
- marcus_holmes 7y agoThe generic AI could be "playing" in a thousand virtual environments at once. Killing one of them doesn't really have a parallel in human life, or ethics. I mean, yes, you killed a sentient being. But if that sentient being has a thousand concurrent lives, then what does "killing" one of those lives even mean? And if it can respawn another identical life in a millisecond, does it even count as killing? I suspect that having sentient virtual entities will provide philosophy and ethics majors a lot of deep thinking room. As it already has for SciFi authors.
- bumby 7y agoWould this opinion change if scientists were able to prove the multiverse theory where there are infinite numbers of "us" living concurrent lives as well?
- have_faith 7y ago> It's like an image classifier that can identify an apple, but has no idea what an apple is Kind of like humans then.
- noir-york 7y agoA child picks up an apple but doesn't know what an apple "is". It doesn't even have the vocabulary to describe it. As adults we know what an apple is because we understand it as a concept, the ideal "apple", and can manipulate the concept into areas way outside the original concept (say, the phrase "apple of my eye").
- sildur 7y agoYes, but you did not manipulate the concept. You did not invent that phrase, but simply learned its meaning. A machine can do that.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bildung 7y agoEvery child reinvents the concept. It wasn't there on birth, and the word and phrases didn't contain it. That's a bit difficult topic to wrap ones head around, but it is critically important to differ between signified (the concept) and signifier (the words etc.). The child develops concepts and is able to create and evaluate inferences, and thus able to understand metaphors etc. The concept is what most AI approaches lack. Googles image search can identify apples, and cherries, and probably can categorize both as fruits, but it can't infer that this probably contains seeds, is a living being etc.
- pingyong 7y agoI think if you have a framework that can produce arbitrary single-task solvers (which AlphaZero can't yet), you would have something indistinguishable from AGI, since communication between single-task solvers is also kinda just a single-task solver. It's certainly not the most efficient way to use our current hardware, and it's not clear to me how big some of these neural nets would have to be, but if we had computers with a trillion times the memory capacity and speed, IMO it'd certainly work on some level.
- simonh 7y agoHow would a single-task solver, or hierarchy of them, go about constructing a conceptual model of a new problem domain? The problem with a solver is it only really goes in a single direction, but when modeling a system you spend a huge amount of time backtracking and eliminating elements that yielded progress at first but then proved to be obstacles to progress later. You also need to be able to rapidly adapt to changing requirements. Imagine playing a game of Chess in which the pieces and rules gradually changed bit by bit until by the end of the game you were playing Go. That's much closer to what real life problems are like and a human child could absolutely do that. They might not be much good at it, but they could absolutely do it even without ever having played either game before just learning as they went. Note to AGI researchers, if your chatbot can't cope with that or a problem like it without any forewarning, don't bother applying for a Turning Test with me on the other side of the teletype.
- marcus_holmes 7y agothey'd do it like we do: by comparing the new situation to previous ones we know about, and applying the model that fits best, and then adapting to results. For humans, the more previous ones we know about, the better, because we have more chance of applying a model that works in the new environment. That's called "experience".
- simonh 7y agoThat’s a very broad, general description of behaviour that doesn’t actually describe an implementation. In fact it could apply to many completely different possible implementations. I suspect though that humans do more than this, that we have a way of either constructing entirely new models from scratch, or of dramatically adapting models to new situations without mere iterative fitting to feedback. Humans are actually capable of reasoning effectively about entirely new ideas, scenarios and problems. We have little to no idea how we do this.
- whack 7y ago> AlphaGo didn't learn the rules of Go. It has no idea what those rules are, it's just been trained through trial and error not to break them. That's not the same thing. It's not approaching chess or Go as an intelligent thinking being, learning the rules and working out their consequences There are indeed some people who learn chess by "reading the manual". Or learn a language by memorizing grammar rules. Or learn how to build a business by studying MBA business theories. There are also tons of other people who do the opposite. They learn by simply doing and observing. I personally have no idea what an "adverb" is, but people seem perfectly happy with the way I write and communicate my thoughts. Would my English skills count as general intelligence, or am I just a pattern-recognition automaton? I won't dispute the pattern-recognition part, but I somehow don't feel like an automaton. I can certainly see the potential upsides of learning some theory and reasoning from first principles. But that seems too high a bar for general intelligence. I would argue that the vast majority of human decisions and actions are made on the basis of pattern recognition, not reasoning from first principles. One last note: "working out their consequences" sounds exactly like a lookahead decision tree
- simonh 7y agoAlphago and it's kind are doing some things that we do, for sure. We do utilise pattern recognition and some of the neurological tools we bring to bear on these problems might look a bit like Alphago. The thing is those are parts of our neurology that have little to do with general intelligence. I think it's becoming clear that they are merely cognitive tools we bring to bear in the service of our higher level general intelligence machinery. In that sense high level Go and Chess players turn themselves into single-task solvers. They're better at bringing that experience and capability to bear in other domains, because they have general intelligence with which to do so, but those specialised capabilities aren't what make them a being with general intelligence. Or if specialising systems are important to general intelligence, it's as just a part of a much broader and more sophisticated set of neurological systems.
- goldenkey 7y agoI can't agree with you. I know many chess players at master and Grand Master level. Look at Bobby Fischer too. Human specialization does not carry over very well to other tasks, only marginally...
- MR4D 7y ago> They are just very highly advanced single-task solvers. What if AGI is just a combination of very highly advanced single-task solvers? I happen to believe that it is an emergent behavior once the complexity gets high enough, so AGI might just be a (large?) collection of AlphaGo solvers connected to different inputs.