4 ms·
I don't think it's about storytelling at all. Star Wars under Disney or Marvel are not examples of good storytelling. What Disney understands is the brand mana
by nabla9 7y ago
I don't think it's about storytelling at all. Star Wars under Disney or Marvel are not examples of good storytelling.
What Disney understands is the brand management. Disney brands are valuable because they are familiar, consistent and safe choices. Disney is the stable food producer in the entertainment business.
Using Scorsese's non-cinema as a label for what Disney does not necessarily bad. First 3 star Wars Movies were cinema. People were surprised, exited and blown away. You can't replicate that again and again. Now Star Wars is just Star Wars. People want stable diet of Star Wars that is just like they remember it with minor variations. It's watered down, but very familiar. They keep all the 'best bits' people like. "I have bad feeling about this", "something something dark side".
- habitue 7y agoBut the article points out that Disney doing that is exactly why Star Wars performance has been lackluster. They're now taking a step back because apparently the public doesn't want a steady drip of Star Wars same-old-same-old
- scarface74 7y agoStar Wars performance “lackluster”? Have you seen the box office returns for them?
- danShumway 7y agoLackluster compared to Disney's expectations. I think it's somewhat absurd too, but part of the point being made in the conversation around this article is that Disney isn't taking risks or making decisions based on creative output -- they're very, very aggressively following market trends. Their first Star Wars release was one of their highest grossing films in something like a decade, but one bad showing from Solo and suddenly Disney is cutting back on yearly releases. They want movies that are safe and predictable. They want to know before they even start production not just that the film will break even, but that it will make a LOT of money. Clearly based on their own statements, they don't feel that confident about a yearly Star Wars release.
- scarface74 7y ago$1.333 Billion for the Last Jedi was below expectations and $2.08 billion was “below expectations”? They made two non trilogy movies. Rogue One was highly rated by both critics and the audience - Solo not so much.
- danShumway 7y agoDon't argue with me, argue with the Disney executives who decided to pull the brakes on their yearly release schedule. Disney has different expectations. If anything, the fact that Disney can look past three high-grossing films and only see the one flop is strong evidence for what people are talking about here. Disney is risk averse, and they look at a 75% success rate as risky.
- scarface74 7y agoThey pull the breaks on their offshoots that’s true. But, one bad release out of 5 isn’t indicative of any trend.